• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Search results

  1. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    The package needs considering. The components of that package may contribute differently to the overall whole. My view is that a great electric traction package has been put under a mediocre shell, and fitted out poorly. That mediocrity has then been purchased at a premium price, and made...
  2. 3

    Companies That You Expect to Disappear Soon

    It was a “specialist” brand that was harder and harder to tell apart when visiting the shop warehouse. I predict Carphone Warehouse will follow suit before long
  3. 3

    Reform UK discussion

    I’ll be interested to see how this plays. Those directly involved have been pushed to the side, while the actual claim is not about personal enrichment in the form of previous lobbying scandals. Much depends on whether the wider public see it as “Reform don’t think the rules apply to them”, or...
  4. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    No, assess the package based on what we experience
  5. 3

    Companies That You Expect to Disappear Soon

    As did all the electrical retailers. I remember buying a fridge from one (now gone) chain, and the salesman being really pushy about the guarantee until my wife made it very clear that we were happy to self-insure for the failure of a fridge freezer
  6. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    They're still one train to travel in. When it comes to IET, the seating could be fixed but the flaws in the engineering will remain
  7. 3

    Cross-country overcrowding: what could be done?

    I think that would work if reduced to "only if XC get a grip"
  8. 3

    Companies That You Expect to Disappear Soon

    A matter on which I would never go to a tin shed, of any kind. However untrained the Currys staff are, I very much doubt that Comet (or whomever) would know enough about the detail of the specific set-up to be willing to advise, even if they had the general knowledge.
  9. 3

    Why doesn't Ripon have a train line towards Harrogate or York?

    I agree with the general conclusion. However, at a detail level, I can see why there may be advantages on what is now a multiple unit railway of not having to use the eastern exit from Leeds for all services, and instead having some traffic between Leeds and the NE take the Harrogate route.
  10. 3

    Why doesn't Ripon have a train line towards Harrogate or York?

    Comments like this completely undermine my confidence in the other arguments. The line was making a profit if you count the income from the large customers that were a) handled centrally and b) have now closed down. I know advocates are supposed to use the rule of best evidence, but this is...
  11. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    A step is also much more of an issue for mobility when needing to go through a train. The ramp is a better answer, but still a compromise. But level boarding is highly desirable for so many - not just "the disabled".
  12. 3

    Reform UK discussion

    I am proud to be a trustee of an organisation that has such policies and hasn’t needed to go hard on enforcement. But managing change in hearts and minds isn’t always easy, especially in small organisations where the worst offenders may also be key volunteers. Ultimately, the organisation...
  13. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    Personal tastes vary. At 6'6" I find airline seats unbearable at all times, but found the extra thickness of the 745 and 755 seats made for a much more relaxed journey over the IETs that I'm used to. I didn't comment on ride as I sat over the articulated bogie on the Flirts, so didn't get a...
  14. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    At the weekend, I travelled a reasonable distance for the first time on Greater Anglia Flirt units - both a 755 and a 745, and for similar journey times to my normal IEP journey. The difference in comfort was stark - and reinforced my dislike of the IET
  15. 3

    Reform UK discussion

    As a trustee of a volunteer organisation, that policy work is often competing with a myriad of other things, all of which are urgent. And where behaviours are deep rooted, the policy work is only the starting point - changing hearts and minds is a major challenge
  16. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    Probably, though without sight of the spec I’d not want to be dogmatic. But the underlying seats were absolutely a customer choice
  17. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    No contract is ever going to make a manufacturer pay for fixing the consequences of the customer’s own choice
  18. 3

    Why is Edge Hill closed on Sundays?

    But Brunswick was built for a different purpose, serves a different catchment, and makes use of an existing inner suburban corridor. Edge Hill has a fundamentally different context and the gains you suggest would rely upon other very significant changes
  19. 3

    Why did the Wickford recovery take longer than Harrow & Wealdstone in 1952?

    I'm sure it is tied to both cost cutting and the availability of resources. That doesn't alter my central point - with other changes. we've lost significant capacity
  20. 3

    Unpopular opinion: IETs are perfectly fine, for the most part.

    Which, in fairness, is also a comment on the shift in bogie designs to inside framed since the Mk4.

Top