• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Lothian Group discussion (Lothian City, Lothian Country Bus and East Coast Buses)

Volvodart

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2010
Messages
2,960
Methinks the news from Alexander Dennis today would suggest pressure will be put on local operators to buy their products.

Can see potentially some new Lothian orders going through ADL.

IF they applied for the original Scotzeb2 funding but were unsuccessful, they would have been eligible to join the consortium for the revived Scotzeb2 funding.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

FlybeDash8Q400

Established Member
Joined
26 Jun 2018
Messages
3,026
Location
Edinburgh
Methinks the news from Alexander Dennis today would suggest pressure will be put on local operators to buy their products.

Can see potentially some new Lothian orders going through ADL.

I can only see it if for some reason they started bodying Volvo again. This seems very unlikely given Volvo’s partnership system and ADL’s desire to stick to integrals only.

Political pressure may mount, but that’s no reason for buying what is in my opinion, an inferior product. I can see an E400H style order albeit repeated with E400EV’s, much like 201-215. This would be a one off order, albeit in this case to get the orders rolling.

There’s a wider discussion to be had on tariffs on the Chinese market, which is the biggest reason why we’re in this situation with ADL. It can’t be forgotten how poor ADL has gone too. However, that comes with some major consequences if it was ever decided to go down that route.
 

stevenedin

Established Member
Joined
26 Jul 2021
Messages
1,801
Location
Edinburgh
Just saw 35 with yet again another font change for the number. These buses must hold a record for the amount of times the font is changed on the destination blinds.
 

Bus9120UK

Established Member
Joined
5 Oct 2019
Messages
1,921
Location
Edinburgh
Buses 929-931, 940 and 944 have joined the five 7900s at Newbridge, clearing the line for door's open day. 905/6 have moved inside.
 

Bus9120UK

Established Member
Joined
5 Oct 2019
Messages
1,921
Location
Edinburgh
Unusual to see a single decker on a 44(81).
It's operating one of the various extra scheduled buses today - it ran as a 36 to Ocean Terminal, then as 34s until this evening when it changed to the 44 in the city centre.
Why it's running as a single decker, no clue. Maybe a genuine mistake with it starting as a 36?

The 36 itself isn't extra, but it and another were ran by Longstone buses before the Central buses took over at Ocean Terminal.

I am curious as to why its advertised as purely a Saturday service today, when I've been able to find improved timetables on more than half of the routes. The 26 is an example, which saw 725e running a short run to Levenhall after coming off the 9.
 

Auld reekie

Member
Joined
23 Jun 2018
Messages
452
It's operating one of the various extra scheduled buses today - it ran as a 36 to Ocean Terminal, then as 34s until this evening when it changed to the 44 in the city centre.
Why it's running as a single decker, no clue. Maybe a genuine mistake with it starting as a 36?

The 36 itself isn't extra, but it and another were ran by Longstone buses before the Central buses took over at Ocean Terminal.

I am curious as to why its advertised as purely a Saturday service today, when I've been able to find improved timetables on more than half of the routes. The 26 is an example, which saw 725e running a short run to Levenhall after coming off the 9.
Thanks for that.
 

paravostok

Member
Joined
13 Feb 2025
Messages
87
Location
West Lothian
Unusual to see a single decker on a 44(81).
I've noticed some weird allocations recently, like the 47 moving to mostly Gemini 2s instead of XLB's, which is weird because though I admittedly don't know every route, I don't know the last time a route had a "downgrade" allocation wise.
 

ScotRail158725

Established Member
Joined
27 Nov 2018
Messages
2,668
I've noticed some weird allocations recently, like the 47 moving to mostly Gemini 2s instead of XLB's, which is weird because though I admittedly don't know every route, I don't know the last time a route had a "downgrade" allocation wise.
What would you class as a downgrade though? The 27 isnt admittedly the best route for XLBs the’d be better off on the 37. Or if we were to talk about routes outwith Central the 26 isnt an ideal candidate
 

CSB0241

Member
Joined
22 Apr 2023
Messages
342
Location
Edinburgh, Scotland
Wished I’d been quick enough on the ball to snap a picture, but just earlier today around 4pm I saw an MCV Evotor in all grey with the dest blinds displaying Lothian Motorcoaches passing Riddrie on the M8 Westbound (I presume headed to Volvo Cardonald). It didn’t have any vinyls on it but I could see clearly that it said Lothian Motorcoaches on the dest blinds (in the same font their other coaches have) & it was in the exact same grey as other LMC vehicles so I can only assume vinyls would be applied soon. If anyone else knows anything about this feel free to add on.
 

paravostok

Member
Joined
13 Feb 2025
Messages
87
Location
West Lothian
What would you class as a downgrade though? The 27 isnt admittedly the best route for XLBs the’d be better off on the 37. Or if we were to talk about routes outwith Central the 26 isnt an ideal candidate
I moreso mean the fact that I'm used to the 47 being "nicer" buses, and now its the kind of wimpy feeling gemini 2's obviously it doesn't really mattter that much but I feel like it absolutely changes people's perceptions on a company if the bus they get is a "nice" bus, also unrelated but as someone who really doesn't know much, how likely/when is lothian country expected to receive any kind of variation vehichle wise, i.e. not just gemini 2 and 3's, and whats with the reluctance for single deckers? sometimes their decisions seem completely superfluous
 

Lx008

Member
Joined
16 Jul 2023
Messages
165
Location
Edinburgh
I moreso mean the fact that I'm used to the 47 being "nicer" buses, and now its the kind of wimpy feeling gemini 2's obviously it doesn't really mattter that much but I feel like it absolutely changes people's perceptions on a company if the bus they get is a "nice" bus, also unrelated but as someone who really doesn't know much, how likely/when is lothian country expected to receive any kind of variation vehichle wise, i.e. not just gemini 2 and 3's, and whats with the reluctance for single deckers? sometimes their decisions seem completely superfluous
Why ought they to receive anything other than the Gemini 2/3??

The only other option would be cascades of the E400MMC which is still many years away.
 

scosutsut

Established Member
Joined
1 Jan 2019
Messages
1,225
Location
scosutsut
I moreso mean the fact that I'm used to the 47 being "nicer" buses, and now its the kind of wimpy feeling gemini 2's obviously it doesn't really mattter that much but I feel like it absolutely changes people's perceptions on a company if the bus they get is a "nice" bus, also unrelated but as someone who really doesn't know much, how likely/when is lothian country expected to receive any kind of variation vehichle wise, i.e. not just gemini 2 and 3's, and whats with the reluctance for single deckers? sometimes their decisions seem completely superfluous
There is some logic to it. The less types you have at a garage the less spare parts you need to hold.

If you run a mixed single decker and double decker fleet, there is a danger that singles end up on double boards whenever you have a failure, having an all decker fleet removes that risk.

Lothian runs singles on a bunch of routes and uses the single deck rota to graduate new drivers onto double decker routes. It works.

East Coast Buses have some low bridges to run under, so they have to have a mixed fleet.

Lothian Country have neither issue, so have the simplicity of an all decker fleet. One less headache for their schedulers.

Very few vehicles are route branded across the fleet, and that gives flexibility to move whatever type onto whatever route they want, which they regularly do.
 

LiviCrazy

Member
Joined
6 Oct 2018
Messages
382
Why ought they to receive anything other than the Gemini 2/3??

The only other option would be cascades of the E400MMC which is still many years away.
There is some irony in the fact that Lothian made a thing of it being more modern buses when they entered the area, yet, once again West Lothian, becomes the area for the hand-me-down buses. Yes, they are better maintained than First’s were, but it is still quite ironic that so much of the fleet are some age now (average age of the Lothian Country fleet is nearly 11yo if BusTimes fleet list is right).
 

FlybeDash8Q400

Established Member
Joined
26 Jun 2018
Messages
3,026
Location
Edinburgh
There is some irony in the fact that Lothian made a thing of it being more modern buses when they entered the area, yet, once again West Lothian, becomes the area for the hand-me-down buses. Yes, they are better maintained than First’s were, but it is still quite ironic that so much of the fleet are some age now (average age of the Lothian Country fleet is nearly 11yo if BusTimes fleet list is right).
I think everything still points towards an eventual all Gemini3 fleet. Single body type, only two chassis types. I’d eventually expect ECB to be the same with an all B5TL/Gemini3 fleet, albeit mixed in with Eclipse3’s. I can’t see this realistically being more than 2 years away, 3 at an absolute most.
 
Joined
25 Jan 2022
Messages
1,163
Location
Edinburgh
Wished I’d been quick enough on the ball to snap a picture, but just earlier today around 4pm I saw an MCV Evotor in all grey with the dest blinds displaying Lothian Motorcoaches passing Riddrie on the M8 Westbound (I presume headed to Volvo Cardonald). It didn’t have any vinyls on it but I could see clearly that it said Lothian Motorcoaches on the dest blinds (in the same font their other coaches have) & it was in the exact same grey as other LMC vehicles so I can only assume vinyls would be applied soon. If anyone else knows anything about this feel free to add on.
Lothian have ordered some MCV Evotor B8R coaches. Notably the Temsa MD9 (YJ16 EPC) has been sold to Coast To Coast alongside Eve Mercedes Sprinter EV10 EVE.

Also if it is of note to anyone, new radios coming soon and antennas.
 
Last edited:

Baileygirl

Member
Joined
31 Oct 2019
Messages
316
Location
livingston
There is some irony in the fact that Lothian made a thing of it being more modern buses when they entered the area, yet, once again West Lothian, becomes the area for the hand-me-down buses. Yes, they are better maintained than First’s were, but it is still quite ironic that so much of the fleet are some age now (average age of the Lothian Country fleet is nearly 11yo if BusTimes fleet list is right).
Ye I agree that Lothian were economical with the truth. When they started the X18, there were adverts on the radio and in local papers stating that new buses were coming to West Lothian to operate it, which turned out to be the ex Londons with personal registrations to hide their age.
 

Graeme Duncan

On Moderation
Joined
3 Mar 2018
Messages
222
According to the Lothian buses tracker Bus 49 has been out of service for several months and Bus 50 has been out for several weeks. Are they both having teething problems.
 

stevenedin

Established Member
Joined
26 Jul 2021
Messages
1,801
Location
Edinburgh
Regarding Lothian Country. The state of the network right now makes it hard to put investment but over time it should hopefully grow and become more popular. I think a lot of bus users were scared off and now drive due to the service in recent years but with trust being regained slowly they hopefully will get back to a decent profitable operation.
 
Joined
25 Jan 2022
Messages
1,163
Location
Edinburgh
Regarding Lothian Country. The state of the network right now makes it hard to put investment but over time it should hopefully grow and become more popular. I think a lot of bus users were scared off and now drive due to the service in recent years but with trust being regained slowly they hopefully will get back to a decent profitable operation.
At least it’s not making a loss like East Coast Buses! :lol:
 
Joined
25 Jan 2022
Messages
1,163
Location
Edinburgh
Important Context: They recorded a £41k loss when the group made a £3.3m profit.

Don't rush to put your nan on eBay.
It was a lighthearted comment! ;) I’m sure they wouldn’t heavily invest in East Coast Buses if it was so very concerning.
 
Last edited:

overthewater

Established Member
Joined
16 Apr 2012
Messages
9,160
Lets be fair here 41k is nothing, in the grand scheme of things. As such East coast is pretty much balanced, however It makes me wonder which route within the company is not pulling its weight?
 

scosutsut

Established Member
Joined
1 Jan 2019
Messages
1,225
Location
scosutsut
It was a lighthearted comment! ;) I’m sure they wouldn’t heavily invest in East Coast Buses if it was so very concerning.
Didn't mean to suggest otherwise, just didn't feel like scrolling through the three pages of factless debate it might have otherwise triggered!
Lets be fair here 41k is nothing, in the grand scheme of things. As such East coast is pretty much balanced, however It makes me wonder which route within the company is not pulling its weight?
It'll be interesting to see what effect the route changes have, and also what the margins might be on the tendered work as those will start to come through in future statements.

What is refreshing though is over the last two financial years it's been almost completely cost neutral - and in that time the fleet has been modernised (with more Gemini 3s.)

Which, considering First closed Musselburgh less than 10 years ago, with an absolute wretched dog eared fleet, it's been quite the transformation.

I don't use the services every day, but I'm grateful to have the option!
 

Top