• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

New National Rail Map - Very Wrong

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
3 Mar 2020
Messages
669
Location
Furness
It is possible that the wrong version has been uploaded and gone live.

So we are all fishing round looking for errors and finding them.

It is possible that another version might appear next week. Who knows?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

nwales58

Established Member
Joined
15 Mar 2022
Messages
1,365
Location
notsure
North Wales coast and Cambrian coast request stops are out of date, can’t remember how long ago they changed.
 

Western Sunset

Established Member
Joined
23 Dec 2014
Messages
3,051
Location
Wimborne, Dorset
Southampton Airport Parkway doesn't have the "airport" symbol, though there's a big clue in the station name... As someone mentioned above, is this the wrong edition uploaded?
Actually, I'm unclear as to why the need for two "airport" symbols, as many stations provide an onward link to the local airport, but have not been identified.
 

ACBest

Member
Joined
30 Aug 2011
Messages
346
Location
Lincoln
Lumo and Grand Central are shown as calling at Grantham, which they of course do not!

Also some interesting spellings for Nottingham Express Transit stops, such as Morr Bridge rather than Moor Bridge, butler’s Hill instead of Butler’s Hill and High Road - Central Colleage instead of High Road - Central College. The walking link between Nottingham Station tram stop and Nottingham Railway Station is also missing, despite such links being shown at Bulwell and Hucknall.
 

Flange Squeal

Established Member
Joined
17 Jul 2012
Messages
1,847
They do now and then.
And sometimes GWR have run trains into Waterloo or Euston, but you wouldn’t put those on a map of GWR routes. Something that only happens very infrequently during certain engineering works (or empties running between the yard and their starting station and vice versa which passenger can’t use) isn’t what a passenger needs/wants from a network map. Hence Cross Country don’t show Eastleigh on their route map or timetables, because you could be waiting months/years to catch one of their trains there!
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
17,154
Bowker Yale on Metrolink is a new one on me
As is 'St. Werburg's Road', 'West Wood', 'Cemetry Road' and 'Oldham Kings Street'.

'Barton Dock Road' tram stop has been 'Trafford Palazzo' for a month now.

Didn't know that 'Exchange Square' tram stop was on the East side of Manchester City centre or that the (closed) 'Manchester United FC Halt' station was at the end of its own branch line.
 

Dstock7080

Established Member
Joined
17 Feb 2010
Messages
3,510
Location
West London
No District Line service from Earl’s Court towards Edgware Road.
No District service to Olympia
Many District/Circle joint stations only have one tick, not a circle as shown in other parts.
Blackfriars (LU), missing
Tufnell Park, missing
Kentish Town, missing
 

1D53

Established Member
Joined
2 Apr 2006
Messages
2,885
Noticed that the freight only Heysham to Warrenpoint ferry makes it to the map too - not sure if that's any use to the average rail user.
 

Kite159

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
22,709
Location
West of Andover
Didn't know that 'Exchange Square' tram stop was on the East side of Manchester City centre or that the (closed) 'Manchester United FC Halt' station was at the end of its own branch line
Well technically speaking it was on the branch towards the Trafford Park freight terminal. So passenger network wise it was at the end of a short branch
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
17,154
Well technically speaking it was on the branch towards the Trafford Park freight terminal. So passenger network wise it was at the end of a short branch
That's at may be, but Manchester United FC Halt certainly isn't / wasn't at the end of a mile long branch line, as the map suggests.

Also, isn't / wasn't the station most recently actually known as 'Manchester United Football Ground'?
 

alistairlees

Established Member
Joined
29 Dec 2016
Messages
4,379
I just noticed that Liverpool now has its very own circle line (image shows circular Merseyrail service running Moorfields - Lime Street - Central)
1764498878487.png
 

enginedin

Member
Joined
15 Dec 2020
Messages
473
Location
UK
That's at may be, but Manchester United FC Halt certainly isn't / wasn't at the end of a mile long branch line, as the map suggests.

So on a map representing passenger lines, how would you depict this if not at the end of a branch line?

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

The third side of the triangle to the east of James St does not exist.
oh yes, fair enough, I agree that it looks like you can go from Central to Moorfields. Interestingly, unlike many of the other inaccuracies that people have highlighted, this one isn't shown on the static version of the map
 

Surreytraveller

On Moderation
Joined
21 Oct 2009
Messages
3,905
• Southern are shown as calling at St Denys despite the fact that they no longer call there.

• Southern are shown as not calling at Netley despite the fact that they do call there on a few services and should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as not calling at Faygate despite the fact that they do call there a few times a day and should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Balcombe with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call there two times a week so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Ifield with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Littlehaven with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Horley with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Salfords with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Earlswood with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Anerley with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as calling at Penge West with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southern are shown as operating between Hilsea and Cosham despite the fact that no such services exist.

• Southern are not shown as operating between Hilsea and Bedhampton despite the fact that four trains per hour exist.

• Thameslink are shown as calling at South Croydon with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southeastern are shown as calling at Eynsford despite the fact that they no longer call there.

• Southeastern are shown as calling at Shoreham despite the fact that they no longer call there.

• Southeastern are shown as calling at Higham with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southeastern are shown as calling at Bellingham with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southeastern are shown as calling at Crofton Park with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Southeastern are shown as a regular service line on the Beckenham Junction to New Beckenham curve when in reality they only get a few services a day so should be shown as a limited service line.

• South Western Railway are shown as calling at Bramley despite the fact that none of their services call there.

• South Western Railway are shown as calling at Mortimer despite the fact that none of their services call there.

• South Western Railway are shown as calling at Reading Green Park despite the fact that none of their services call there.

• South Western Railway are shown as calling at Reading West despite the fact that none of their services call there.

• South Western Railway are shown as not calling at Winnersh Triangle despite the fact that all of their trains on that route do call there.

• South Western Railway are shown as not calling at Earley despite the fact that all of their trains on that route do call there.

• South Western Railway are shown as not calling at Warminster despite the fact that all of their trains on that route do call there.

• Gatwick Express should be shown as going via the Redhill line too as a couple of early morning and late evening services are booked that way instead of the Quarry line.

• Croydon Tramlink has Reeves Corner at the wrong location which incorrectly makes it look like trams from Church Street call there when in reality the stop should be placed on the left side of the triangle.

• Docklands Light Railway incorrectly shows trains from Poplar as terminating at Stratford International and trains from Canning Town as terminating at Stratford when in reality it is the opposite way round.

• Cross Country are shown as calling at Eastleigh despite the fact that they no longer call there.

• Greater Anglia are shown as not calling at Seven Kings despite the fact that they do call there on a few services and should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Acton Main Line despite the fact that they no longer call there.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Hanwell despite the fact that they no longer call there.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Ealing Broadway with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Southall with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Hayes & Harlington with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at West Drayton with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Iver with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Langley with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Burnham with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Taplow with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Wanborough with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Winnersh with a regular service symbol despite the fact that they only call a few times a day so should be shown with the limited service symbol.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Winnersh Triangle despite the fact that they do not call there.

• Great Western Railway are shown as calling at Earley despite the fact that they do not call there.

• Heathrow Express are shown as operating between T123 and T4 despite the fact that none of their trains go there.

• Kentish Town station is completely missing on the Thameslink route.

• Kentish Town station is completely missing on the Northern Line route.

• London North Western Railway are shown as not calling at Bushey despite the fact that they do call there regularly.
Thameslink call at South Croydon twice an hour in each direction all day except late evenings (and more frequently during the peaks)
The Three Bridges and East Grinstead to Bedford services call there
 

GN Boy

Member
Joined
8 Dec 2020
Messages
101
Location
England
The map makes out that Thameslink services call at the likes of Alexandra Palace, Welham Green and the such, which of course they do not.
 

PLY2AYS

Member
Joined
26 Mar 2024
Messages
518
Location
Montserrat
It’s also extremely bothersome that annotations for partial/infrequent services, that the text is white and unreadable, even for those who aren’t hard of sight.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
17,154
So on a map representing passenger lines, how would you depict this if not at the end of a branch line?
A very short stub, perhaps? Or better still, by omitting it altogether, it's not as if the station has been in use for almost 8 years now?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top