overthewater
Established Member
- Joined
- 16 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 9,086
They had a contract in West Fife since last year.
-
Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!
Lothian Group discussion (Lothian City, Lothian Country Bus and East Coast Buses)
- Thread starter GusB
- Start date
They had a contract in West Fife since last year.
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R
RailUK Forums
Scotrail344Lad
Member
Keep Seeing One In Bathgate (For St Kentigrens Academy).
Route SCH901 - Lucky Kids, Would imagine the bus would be comfy
Route SCH901 - Lucky Kids, Would imagine the bus would be comfy
CSB0241
Member
They have indeed, yes, though with the new student accommodation at Liberton Dams it makes you wonder if stops will at the very least be instated there further down the line. Reinstating the stops at Hallhead Road could be nice but I wouldn’t bet on it.
Jeezo that must’ve taken you ages, props to you mate.
I’m overall fairly mixed on the changes this time around - definitely some good things but equally there were a few changes that I was a bit taken aback by (especially the new X5 timetable, I’m especially bewildered by that). Don’t particularly envision the 28 being Lothian’s busiest route but the link from the new estates at Gilmerton into town will hopefully go down well. Additionally the 28 provides a good link from the new student accommodation at Ellen’s Glen to Kings Buildings & Bristo Square.
Most of the EastCoast changes are far from anything to write home about, the extension of the Sunday 106 will be nice for people along the A199 corridor. The X5 cuts are extremely surprising to me, the new timetable is abhorrent. I’d personally argue that if anything the X5 & 124 should swap frequencies with one another (think the logic they used when switching the Sunday frequency on the X6 & X7 in Haddington way back yonder, albeit for the full week instead), though that’s a conversation I’ll save for the speculatory thread.
The 72 & X19 change is a bit odd but more than welcome. The X19 extension is a good enough alternative to reinstating the X17, & - as stated prior by another user - makes it stick out a bit more from the X38. I don’t envision many people using the X19 between Kirkliston & Livingston when they can just get the marginally quicker X51, though I’m sure the residents of Winchburgh & Broxburn will enjoy the faster bus into Livingston, even if it means a less frequent service from Winchburgh.
paravostok
Member
Im a little scared regarding the new X19, as it feels like it, the 902, and E19 are now all fighting for the same Livingston Centre - Uphall/Broxburn trunk, and given the X19 and 902 are hourly vs. the E19 every 20 minutes, not sure what this will mean unless the X19 starts doing better
The journey stuff was just done using bustimes API and some excel magic.
Sadly block data is patchy on BusTimes but predictions for the new services based on the available data:
37A 05:47 M-F runs onto a 7 (although I think this will actually be a 24 at 06:49)
37A 05:52 SAT runs onto a 37
37A 05:51 SUN unknown block
37A 06:43 M-F runs onto a 28 at 08:05 from Gilmerton
37A 06:50 SAT unknown but assume 08:11 28 from Gilmerton
37A 06:51 SUN unknown as no service 28
37A 20:20 DAILY comes off a 11 - looks to be the one that ends as a 15 to Elm Row at 17:34
39A 05:54 DAILY runs onto a 5 at 07:02/07:13/06:51 from The Jewel
39A 06:54 DAILY unknown block
39A 20:20 DAILY comes off a 49 ending at Fort Kinnaird at 20:04 on M-F, 20:08 at the Royal on Saturdays but Sundays unsure.
Sadly block data is patchy on BusTimes but predictions for the new services based on the available data:
37A 05:47 M-F runs onto a 7 (although I think this will actually be a 24 at 06:49)
37A 05:52 SAT runs onto a 37
37A 05:51 SUN unknown block
37A 06:43 M-F runs onto a 28 at 08:05 from Gilmerton
37A 06:50 SAT unknown but assume 08:11 28 from Gilmerton
37A 06:51 SUN unknown as no service 28
37A 20:20 DAILY comes off a 11 - looks to be the one that ends as a 15 to Elm Row at 17:34
39A 05:54 DAILY runs onto a 5 at 07:02/07:13/06:51 from The Jewel
39A 06:54 DAILY unknown block
39A 20:20 DAILY comes off a 49 ending at Fort Kinnaird at 20:04 on M-F, 20:08 at the Royal on Saturdays but Sundays unsure.
overthewater
Established Member
- Joined
- 16 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 9,086
The X19 is all stops in Uphall and Broxburn, and no high steps. The 902 only has a few stops, I can't see the 902 lasting long if E19/20 give it a good run for its money.,
It will be more X19 V E19 battle for Broxburn passengers.
Baileygirl
Member
Don't see the E19 taking much traffic from the X19. You need to book the E19 and it's not very easy, they won't stop if you just put your hand out. Don't see it lasting long.
FlybeDash8Q400
Established Member
The E19 is complete overkill anyway. It’s one of a few of Ember’s dafter ideas.
The 902 is probably going to lose out if the E19 sticks. I wouldn’t think the X19 nor the 72 is related in any way to these.
The 902 is probably going to lose out if the E19 sticks. I wouldn’t think the X19 nor the 72 is related in any way to these.
The X19 is an additional 24 mins from the Livingston trunk to Newbridge than the X17. However the X17 was not well used past Broxburn to Livingston.
E19 Vs X19 is irrelevant as Ember don't run to Edinburgh City Centre.
It is only an inservice depot placement to claim the milage back. The full service will be Livingston - Airport - Glasgow - Airport - Livingston and I wouldn't be surprised to see further expansion with other services being added to bring it up to a 20 minute service on both E19 services when more services launch
It is only an inservice depot placement to claim the milage back. The full service will be Livingston - Airport - Glasgow - Airport - Livingston and I wouldn't be surprised to see further expansion with other services being added to bring it up to a 20 minute service on both E19 services when more services launch
overthewater
Established Member
- Joined
- 16 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 9,086
The old First bus service which operate the same route was. Ember is picking up more people but from Livingston bus stance.
Did it operate the same route? I thought it started at the airport. The X17 ran from Edinburgh and gave connections on the A8 direct to Livingston. It appeals to folks in the north of Livingston who don't want to endure the X27/28.
Around the time the X19 was launched the First 25 ran to Edinburgh directly similar to the X17 route, I presume this is the one overthewater is referring to. The X17 was different in that it went through Craigshill before the Fastlink.
If not the 24 was the other but that one went through Pumpherston. Both later became the X24/X25 and lasted for a while longer, including with McGill's (as seen on this map https://images-mcgillsse.passenger-website.com/2022-11/West Lothian and Livingston.pdf ).
Last edited:
overthewater
Established Member
- Joined
- 16 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 9,086
There has been a fast bus to Broxburn for years, at least 25 years, at one points it was the old 651, then it become the 21. Then when the major overhaul took place it was 25 and 600.
Understood. But my comment was about the additional 24 mins because of diverting through Winchburgh. The only First service I know of going through Winchburgh from Livingston was the 600 and would have had similar journey times. The X25 takes a substantially different route to the X19.
I'm not talking about a fast bus to Broxburn. I'm referring to the X17 which was Livingston trunk and then followed X18. The 600 finished at the airport and I don't think the 25 went near Winchburgh.
It's a fair point to make. Myself as someone who used the X17 to get to Livingston as a more convenient option I am not deterred by the increased journey time given the limited choice. Particularly if it is necessary to preserve the other links the X19 already had, which (in my observation) did not perform well. So it could well be the way to save the route in it's entirety. I'm not sure if all users will appreciate the deviated route but having something again after losing the X17/X24/X25 is still a positive development!
I presume regarding Broxburn > Livingston you mean that this is somewhere the X19 may perform better vs the X17 with thanks to the Winchburgh section, even with the increase in journey time for other users?
This is certainly the comment that overthewater was responding too. On the outside it looked like you were saying the X17 didn't perform well here, so the X19 won't either.
Last edited:
651 was a takeover from Nordi’s Dunfermline service. The predecessors to the x24 and x25 was the 12/16 (with the 10 operating a very similar route to the current X18) then the 21/22. I believe they launched around 2000 as I know prior to that if we were going to Corstorphine from Livingston we had to get the 27/28 to Sighthill and walk down.
Having driven the X17, the service was busy at certain times of the day on the Broxburn to Livingston part. A lot of passengers commented that they liked the faster service to Livingston. I feel the Deer Park section might be might busier now that Starbucks, Greggs and McDonald’s are now there. For myself as a Kirkliston resident I’m just glad they haven’t gotten rid of the service, however I do feel this will be last chance saloon. We just need people to use it.
Baileygirl
Member
The X17 went through Pumpherston,Uphall and Broxburm to Edinburgh. It replaced the 287 which only went to Broxburn. First 22 then 21/21A also went through Winchburgh before the 600.
Humberscot
Member
The X19/72 change is interesting, bordering on slightly odd tbh. Am coming at it from a Winchburgh perspective with nearly weekly travel on both. Currently the 72 is well used from Winchburgh to Livingston and is developing good usage with residents having enjoyed the change from every hour to every 45 mins - word was 'this could well be heading for a 30 mins frequency '. The current X19 is not really well utilised outwith peak hours - for us as a family, the fact that if we go into Edinburgh, you usually have to wait for the hourly return is a major factor in choosing the McGills X38 most times which has a half-hourly service. Whilst not perfect, McGills have really upped their game from pre-Covid days and of course the lower ticket price is a factor. The X19 to Edinburgh hasn't really captured the big market for Winchburgh into Edinburgh which is a shame as Winchburgh is growing in population size all the time. In summary it is a bit baffling that one route which is ripe for further growth is being scaled back, whilst another for which there seems little interest is being slightly amended. We will wait to see what comes of these changes.
stevenedin
Established Member
926 has been sold according to bustimes
FlybeDash8Q400
Established Member
It has. It and 11 7900’s currently reside at Seafield.
overthewater
Established Member
- Joined
- 16 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 9,086
Service X19 is now faster to St John Hospital and Designer outlet and restores the service back to what it should have been operating as.
I think long term the X19 will end up being every 30mins to livingston, but the 72 will carry on at the strange 40min freq. The hope was if the 72 did become every 30mins it would extend to Harthill once per hour instead of Fauldhouse.
Baileygirl
Member
The services west of Livingston are still dire with either 40 or hourly service. Like a Sunday all week. Traffic is now horrendous, used to be 15 or 30 minute frequency. Only decent services are the X18, X27 and X28.
zjsptgzxyspks
Member
They could probably try a seasonal timetable on the X5, summer timetable between 1 Apr - 30 Sept being every hour with the last departure from North Berwick around 18:30.
AndrewTaylor95
Member
Doubt they'd extend it to Harthill with it being in North Lanarkshire, be the first Lothian bus in recent times they operated outwith the Lothian area if that was the case, Greenrigg possibly cause it's still West Lothian
overthewater
Established Member
- Joined
- 16 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 9,086
Up at the SVBM over the weekend they were selling off Lothian bus timetable booklets for Fiver, dated 2022. What is the story as to why they were never given out to the public?
Dfatcontroller
Member
Travelshop closed due to COVID perhaps?
LothianBusesPh
Member
What would that have to do with 2022?