Labour’s mayors have warned they are ready to “stand up” to a Starmer government to pursue better deals on issues such as housing, transport and local council funding.
The directly elected “metro mayors”, already major power brokers in their regions, are planning to act collectively to counter Westminster’s domination of British politics in an intervention they say is needed to kick-start the economy.More than half of England’s population is now represented by a directly elected regional mayor following this month’s local elections, of which all but one – Conservative Ben Houchen in Tees Valley – are held by Labour.Their victories were warmly celebrated by Labour HQ and used by Sir Keir Starmer as evidence of the country’s renewed faith in his party to deliver in office.
But i can reveal that while relations between mayors and the Labour front bench are currently cordial, both sides are gearing up for things to get more tricky after the general election.
As as a poll lead of more than 20 points suggests that, barring major upset, Labour is on course to win power for the first time in 14 years, the mayors are determined that the power should be shared.
Writing exclusively for i, Mayor of West Yorkshire, Tracy Brabin, said they would “act as a collective voice to counter the Westminster and Whitehall-dominated discussion on the action needed to kick-start our national economy”.
Stamer said today that he was expecting “robust conversations” with mayors but warned that they could not expect to “get everything they want”.
“I expect them to push me,” he told i. “But I will have to say no on some things and we will work on other things.”
A Labour insider has said there is already “distrust” between the party’s HQ and some of the mayors.
Brabin is chair of the UK Mayors Group (formerly M10) – a body which has represented the country’s metro majors and London Mayor Sadiq Khan, and will be the vehicle they use to challenge and work with Westminster.Its members already have a history of going against their national leaders and government. The previous Conservative West Midlands mayor, Andy Street, was openly critical of the idea of cancelling HS2 beyond Birmingham as speculation grew that Rishi Sunak was about to axe the line.
And there was a public disagreement between Khan and Starmer over London’s ultra-low emission zone (Ulez). Now with the mayors increasing in number to 12, their potential for collective power and dissent has been stepped up.
If Labour were to win on 4 July, it would find itself dealing with a very different political landscape to when it last held office.Former heartlands in the North and the Midlands are filled with prominent Labour figures such as Andy Burnham, the Mayor of Greater Manchester, who operate outside the whip system and will not be afraid to deviate from the party line.
The mayors’ collective demands will include achieving a long-term single funding settlement for each region, better funding for local councils, and investment to improve public transport.
“As mayors, we know our local places, we are passionate to see our regions thrive, and we know best which policies will help in each of our regions,” Brabin added.
“But we’re also able to work together, putting place before party, reaching across geographic lines and the dividing lines of Westminster, to put trust and confidence back into our politics.”Fellow mayors have echoed the calls in interviews with i.
Labour’s mayors, particularly in the North, have become accustomed to publicly criticising Conservative ministers such as Housing Secretary Michael Gove and Transport Secretary Mark Harper.
Asked if he will be prepared to publicly criticise a potential Labour minister such as deputy leader Angela Rayner or shadow Transport Secretary Louise Haigh; Mayor of South Yorkshire, Oliver Coppard, said: “I definitely think there is a kind of strain or a strand, within the mayoral role which says just place over politics.Former heartlands in the North and the Midlands are filled with prominent Labour figures such as Andy Burnham, the Mayor of Greater Manchester, who operate outside the whip system and will not be afraid to deviate from the party line.
The mayors’ collective demands will include achieving a long-term single funding settlement for each region, better funding for local councils, and investment to improve public transport.
“As mayors, we know our local places, we are passionate to see our regions thrive, and we know best which policies will help in each of our regions,” Brabin added.
“But we’re also able to work together, putting place before party, reaching across geographic lines and the dividing lines of Westminster, to put trust and confidence back into our politics.”
Fellow mayors have echoed the calls in interviews with i.Labour’s mayors, particularly in the North, have become accustomed to publicly criticising Conservative ministers such as Housing Secretary Michael Gove and Transport Secretary Mark Harper.
Asked if he will be prepared to publicly criticise a potential Labour minister such as deputy leader Angela Rayner or shadow Transport Secretary Louise Haigh; Mayor of South Yorkshire, Oliver Coppard, said: “I definitely think there is a kind of strain or a strand, within the mayoral role which says just place over politics.“I think the tone may change a bit, clearly, because I probably come at that with much more of a bias towards understanding that the Labour Party is going try and do the right thing in government for South Yorkshire, versus my perspective on this government.
“But some of that is about being able to have the conversations before the decision is made and all too often in these relationships that I have right now with government ministers, I’m not able to shape the decisions before they are made.”
“I think we do it [criticise Labour] respectfully and I think we say we’re here to stand up for our places.”
Kim McGuiness, Mayor of the North East, said: “There’s a strong voice in the North that wants to push Labour to go further and faster.“We’re having those conversations with the Labour front bench about what we want and need, what powers we can make use of to make a difference, to create opportunity, it shows that we really mean business.
“We’re not always going to agree all the time, there will be differences of opinion, but it’s about everybody round the table being grown up to know that.
“My responsibility is to people before party.”oliticsConservativesLabourLiberal DemocratsBrexitScotlandAnalysis
LATEST3h agoLBC's Iain Dale quits in bid to run as candidate in general election
LATEST4h agoStarmer reveals Labour's five-year plan to clear NHS backlog
LATEST5h agoTories will scrap one in eight 'bad' degrees to fund apprenticeships
‘We will stand up to Starmer,’ Labour mayors warn
EXCLUSIVEEngland's big new regional mayoral power brokers plan to work together to challenge Westminster
Mayor of West Yorkshire Tracy Brabin takes a selfie at a meeting with Labour’s newly expanded team of mayors and the party leadership, including Sir Keir Starmer (Photo: Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire)
By Steve Robson, Hugo Gye
May 27, 2024 2:59 pm(Updated May 28, 2024 10:50 am)
Labour’s mayors have warned they are ready to “stand up” to a Starmer government to pursue better deals on issues such as housing, transport and local council funding.
The directly elected “metro mayors”, already major power brokers in their regions, are planning to act collectively to counter Westminster’s domination of British politics in an intervention they say is needed to kick-start the economy.
More than half of England’s population is now represented by a directly elected regional mayor following this month’s local elections, of which all but one – Conservative Ben Houchen in Tees Valley – are held by Labour.
Their victories were warmly celebrated by Labour HQ and used by Sir Keir Starmer as evidence of the country’s renewed faith in his party to deliver in office.
But i can reveal that while relations between mayors and the Labour front bench are currently cordial, both sides are gearing up for things to get more tricky after the general election.
As as a poll lead of more than 20 points suggests that, barring major upset, Labour is on course to win power for the first time in 14 years, the mayors are determined that the power should be shared.
Writing exclusively for i, Mayor of West Yorkshire, Tracy Brabin, said they would “act as a collective voice to counter the Westminster and Whitehall-dominated discussion on the action needed to kick-start our national economy”.
Stamer said today that he was expecting “robust conversations” with mayors but warned that they could not expect to “get everything they want”.
“I expect them to push me,” he told i. “But I will have to say no on some things and we will work on other things.”
A Labour insider has said there is already “distrust” between the party’s HQ and some of the mayors.
Brabin is chair of the UK Mayors Group (formerly M10) – a body which has represented the country’s metro majors and London Mayor Sadiq Khan, and will be the vehicle they use to challenge and work with Westminster.
WOLVERHAMPTON, UNITED KINGDOM - MAY 13: Mayor of West Yorkshire Tracy Brabin attends a meeting with Labour's mayors at the GTG training centre on May 13, 2024 in Wolverhampton, United Kingdom. The first meeting since local elections outlined the mayor's strategies for enhancing regional growth goals in Labour's devolution agenda. (Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)
Tracy Brabin, second from left, will chair the UK mayors network which aims to speak with a ‘collective voice’ (Photo: Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)
Its members already have a history of going against their national leaders and government. The previous Conservative West Midlands mayor, Andy Street, was openly critical of the idea of cancelling HS2 beyond Birmingham as speculation grew that Rishi Sunak was about to axe the line.
And there was a public disagreement between Khan and Starmer over London’s ultra-low emission zone (Ulez). Now with the mayors increasing in number to 12, their potential for collective power and dissent has been stepped up.
If Labour were to win on 4 July, it would find itself dealing with a very different political landscape to when it last held office.
Former heartlands in the North and the Midlands are filled with prominent Labour figures such as Andy Burnham, the Mayor of Greater Manchester, who operate outside the whip system and will not be afraid to deviate from the party line.
The mayors’ collective demands will include achieving a long-term single funding settlement for each region, better funding for local councils, and investment to improve public transport.
“As mayors, we know our local places, we are passionate to see our regions thrive, and we know best which policies will help in each of our regions,” Brabin added.
“But we’re also able to work together, putting place before party, reaching across geographic lines and the dividing lines of Westminster, to put trust and confidence back into our politics.”
Fellow mayors have echoed the calls in interviews with i.
Labour’s mayors, particularly in the North, have become accustomed to publicly criticising Conservative ministers such as Housing Secretary Michael Gove and Transport Secretary Mark Harper.
Asked if he will be prepared to publicly criticise a potential Labour minister such as deputy leader Angela Rayner or shadow Transport Secretary Louise Haigh; Mayor of South Yorkshire, Oliver Coppard, said: “I definitely think there is a kind of strain or a strand, within the mayoral role which says just place over politics.
WOLVERHAMPTON, UNITED KINGDOM - MAY 13: (L-R) West Midlands mayor Richard Parker, Mayor of Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Nik Johnson, Mayor of London Sadiq Khan, East Midlands Mayor Claire Ward, Mayor of West Yorkshire Tracy Brabin, Mayor of South Yorkshire Oliver Coppard, Deputy Leader Angela Rayner, Metro Mayor of the Liverpool City Region Steve Rotheram, Labour leader Keir Starmer, Mayor of York and North Yorkshire David Skaith, Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves, Mayor of Manchester Andy Burnham, Mayor of the North East Kim McGuinness and Mayor of the West of England Dan Norris pose for a family photo during a meeting at the GTG training centre on May 13, 2024 in Wolverhampton, United Kingdom. The first meeting since local elections outlined the mayor's strategies for enhancing regional growth goals in Labour's devolution agenda. (Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)
Sir Keir Starmer has been warned his Labour mayors will not be afraid to ‘stand up’ to him (Photo: Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)
“I think the tone may change a bit, clearly, because I probably come at that with much more of a bias towards understanding that the Labour Party is going try and do the right thing in government for South Yorkshire, versus my perspective on this government.
“But some of that is about being able to have the conversations before the decision is made and all too often in these relationships that I have right now with government ministers, I’m not able to shape the decisions before they are made.”
“I think we do it [criticise Labour] respectfully and I think we say we’re here to stand up for our places.”
Kim McGuiness, Mayor of the North East, said: “There’s a strong voice in the North that wants to push Labour to go further and faster.
“We’re having those conversations with the Labour front bench about what we want and need, what powers we can make use of to make a difference, to create opportunity, it shows that we really mean business.
“We’re not always going to agree all the time, there will be differences of opinion, but it’s about everybody round the table being grown up to know that.
“My responsibility is to people before party.”
Starmer told i: “I would expect [the mayors] to challenge me, they are there to represent the people who put them into power as mayors, it is their absolute responsibility to fight for all of the people that voted for them – and the people who didn’t vote for them – in the areas that they represent, and I’ve no doubt we will have robust conversations.
“We’ve already started those conversations, but what we will have is a sort of grown-up approach as to what’s possible and what can be done. And you will have a Westminster government, if we were privileged enough to serve, working with our mayors.“And think of the difference that will make – instead of a central government fighting the mayors, trying to create tension – you saw this very acutely, by the way, during the pandemic, if you remember, particularly in Greater Manchester, the government and the mayor at loggerheads – I want to see a government and our mayors working together.”