• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Search results

  1. E

    Did Beeching wante to retain track beds on all the lines recommended for closure?

    Looking at the Railways objectively in 1963 it would be hard to avoid the conclusions 1. Car ownership was increasing rapidly and reducing the potential market for passenger rail travel 2. Most freight traffic lost money (very much so in the case of the much missed pickup goods pottering along...
  2. E

    Is needing a ticket before travel obvious?

    And that the information is CORRECT!
  3. E

    Why are people opposed to HS2? (And other HS2 discussion)

    Yes there was! Anyone who knows railway history will be aware of the opposition to rail schemes in the early days. And the question of "money being spent on other things" didn't arise as private investors raised all the money required.
  4. E

    Should people be allowed to stand in 1st class on very crowded services.

    Part of the privilege of wealth is to enjoy the discomfort of those who don't have it.
  5. E

    People locking themselves in the toilet when I need to use it

    A few years ago I told the guard about someone occupying the toilet for half an hour. The guard opened up and found the passenger inside had collapsed after a heart attack. So - always worth reporting once a reasonable length of time has elapsed.
  6. E

    Birmingham to Bradford: Not able to buy extra ticket onboard then threatened with PF at Bradford?

    In the past, I have found people very reluctant to endorse tickets (eg after train cancellations forcing a change of route).
  7. E

    My idea for electric planes instead of high speed rail

    Two words - energy density. Assuming the electric power is stored in a battery, the weight of any such batteries is going to put a severe limit on the number of passengers that can be carried. The energy density of fossil fuels is much higher than for a battery, and yet air taxis, light planes...
  8. E

    What is your controversial railway opinion/idea?

    Indeed - the better comparison is with a shared taxi. And the true cost of motoring should include an element for extra depreciation and wear and tear. Car leasing agreements typically charge 10p a mile for excess mileage.
  9. E

    Leeds to London by coach

    I certainly do have an issue with sitting in a seat for 17 hours without any sort of break. They give cattle in transit more consideration than that!
  10. E

    What if the DfT gave £1 billion a year for electrification?

    I'm looking forward to HST running on third rail :-)
  11. E

    West Coast Railway Company Windermere Services: Strike Breaking?

    Given that Northern would NOT be running trains even if there was no strike, I fail to see how any West Coast driver would be strike breaking.
  12. E

    Incorrect Advice from Virgin Staff at Birmingham New Street

    Re: endorsements - on a previous occasion I was travelling from Warrington to Swindon when there was a problem between Birmingham and Gloucester which meant I had to go via London instead. I doubt very much if I would have got past the platform staff at Paddington if the ticket hadn't been...
  13. E

    Northern's Problems in the North West

    The whole thing would make a classic case study for a "Managing Change" course.
  14. E

    What is your controversial railway opinion/idea?

    Controversial train opinions 1. If all lines closed other than inter city and South Eastern commuter, the UK economy would not be significantly affected. 2. Privatisation has been good for rail staff 3. Government controls railways much more strictly than in BR days 4. Self driving taxis, by...
  15. E

    Northern franchise awarded to Arriva.

    Northern must stay! I'm making a fortune in delay repayments....
  16. E

    'Safeguarding issues' caused by timetable changes

    If we want a summary of what is wrong with the railway industry, this sentence is it.
  17. E

    Has National Express scaled back its services?

    Speaking for my local area - Warrington now has just 2 direct services to London (it used to be 4), and one other service (323 to Cardiff - which incidentally allows you to get to London in the afternoon by changing at Birmingham) when there were 3 or 4 cross country services to...
  18. E

    Data Protection and Revenue Protection

    And, more to the point, is all the passenger is obliged to provide. I suppose the passenger could, if they wish to be helpful, provide extra information to demonstrate the address is valid (eg, show a driving licence) but can't be forced to so so.
  19. E

    Network Rail looking at how it could bring in 24 hour train service

    A little strange. Until a few years ago most lines were very much 24/7 operations, and even now a lot of freight moves at night. But night passenger trains have more or less disappeared from the network, leaving the overnight travel market, limited as it is., to coach companies. I presume the...

Top