1. The suggestion (which Neil might indirectly be making, though I can't be certain) that it doesn't matter if the Euston lounge is mediocre because passengers on the most expensive first class tickets (Anytime 1st) will take the next available service which will inevitably be within a few minutes, is not a suggestion I can agree with. There is only an hourly service to Rugby, Stafford, Chester, Runcorn, Liverpool, Preston, Macclesfield and Wolverhampton. Some major destinations there. The frequency is even worse for stations on the Trent Valley, stations west of Wolverhampton, stations west of Chester and selected stations north of Preston. And for Stoke-on-Trent, a passenger missing the xx:20 has a 40 minute wait for the following hour's xx:00. Anytime 1st fares from Euston to any of these stations are very expensive. Passengers purchasing such fares to these destinations deserve a comfortable waiting facility at Euston.
2. The Euston lounge needs to be at least twice its current size; preferably triple. VTWC had the opportunity to expand it (along the balcony and/or onto the ground floor), but chose not to do so. 47271 seems to suggest that the 2015 refurbishment did little to improve the ambience of the lounge, and I agree. The business desks were needed to provide a decent work space; it's a pity this had to be at the expense of the quiet seating area. The Euston lounge is no longer a comfortable place to sit and relax. If I have a long wait before a train, I'll go and read a book in the British Library (open to all, not just first class ticket holders!). If the lounge was larger these compromises would not be needed and there would be sufficient capacity during peak hours.
3. What is worse than not offering what customers expect, is not offering what customers expect and yet advertising the very service you are not offering (in this case, canapes). The small canapes in the attached screenshot of the VTWC website were only ever offered in the Euston lounge between 5pm and 6:30pm on weekdays. It was bad enough that the VTWC website implies they are available in the Edinburgh Waverley and Glasgow Central "lounges" (I struggle to describe the seating area at Glasgow Central as a "lounge"); even worse is continuing to display them on the website even though they haven't been offered in the lounge for at least six months. The canapes don't look special on the website, but they were decent. Are some posters in this thread really suggesting that business passengers on Anytime 1st tickets, about to board an evening meal service, are going to shove twenty canapes into their briefcase or handbag before leaving the lounge? They are hardly going to keep well. They were useful for passengers who were peckish while waiting up to an hour for their evening meal departure.
4. Overall, the Euston first class lounge is better than the Euston standard class waiting room. That's not saying much. At least there are private shower facilities.