Oooh yeah that is a really good one!
I'm so glad we watched it - it's nuanced, and, even with all those closeups, not a single shot is wasted. And it's realistic. Henry Fonda doesn't make them all change their minds in turn - each one is in charge of their own thoughts about the case, their own opinions - and each one chips something in. These aren't just 12 random characters that discuss a murder, each one is unique yet realistic. These are real people, you feel. You could meet them. Some you wouldn't want to meet. But, what starts off as doubt - even just a gut feeling of doubt - turns into something much larger when everyone adds their own impetus to it. There isn't a laboured verdict based upon the feelings of one individual - it's something they've all contributed to, that
they've created. And it's exceptional.
The filming is very well done indeed, such as the knife moment and at one point where the crowd is literally split by Lee J. Cobb (they're standing in a crowd and then suddenly we get another angle where we see that he's quite isolated in the middle). Speaking of the acting, every juror is worth his salt and hands in a great performance, but I thought that Lee J. Cobb was absolutely brilliant. That final speech is so realistically done, so well done...it really deserves more plaudits.
And all those closeups...you can read their thoughts. They
act as if they're in a hot room - whether they actually are or not doesn't matter, but we believe it's a hot room. It's the nuances - the little things, the darkly comic details - that really make this film spectacular.
So, in short, this is right up there with the best I've seen. Do watch it if you haven't already - if you see it on DVD and it's not hideously pricey, go for it. It truly is one of the best movies of all time, and I highly recommend it.