• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Search results

  1. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    Can I please be cheeky and re-ask this question as my sense of curiosity is positively burning (and, in fact, I have been asked this by two of my friends) ?
  2. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    I am not sure you can make that comment, as it could also affect the decision whether to bother putting toilets in ore not, for trains into the future. any train And how many in the future ? It's basic business / human nature : if stuff becomes more difficult and/or expensive people try to avoid...
  3. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    Whatever the truth of the matter this is a classic case of the law of unintended consequences. I remember when regulations were introduced that every train with a toilet must have one which is disabled accessible. The latter are bigger and more expensive, so it just encouragd some train...
  4. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    The Times : https://www.thetimes.com/uk/transport/article/rail-replacement-buses-fewer-tz5lbbjqw
  5. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    I thought here were new rules about only busses with defined "acceptable disabled access" were allowed these days ?
  6. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    If the epicentre of the problem was in the Ardwick area can anyone tell me why we were able to get this train pretty much no problem (apart from it being late) ?
  7. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    This is still going on now, that guard (and myself to be fair) was right !
  8. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    In my experience revenue checks, particularly on the train, rarely happen when there is major disruption, the staff would rather just keep their heads down.... To be fair, at Piccadilly today there were loads of staff out and about giving advice, so fair play to them.
  9. Justin Smith

    Trains all at a stand in the Manchester area... (Thursday afternoon 06AUG2026)

    We were travelling to Sheffield, originally from Oxford Rd, and took the decision to walk to Piccadilly despite being told "it'd be no better". For once the Gods were smiling on us and we just had time to get on the 14.48 stopper because it left 36min late ! This goes via Romiley not Stockport...
  10. Justin Smith

    Elsecar heritage railway

    I planned to volunteer for the Elsecar Railway (and the Chesterfield Canal society, or whatever they call themselves now) when I retired, but that won't be for 2 or 3 years ! Hopefully they've restarted by then.....
  11. Justin Smith

    50th anniversary of the Bressingham footplate ban (which was overturned the following year)

    Good news indeed. Though I do remember a few years ago on the SVR asking if I could walk down to the bottom of the platform ramp (at Bridgnorth) to take a picture of the loco (7812) which had just hauled us in, and being told "No" ! Sadly I have never felt the same way about the SVR since.....
  12. Justin Smith

    50th anniversary of the Bressingham footplate ban (which was overturned the following year)

    I think it's both, but personally I think this whole "duty of care" stuff should be scrapped and replaced by the concept of a "reasonable degree of care", plus the notion of personal responsibility has been forgotten in modern society. Everybody seems to expect others, ultimately the state, to...
  13. Justin Smith

    WCR - Jacobite 2026

    I have every sympathy with anyone trying to get away with not complying with idiotic rules.....
  14. Justin Smith

    50th anniversary of the Bressingham footplate ban (which was overturned the following year)

    Or the ambulance chasing lawyers.... There really is no such thing as a free lunch is there ? Some think no win no fee lawyers are a Godsend, but we all pay for that with our increasingly regulated and restricted lives......
  15. Justin Smith

    50th anniversary of the Bressingham footplate ban (which was overturned the following year)

    Just read a fascinating article in my back volume of Railway Magazines (1977), April p180. It shows the 1970s weren't as free as we appear to think, though they came to the right decision in the end.... The potted version was that a Mr C.H. Hewison (Chief Employment Inspector at the Railway...
  16. Justin Smith

    Why did the Bluebell Railway have to pay landfill tax on the material removed from Imberhorne cutting ?

    I'd have thought it's a similar principle as older locos having "grandfather rights" to use the network despite maybe having pollution levels which are not legal these days. It's basically that stuff should not be imposed retrospectively, there's an argument that they effectively retrospectively...
  17. Justin Smith

    Why did the Bluebell Railway have to pay landfill tax on the material removed from Imberhorne cutting ?

    I understand the principle of the landfill tax (though taxing the responsible disposal of waste was always going increase to fly tipping, which it has big time) but I cannot see how it was considered justifiable to tax the landfilling of waste that was already landfilled. It was effectively just...
  18. Justin Smith

    Why did the Bluebell Railway have to pay landfill tax on the material removed from Imberhorne cutting ?

    Bit of a niche question this ! When the Bluebell Railway cleared the Imberhome cutting tip (i.e. waste material that was already landfilled....) why did they have to pay landfill tax on it ? ! ?
  19. Justin Smith

    Price and time saved difference between HS2 at 225mph and 185mph

    Well it seems they were building it to go too fast..... HS2 failings blamed on high-speed focus and political pressure : BBC news Another interesting theory on the net : The central lesson was think slow, act fast - work through the hard planning properly upfront so that when you start...

Top