• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

FCC 321s

Status
Not open for further replies.

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,878
Location
UK
Okay, I'll plead ignorance on the mechanicals - but the 319s that are being refreshed now will be nothing to what is going to happen when they're cascaded.

I'd hope the 313s will be getting THAT work, not what's going on now. Mechanically, they seem pretty sound. Most faults seem to be down to the doors now, as they run in most weather conditions and hardly ever fail on the power switchover.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Skimble19

Established Member
Joined
12 Dec 2009
Messages
1,508
Location
London
Okay, I'll plead ignorance on the mechanicals - but the 319s that are being refreshed now will be nothing to what is going to happen when they're cascaded.

I'd hope the 313s will be getting THAT work, not what's going on now.
As would I. If we're going to be having these NXEMU's running around, then the 313's will soon start to seem very old and non-passenger friendly (if you get my gist, e.g no CIS, lack of DDA compliance etc.) compared to them and the 365's..

Mind you, I'm surprised that the 321's were fitted with CCTV but not CIS, seems odd not to do both at the same time.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,878
Location
UK
The 317/1s were done in two stages as well. CCTV first, then screens - and then, some considerable time after, the software to actually drive the screens!

FCC said that there was no requirement in the franchise to add CIS to the 319s, so they didn't (nor CCTV). FCC has also not added CCTV to the 365s, leaving their flagship (pre 377) fleet lacking in a rather important feature.

I understand grandfather rights not forcing CCTV and CIS to be added, but I am disappointed that the DfT couldn't have made it a requirement that CIS is added to ALL trains by a certain date.

At night, there are always loads of passengers who don't have a clue what station the train is at - and when it's crowded in rush hour, it's always down to other passengers to say 'it's xxx' because they've kept count or can recognise features of the station without seeing the incredibly poorly lit signs.

Talking of which, how expensive would LED/solar illuminated signs for platforms be?
 

mackenzie_blu

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2008
Messages
493
Location
Zone 3 - Northern Line
The 317/1s were done in two stages as well. CCTV first, then screens - and then, some considerable time after, the software to actually drive the screens!

FCC said that there was no requirement in the franchise to add CIS to the 319s, so they didn't (nor CCTV). FCC has also not added CCTV to the 365s, leaving their flagship (pre 377) fleet lacking in a rather important feature.

I understand grandfather rights not forcing CCTV and CIS to be added, but I am disappointed that the DfT couldn't have made it a requirement that CIS is added to ALL trains by a certain date.

At night, there are always loads of passengers who don't have a clue what station the train is at - and when it's crowded in rush hour, it's always down to other passengers to say 'it's xxx' because they've kept count or can recognise features of the station without seeing the incredibly poorly lit signs.

Talking of which, how expensive would LED/solar illuminated signs for platforms be?

The GN does seem to be bad for signage at night. I know when I went up to see an ex last year I was abit worried as I'd never been that far and couldn't make out most stations.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,878
Location
UK
Some stations have the new signs with black/blue text on white background, while others still have white text on the old Wagn-purple backgrounds. Neither are that easy to read (the new ones have smaller text), but the old-Wagn ones are near impossible.

At many stations, the signs aren't underneath platform lights either!
 

ungreat

Member
Joined
11 Nov 2006
Messages
964
Last I heard they were due to be replaced way before the mid 2020's, could of changed though.

Nit pick...can people stop saying "Could of" when its friggin "Could HAVE"!!

Smacks of moron speak..words are not spelled in regional dialect..for example,if I had answered this post in my dialect,it would have(not of) been..

Smacksatwat talk...dunna talk in tha local gob mek it reyt for allon us...

Not everyone has "of" as a sub for "has"...yes,it's picky..but for you wannabe rail employees,the grammar can be the desk rather than the bin....

From a rail employee who might OF not got a job because he might OF been a bit remis with his grammar...it counts,believe me
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top