My late brother in law was in the DWAS in the 90s and often said to me that a great swathe of the membership were convinced that the show belonged to them and nobody else had the right to make any decisions as to how it should return/develop. He felt that it was bordering on the political, with factions manoeuvring for position and almost laughable as a result. Sadly, he died before the 2005 relaunch although he did manage to see the Paul McGann film of which he, like me, wasn't too fond
I don't much care for the phrase "arriviste whovians", not only because I wouldn't dream of using it in conversation, but also because Doctor Who is just a television program and not the intellectual property of any one particular group apart from all its general viewers that is, whatever age they are and in whatever period they started watching it. According to the viewing figures the producers would appear to have got it right. You don't make a program like Dr Who just to appeal to a limited audience, not on that sort of budget you don't!
The Christmas special was a bit stilted IMHO but they were on a hiding to nothing having to follow what is likely to go down as the single most popular episode in the show's history. Parts of it were slow and, like others, I couldn't work out why they bothered with some of the monsters on display but then, you can't please all of the people all the time.
Butts, commiserations on the non-appearance of your old mate once again. I'm sure he'll be along one day to scream "destruction" at you from the idiot box!
If it's any consolation, I was having a pint with Davros at the "Crown and Crossed Sink Plungers" on Christmas Eve and he sent his best wishes, just before he was thrown out for cheating in the festive darts tournament.
Your point about DWAS is probably relevant, indeed members are/were somewhat akin to "train spotters" with regard to nit picking any aspect of the show.
Does Davros use a straw ? And how does he throw darts ?