Some stations refuse to issue reservations on the basis that you have to have a ticket. York station, which is normally very good, is among them unfortunately. I have checked with friendly stations such as Machynlleth who confirmed that there is no such rule.
Forcing customers to present tickets causes a nightmare when organising a cycling trip for a group of people, especially if some of them are going to be using railcards, rovers, and will only go on the trip if they can book AP tickets which creates a 'chicken and egg' scenario.
Officially NXEA say you need a reservation on the 'InterCity' service between Norwich [NRW] and London Liverpool St [LST} however according to regular users there are 5 bike spaces and they have never seen them all used and, despite me encouraging them to get reservations for our Norfolk cycle ride along disused lines this week, they refuse to get reservations on the basis that there is no need to do so. I'll have to trust their judgement as regular users, but my advice is always to reserve, where possible.
By the way is anyone reading this interested in joining us on rides along (mostly) disused railway lines? If so please either send me a PM, reply here, or go to UserCP and click Group Membership and apply to join!
142094 - I bet you heard this from EC staff. They have fobbed several people off with the same excuse, maybe there is some truth in it but if there are serial offenders then they should deal with them and not effectively punish all of us! The solution is to go to a more friendly TOC.