• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

"Upgrading" my Railcard...What are my options?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Broken Viking

On Moderation
Joined
23 Oct 2006
Messages
1,666
Location
some place west of France
Hail all! <D
All this recent talk about railcards and validity has reminded me that I need to start looking at my own options for replacing my current YPR. The situation is that my railcard expires in mid May, but with my 26th being in November (And me not being in full-time education) I'm not sure whether I'd be allowed to renew it as normal, given that I'll cease to be valid on age grounds come November.

When trying to gauge other options in relation to my usage of the rails (I travel all over, and would like to have the discount available in as many locations as possible) I've come up with two possible replacements:
  • Family Railcard:
    Like the YPR, this appears to allow discounted travel right across the country for the holder and another 1-3 adults on similar time/ticket restrictions to the YPR. However, one problem seems to be that a child also needs to be travelling with the card holder for the railcard to be valid...Definitely not an option for me as I never intend to have kids.
    I have wondered whether this "Child must travel" requirement extends to actually having a child present, or whether just buying a child ticket alongside my own would be sufficient to validate travel under such a railcard. Can anyone clarify the situation, and whether or not the latter practice would be permitted?
    .
  • Network Railcard:
    This offers the same discount as the YPR in terms of fares available, and (I think) runs to the same time restrictions, but the biggest kick in the teeth for me is the fact that it's restricted to journeys within the old NSE region...Although I can't seem to determine whether that means it's only for journeys wholly within NSE, or if it can be used for journeys that include an NSE section as part of the trip.
    My most regular journey nowadays is FNB -> DBY via WOK, WAT/MYB, HWY, BAN, BMO/BHM and TAM, and if holding a Network Railcard I think I'd be able to obtain the discount for my split tickets between FNB-WOK and WOK-HWY-BMO, meaning I'd only have to pay full fare on the XC leg between Birmingham and Derby (Which is only £3.00 more than I currently pay anyway).
    Can anyone confirm that I'm interpreting the Network Railcard rules and discounts correctly?
Now if there was some kind of "Adult" version of the YPR knocking around (Maybe priced a little higher than the YPR, say £35,-) then my choice would be obvious, given that my current railcard more than pays for itself over the course of a year...But I don't believe that there is any such railcard available. I have tried to investigate whether or not I qualify for a Disabled Persons Railcard due to my disability that prevents me from working, but my situation in that regard seems to fall right into the middle of the grey area - Even the DPR issue office themselves can't seem to work out whether I qualify for one or not! :!:

If anyone can give me a bit of advice on the be(a)st and most appropriate railcard for me to choose once I cease to be valid for a Y-P, then I'd be most greatful. <D
>> Death <<
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Techniquest

Veteran Member
Joined
19 Jun 2005
Messages
21,839
Location
Nowhere Heath
You can renew your Y-P right up to the day before your 26th if that's any help. Only a one year one though.

A Network Railcard will come in handy for your regular journey it would appear, not sure if it allows you to use Virgin from Euston to Birmingham in the ex-NSE area though (never really looked into one).

Can't advise on the Family Railcard, although I'm sure you'd have to have a child present with you.
 

87015

Established Member
Joined
3 Mar 2006
Messages
5,078
Location
GEML/WCML/SR
Get a job on the railway and 'flash the pass' or get a car.

Easier said than done of course.
 

FGWman

Member
Joined
10 Dec 2010
Messages
177
you can buy another railcard the day before your birthday in November which will then be valid fo a full year until the day before your 27th Birthday.

Yes you can split ticket with you Network Railcard but the rule that your train must stop where the tickets split will still apply.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
17,298
A Network Railcard should be available on Virgin Trains services, but will be valid only as far along the line as Milton Keynes Central.

If travelling via High Wycombe, a Network Railcard should be valid as far along the line as Banbury.

As previously mentioned, your train must stop where the tickets split applies, and I believe that for Virgin Trains services calling at Milton Keynes Central, the train would need to be both setting down and picking up passengers (not all VT services calling there actually do both).
 

Wolfie

Established Member
Joined
17 Aug 2010
Messages
7,436
Have had an annual Goldcard, which works as a Network card, for years and it has NEVER been valid on the former Intercity lines eg Virgin, sorry......:cry:
 

matt

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Global Moderator
Joined
30 Jun 2005
Messages
8,876
Location
Rugby
Family Railcard:
Like the YPR, this appears to allow discounted travel right across the country for the holder and another 1-3 adults on similar time/ticket restrictions to the YPR. However, one problem seems to be that a child also needs to be travelling with the card holder for the railcard to be valid...Definitely not an option for me as I never intend to have kids.
I have wondered whether this "Child must travel" requirement extends to actually having a child present, or whether just buying a child ticket alongside my own would be sufficient to validate travel under such a railcard. Can anyone clarify the situation, and whether or not the latter practice would be permitted?

Unsurprisingly you need to have child travel with you.
 

hairyhandedfool

Established Member
Joined
14 Apr 2008
Messages
8,837
....and I believe that for Virgin Trains services calling at Milton Keynes Central, the train would need to be both setting down and picking up passengers (not all VT services calling there actually do both).

The train must call there yes, but there is no requirement to set down and pick up.
--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
....Family Railcard:....

I have wondered whether this "Child must travel" requirement extends to actually having a child present, or whether just buying a child ticket alongside my own would be sufficient to validate travel under such a railcard. Can anyone clarify the situation, and whether or not the latter practice would be permitted?....

You must have a fare paying child with you.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
17,298
The train must call there yes, but there is no requirement to set down and pick up.

Sorry, don't follow. If a Northbound VT train from London Euston is pick up only at Milton Keynes Central, how are you going to be able to use split tickets to travel on that train for the EUS-MKC leg?
 

Flamingo

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2010
Messages
6,806
Hail all!
I have wondered whether this "Child must travel" requirement extends to actually having a child present, or whether just buying a child ticket alongside my own would be sufficient to validate travel under such a railcard. Can anyone clarify the situation, and whether or not the latter practice would be permitted? >> Death <<

Last time I had someone without a family railcard, or child, on a family railcard ticket who was too dumb to take the option of excessing their ticket (£30), or leaving the train when asked, they were nicked, and fined a total of £450.

They did have a child ticket as well.
 

LexyBoy

Established Member
Joined
23 Jan 2009
Messages
4,478
Location
North of the rivers
Unfortunately a Network railcard has much tighter restrictions on it than a YPR. During the week, it can't be used at all before 10.00, and after that it's a £12 minimum fare, so your split tickets may only work at the weekend.

The boundaries of the Network area are shown on the leaflets available at stations, or www.railcard.co.uk/network

incidentally, a friend of mine went to renew his Y-P online just before his 25th, and was given the option of a 3 year one :)
 

MikeWh

Established Member
Associate Staff
Senior Fares Advisor
Joined
15 Jun 2010
Messages
8,582
Location
Crayford
You do have to have a child with you when using the family railcard, but the child does not have to be old enough to need to buy a ticket. You can therefore pay the child rate for a 2-year-old which will entitle the adult(s) to the discounted rate and will usually work out cheaper than not using the railcard for the adult(s) alone.
 

Fred26

Member
Joined
5 Mar 2010
Messages
1,107
You do have to have a child with you when using the family railcard, but the child does not have to be old enough to need to buy a ticket. You can therefore pay the child rate for a 2-year-old which will entitle the adult(s) to the discounted rate and will usually work out cheaper than not using the railcard for the adult(s) alone.

This used to be available on Family Travelcards too, when NXEA did the child portion for £1.

If your current YP runs out in May and you use the railway a lot, I'd renew it then and do it again the day before your birthday. Only do that, however, if you've clearly made your money back from the first transaction.
 

Broken Viking

On Moderation
Joined
23 Oct 2006
Messages
1,666
Location
some place west of France
Many, many thanks for all of the advice so far guys! <D
You can renew your Y-P right up to the day before your 26th if that's any help. Only a one year one though.
you can buy another railcard the day before your birthday in November which will then be valid fo a full year until the day before your 27th Birthday.
If your current YP runs out in May and you use the railway a lot, I'd renew it then and do it again the day before your birthday. Only do that, however, if you've clearly made your money back from the first transaction.
Well, I'm definitely glad to hear that I can renew my current YPR like that then! I know it's the most expensive of the railcards...But I have to say I'm still happy to pay the price for it. The savings I make mean the initial outlay makes perfect sense! :D

I suppose the anniversary of my YPR does throw a spanner in the works for a "just in time" renewal. I originally purchased my first one a few days after my 16th birthday and intended to renew it annually on that date, but since then there have been a couple of renewal lapses lasting a month or so (I knew I wasn't travelling for a while, so decided to hold renewal until the next journey to extend my coverage a bit) and at one point I got 15 months for the price of 12 when renewing because of a promo that was on at the time. :)

Obviously; When May comes around I'll need to renew to keep my current YP benefits going as they exist now, but I'm not so sure if I'll make up £28.00 of savings between that point and just before my 26th. There will be one point immediately after expiry where I won't be able to use the network for about six weeks anyway (Lots of stuff going on then, and no time for bashing) and after that I'll be making about 4-5 trips to Derby along my "usual", plus maybe a couple of trips to West Wales and Staffordshire before my 26th.
Does anyone reckon that for the time between May and November, I might be better off paying full fare on my Derby runs, trying for Advances on the Wales/Staffs ones, and holding off on my YP renewal until November? :)

incidentally, a friend of mine went to renew his Y-P online just before his 25th, and was given the option of a 3 year one :)
If I could get hold of a three-year YPR right now, I'd be really chuffed! Assuming from the posts above that age is only taken into account at time of purchase, YPR start date, and it would indeed be legal for me to do so, then I could get a three year YPR right now and enjoy the benefits right up until I'm 28! :shock:8-)

That said, I doubt that I'd be allowed to purchase one...Not with my D.O.B being clearly visible on my photocard and no doubt registered on the YPR website computer. That said; If I could buy one when my current YP expires, how much would that come to? It might work out cheaper in the long run than buying two standard YPRs in the space of a year even if I was ordered by NR to surrender the three-year railcard on my 27th birthday! <D

A Network Railcard will come in handy for your regular journey it would appear, not sure if it allows you to use Virgin from Euston to Birmingham in the ex-NSE area though
Yes you can split ticket with you Network Railcard but the rule that your train must stop where the tickets split will still apply.
Since discovering the Chiltern route, I tended to stay away from the WCML and Reading -> Brum feeder because of the higher fares charged by VWC and AXC at the time. That said, I've since started considering WCML routes again after discovering that Virgin aren't the only TOC running services between Euston and Liverpool... ;)

I know the idea of me choosing a 350 over a 390 may seem very strange for a speed phreak like myself, but obtaining the lowest fare is my main concern when it comes to choosing rail journeys. When doing WCML runs where speed or enjoyment is a consideration, I'll often buy a London Midland OPR to cover my journey in full, then try for a VES/VDS Advance on Virgin on top - Regarding the cost of the Advance as a "High speed supplement" (Similar to those charged in Europe) which can be used if I make the specific Virgin service, but if I miss it the LM fare will still get me there in the end! 8-)

If travelling via High Wycombe, a Network Railcard should be valid as far along the line as Banbury.
When ye say that, do ye mean that all fares on an NWR have to be "cut" there, or can a through ticket to a further destination be purchased at the NWR discounted rate? :?:

In other words: I'm travelling from Marylebone to Moor St. on a direct Chiltern service, and I'm buying my ticket with a Network Railcard. Which of the following applies?
  • I may buy an individual, direct off-peak return ticket between MYB and BMO which costs 33% less than normal as the NWR discount is applied to the entire journey, or
  • I have to buy two sets of return tickets split at Bicester North; The MYB-BCN return attracting the 33% NWR discount due, and the BCN-BMO return being charged at full fare.
Unfortunately a Network railcard has much tighter restrictions on it than a YPR. During the week, it can't be used at all before 10.00, and after that it's a £12 minimum fare, so your split tickets may only work at the weekend.
Oh dear Gods...I find the minimum fare rules and conditions on the YPR tricky enough to understand and comply properly with! If ye remember some of my older posts, there was one point where I bought a YP CDR from the Guard which I thought was valid for YP discount without minimum fares being applied...But other users here determined that the minimum fare rule did actually apply, and that I should've really bought a full-fare CDR instead! :shock:

Last time I had someone without a family railcard, or child, on a family railcard ticket who was too dumb to take the option of excessing their ticket (£30), or leaving the train when asked, they were nicked, and fined a total of £450. They did have a child ticket as well.
Ahh...Cheers for thy story, Flamingo! That at least eliminates considering the Family Railcard in my case! :)
(Just out of curiosity though, do the rules require that the holder travels with their own children? If not, a Family Railcard might still be worth considering for bashing days where it's possible to have a friends son (Who does like the railways) present. :))

Get a job on the railway and 'flash the pass' or get a car. Easier said than done of course.
Tell me about it...When one of my relatives joined LUL in the 70's, they got a 75% off BR PRIV pass that they've still been allowed to retain and make use of to this day! When I worked for LUL myself a few years ago (It was a very short stay mind...Curse those Bloody Chavs on the apprenticeship!) all I got was a poxy six-zone Oyster card which I was ordered to hand back when I left! :roll::(

Given my situation regarding my disability and my known inability to work in customer facing roles, I fear the chance of me ever getting a job in the railway that I can actually do is extremely slim...Especially seeing that SWT recently had a push for new drivers, which I've gone and missed completely! :shock::sad::cry:
 

Flamingo

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2010
Messages
6,806
(Just out of curiosity though, do the rules require that the holder travels with their own children? If not, a Family Railcard might still be worth considering for bashing days where it's possible to have a friends son (Who does like the railways) present. )
No, it can be anyone's kid. I have considered renting mine out by the hour. <D
 

Deerfold

Veteran Member
Joined
26 Nov 2009
Messages
13,767
Location
Yorkshire
Tell me about it...When one of my relatives joined LUL in the 70's, they got a 75% off BR PRIV pass that they've still been allowed to retain and make use of to this day! When I worked for LUL myself a few years ago (It was a very short stay mind...Curse those Bloody Chavs on the apprenticeship!) all I got was a poxy six-zone Oyster card which I was ordered to hand back when I left! :roll::(

It's not a six zone Oyster - it's all zones right out to 9 (formerly D). I found the ability to get to work from Chalfont & Latimer for nothing came in very useful for 3 months a few years ago.

A colleague's dad gets 75% PRIV and also free travel on many bus sevices in the South East outside London (not just after 0930 which he gets due to age anyway). I think you needed to be emplyed by early 1992 or 1996 to get the 75% and sometime much earlier to get the bus privs.
 

FGWman

Member
Joined
10 Dec 2010
Messages
177
Given my situation regarding my disability and my known inability to work in customer facing roles, I fear the chance of me ever getting a job in the railway that I can actually do is extremely slim...Especially seeing that SWT recently had a push for new drivers, which I've gone and missed completely! :shock::sad::cry:

Without wishing to ask about your disability perhaps you could look at a disabled railcard.
 

Flying Snail

Established Member
Joined
12 Dec 2006
Messages
2,048
When ye say that, do ye mean that all fares on an NWR have to be "cut" there, or can a through ticket to a further destination be purchased at the NWR discounted rate? :?:

In other words: I'm travelling from Marylebone to Moor St. on a direct Chiltern service, and I'm buying my ticket with a Network Railcard. Which of the following applies?
  • I may buy an individual, direct off-peak return ticket between MYB and BMO which costs 33% less than normal as the NWR discount is applied to the entire journey, or
  • I have to buy two sets of return tickets split at Bicester North; The MYB-BCN return attracting the 33% NWR discount due, and the BCN-BMO return being charged at full fare.
Oh dear Gods...I find the minimum fare rules and conditions on the YPR tricky enough to understand and comply properly with! If ye remember some of my older posts, there was one point where I bought a YP CDR from the Guard which I thought was valid for YP discount without minimum fares being applied...But other users here determined that the minimum fare rule did actually apply, and that I should've really bought a full-fare CDR instead! :shock:

Network Railcard discounts only give a fare on Avantix for journeys wholly within the former NSE area so you would have to split at stations within the area and use trains that stop there or change trains.

An interesting (if not at all direct) route from west midlands to London would be to go via Worcester, which at £28.20 SVR £40.90 SOR to London on a NEW (2010 fares) is good value.


Tell me about it...When one of my relatives joined LUL in the 70's, they got a 75% off BR PRIV pass that they've still been allowed to retain and make use of to this day! When I worked for LUL myself a few years ago (It was a very short stay mind...Curse those Bloody Chavs on the apprenticeship!) all I got was a poxy six-zone Oyster card which I was ordered to hand back when I left! :roll::(

Do LU staff not get PRIV cards anymore? I have had one or two presented to me looking for discounts from Dublin Airport. My CIE Priv is still endorsed for LU although I have been told they no longer do Priv rate travelcards.



No, it can be anyone's kid. I have considered renting mine out by the hour. <D

Sounds like a good business opportunity, set up some holding pens in main rail stations and offer chavs free child minding on signing a waiver, tag the brats (good training for their adult life in the criminal justice system) and rent them out to skint long distance travellers along with an app form for a FAM railcard.
 

Flamingo

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2010
Messages
6,806
Sounds like a good business opportunity, set up some holding pens in main rail stations and offer chavs free child minding on signing a waiver, tag the brats (good training for their adult life in the criminal justice system) and rent them out to skint long distance travellers along with an app form for a FAM railcard.

You've thought about this to a frightening depth. You really need to get out more! :lol::lol:
 

Mojo

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
7 Aug 2005
Messages
21,192
Location
0035
It's not a six zone Oyster - it's all zones right out to 9 (formerly D).
Plus Watford Junction!
IA colleague's dad gets 75% PRIV and also free travel on many bus sevices in the South East outside London (not just after 0930 which he gets due to age anyway). I think you needed to be emplyed by early 1992 or 1996 to get the 75% and sometime much earlier to get the bus privs.
Yes, my Mum and dependants get the 75% Priv (issued by TfL) and she also gets the same free staff pass as active staff for Zone 1-9+W. It's only for safeguarded staff, so those employed before BR.

I don't fully remember but you have to be a real old timer to get the ex-London county buses, something like pre-1979!
 

Deerfold

Veteran Member
Joined
26 Nov 2009
Messages
13,767
Location
Yorkshire
Plus Watford Junction!
Yes, my Mum and dependants get the 75% Priv (issued by TfL) and she also gets the same free staff pass as active staff for Zone 1-9+W. It's only for safeguarded staff, so those employed before BR.

I don't fully remember but you have to be a real old timer to get the ex-London county buses, something like pre-1979!

OK, sorry to 9 +W.

I remember the days when Watford was in Zone D and forget it isn't in 9 now. I think to get the out of town buses you have to have been employed pre break-up of London Country Buses which was late 70s if I remember correctly (includes retired staff who are entitled to passes).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top