Yes, I agree. Once GBR is set up it will be for them to decide what liveries and overall brands to use. Hopefully before then only a relative handful of trains will have been painted in the GB News livery.I think common sense will eventually come through and they will amend it over time. IMO intercity needs to come back as a separate sector with its own livery
Wind the clock the clock forward and the same conversation would be "no you need a blue train, the blue ones go to London".That’s definitely been the case. Back in the days of SWT I was waiting at Havant station when a Waterloo train (2 x Class 450) rolled in. A woman who had obviously missed the announcement or hadn’t looked at the display hastily asked another passenger ‘is this the Worthing train?’ to which the other passenger replied ‘no, you need a green train, the blue ones go to London’.
Did people whinge about trains being repainted in BR days? Did they whinge about new trains being built/bought (APT aside?)From the sublime Intercity, to the subtleness of Regional Railways, to the pride of Network SouthEast........
.....to this monstrosity![]()
Considering that BR green lingered on a few locomotives until about 1978 I think it would be accepted that a change to GBR livery wont just happen in an instant.Also, it will take that longer to complete the process of colouring in all these trains
Scotland.Is there any european country that has a) one livery for all trains, and b) has a livery consisting so much of their flag. This seems to be so over done and in your face that I just don't understand it
Scotland.
Which will be a shame if it comes to pass.The Inter(7)City trains have a different livery there, though they seem to be suggesting the 222s won't.
I think it was done in house at the DfT to 'save money'. The LNER team would never come up with something as bad as this. Maybe they refined it but... silk purse, sow's ear...I had heard that it was the LNER design team who came up with the livery. How true, I do not know.
Find it strange from an 'optics' point of view that the first rebranded train is in the South of England - yo'd have thought it would make more sense politically to do one elsewhere.
Interesting that you bring Northern up actually. Isn't there a push up there to have trains under the "Bee" branding with that 323 in yellow? How will things like that now work? Are we going to see local mayors fighting with the Government over who controls trains in their areas?GTR is a reasonably decent if basic operation these days. I think rebranding Northern will take rather longer as it would poison the brand.
Interesting that you bring Northern up actually. Isn't there a push up there to have trains under the "Bee" branding with that 323 in yellow? How will things like that now work?
Oh I meant more that there's a perception that the South gets all the attention and cash. So to rebrand a first train in the North of the UK (not necessarily Northern) would make more sense to meGTR is a reasonably decent if basic operation these days. I think rebranding Northern will take rather longer as it would poison the brand.
Was this a public open day kind of event or private?
It was private, the P7 was fenced off and there was security guards - that was as close as I could get (2x zoom)).Was this a public open day kind of event or private?
I do think people who join railway enthusiast type forums are more likely to overblow things like this.
Because the unit is not due for repainting. More money being hosed up the wall on a re-livery that isn't necessary.
See I actually think the base blue is a really nice shade and would look smart as just the base blue with white doors. The red and union-jacking of it ruins it.
The entire livery is vinyl on TPEIncidentally, on the TPE livery I think the pale grey is the base paint coat, with the extra colours applied over it as vinyl due to the livery complexity. The Chiltern Mk5s were done in vinyl as the paint coat would have still been well within warranty. Same with the South Eastern 707s.
Better than the original57301 must be the obvious candidate. Here is a image of the nearest Gemini could come up with it
I do think people who join railway enthusiast type forums are more likely to overblow things like this.
Already got 7 pages on what amounts to discussion of a paint scheme on a railway carriage.
I would find it hard to believe that GBR/DfT etc (probably via consultants/design agencies etc) haven't gone to quite a few focus groups with passengers from all backgrounds and asked their views on it, to get this far, and with enough confidence to make it a political and ministerial announcement. It must therefore have performed reasonably positively with decent data to back it up. I'd also imagine it's been via charities, equality groups etc for their feedback and refinement.
It would also appear from my limited time on this forum, that you are generally quite left leaning - when the mood of the country is shifting massively towards Reform/right of politics - with British or national identity a huge part of that.
A lot of the trains they're sticking it on don't have powerful enough headlights to remove the yellow.Interesting that they are keeping a yellow front. I wonder if that will feature on all trains?