Has this been reported to the appropriate people?
It's certainly been reported, but whether an
appropriate person picks up on it is questionable. In my experience reporting problems with rail ticket bookings is futile - they go to someone who I wouldn't trust to open a can of sardines that was already open, and you are fobbed off by them at every opportunity. It takes several attempts to escalate any matter to someone with the slightest bit of understanding of the systems involved.
£80.. You can't as far as i can tell, easily get on a Tube train without a ticket anyway
But a Penalty Fare is for all sorts of honest mistakes (or 'mistakes' that are not honest but are treated as if they were honest), such as:
- Losing your Railcard
- Not realising your Railcard has recently expired
- Travelling overdistance
- Travelling in 1st with a Std ticket when 1st looks identical to Std.
A Penalty Fare is not just a charge made for people who have forgotten to buy a ticket or lost their ticket.
If there is anyone here who has never ever had a ticket/railcard lost or stolen I would say they are extremely lucky.
arent all the stations gated?
No, many stations and many interchanges are not gated. Even if they were gates only ensure a ticket of
some validity (highly variable) at the point of entry/exit.
£80 is fare, after all, i am being fined £95 for not having a ticket between Sheffield and Meadowhall,
Sorry to hear you have been convicted and fined, but at least it's not a recordable offence. I would suggest discussing this in the relevant thread, not here though.
80 pounds for a fare that could normally be as little as 1 or 2 pounds seems excessive and seems more like the level of a fine to me.
It should act as a good deterrent, and make sure people have a ticket before they get on board,
But it's not just about ensuring people have 'a ticket'
before they board, a PF can be issued for any number of reasons and not just because of not having a ticket at the point of entry.
Some people are so scared by Penalty Fares that they are afraid to travel from stations where there are no facilities for them to buy their ticket, or they are afraid of what will happen if they use a different route (for which a fare is available so an excess can be applied) to the one printed on their ticket. PFs do not apply to these scenarios but if you say people will be given a PF if their ticket is not completely valid then most regular customers have no way to know that. It is a deterrent to travel not just a deterrent to travelling without a ticket.
Also it's not a deterrent if tickets are rarely checked. We're far more civilised up North (in general) by having regular checks and no need for Penalty Fares. There is a much greater chance of passengers paying for a valid ticket, but a much lesser chance of passengers paying a ridiculous fare that is as high as some fines for making an honest mistake.