Both of First's two corporate schemes were more inventive and unique imo, really don't understand the hate for Barbie (besides the Fade variant). Arriva have never had a nice livery, Stagecoach Stripes and Beachball are icons of the bus industry - albeit with Stagecoach i do tend to prefer the specialist liveries (Buchan Xpress, The Lakes, Gold etc).
Don't know about Arriva not having a nice livery. Got to remember that when the first one came in, it replaced a rag tag bunch of pretty average ones.
Agree about the First fades, and quite liked the original willowleaf. However, the First urban is too much faff so replacement panels etc are a nightmare. Not practical and it's not very bright - on a dark day in Bolton, buses just merge into the murk rather than stand out.
Transdev liveries are nice, but i understand the moaning about them as they have became repetitive and it is quite a boring design anyway especially with other operators "borrowing" it.
It's only repetitive if you're some gricer. If you're an average punter in Transdev world, it's because they have a house style.
If you see something similar elsewhere, how will the average punter know? I've travelled on Buses of Somerset and other passengers are always saying how reminiscent it is of the park and ride livery in Norwich - NOT!
Who'd have thought so many eminent graphic designers would inhabit this forum.....