• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Tell me FGW are good

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jim

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2005
Messages
3,490
Location
Wick
Made several journies on Saturday, whilst chasing tours/freight:

Start on a good note, I got the 0638 Trowbridge-STJ, got a seat on a pretty rough looking 158, with, O yes, the windows open.

Next I took the 0825 STJ-Bristol TM, which was a 150, not exactly clean and tidy, but we did get some seats.

The next job was to try and do some HST moves (which got abandoned in the end) Firstly we got the 0900 from BTM to Bath, 180102 which was full and standing, and I'm pretty sure it would of turned pax away by Swindon

Next was 0923 Bath Spa - Trowbridge, Full and Standing, but the timekeeping wasn't too bad, got in about 5 late.

After spending some time foting in Trowbridge, we were going to try and go to Bath, we ran for the 1118 (which arrived at 1136) which had a SWT 158 on the front, but it was still wedged, and there was about 15 people left behind. 1144 pulled in, and only just got everyone on, one of those noses against the window jobs!

We decided to get the 1150 to Westbury in the end, which was a roasting 158871, which we got seats on, at each end of the carrige anyway!

Next we took the 1238 to Oldfield Park (to fot a spoooon) and it arrived 2 minutes late, but, you guessed it, FULL AND STANDING. Turned 1 person away at Freshford

The best unit journey of the day, came on the 1421 from Oldfield PK-Bath Spa, which was FIVE coaches, of which we got 3 to our selves, however I must stress that it had come back from Cardiff, after going there 5 car full up earlier on.

On to a HST, formed of extremaly comfertable un-refurbished coaches. 1513 Bath-Chippenham. Obliviousally it was a high speed, so didn't get ticket checked. Arrival was 5 late

Next was 1525 Chippenham - Westbury, being a Melksham line train, it was emptyish, but TWO people got off at Melksham and ONE got on! Local service, so we did get ticket checked, however it was 158816, with, you guessed it, the windows open!

Next journey after foting some HST's, we took the 1632 to Freshford, of which there was a massive FIVE bikes on! 150219 did the trip, getting us in 7 late, of which we got a seat after AVONCLIFF!

Finally 150233 took us to STJ, which we got a TABLE on.

For me though, the day wasn't over, I needed to get back to Trowbridge!

1924 from STJ, arrived at 1948, when I say wedged, I mean it. 150 vice the amended booked 150+153. The muppets operating the 'q' at Cardiff put a FULL LOAD on the train. There was 2 of us at STJ waiting to get on it, and we both did, in the guards door on the 150. Had to stay there to Bristol, where nearly everyone got off, and I got a seat back to Trowbridge.

Someone tell me FGW operate a good service!
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

andel

Member
Joined
8 Feb 2006
Messages
173
FGW operate a good service!

I could repeat him but I don't wanna lie.

OK - truth be told, in peak they operate a dismal service, but off-peak they can be alright... find the hidden quiet gems and you're laughing...
 

djw1981

Established Member
Joined
10 Jul 2007
Messages
2,642
Location
Glasgow
I've never been on one.

Never been on an FGW service, or never been on a good FGW service?


It would appear that whilst FGW can operate the long distance routes fine, their cross country/regional services leave much to be desired.
 

Mintona

Established Member
Joined
8 Jan 2006
Messages
3,592
Location
South West
They can be all right. Taunton - Great Malverns are usually pretty good, apart from the peak 153 from Bristol Parkway to Gloucester I had to endure once. But they're reasonable ;)
 

Mojo

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
7 Aug 2005
Messages
21,190
Location
0035
I'm now a daily commuter on the 0748 RDA-BRI and the 1635 BRI-RDA. Service is quite good, always get a seat and there tends to be enough room when they put a 158 on the service, but it's very busy when a 143 turns up (can't remember what it's like when a 150 shows).

It's often a few mins late because of delays caused with door openings when they're doing tickets or delays on Mainline services. About once a week the train leaves about 7 min late and get's held at Dr Days for the 1644 to CNM to pass.

It's annoying I have to buy my tickets in advance because often the train staff can't do everyone on the 0748 and it's normally a long queue at the barriers. Fares are cheap - £2 rtn, £1.50 sgl or £6 for a week. With my Priv, a week's lot of SDRs work out at £2.50. Even without Priv, that's good value, as the girl that sits next to me says she pays £3 per day for the bus! Also the Car Park at Clifton Down & Filton is free, but it's very expensive at Parkway (£5 weekdays, half price weekends,) given it's an out of town station, that's not very good IMO. Price at Temple Meads is on par with City Centre parking fees.

Train staff are usually friendly, as are some guys in the ticket office. Their compensation scheme for cancellations is also quite good and it's very easy to get a taxi if you're late/train cancelled. I've heard on Central you only get a cab if the next train is more than 90 min away. I've had a cab from FGW with up to half hour to wait! However, cancellations are all too frequent on my line which are 90% of the time caused by rolling stock or staff problems, could do better there.

Trains are infrequent but that's the Council's fault for not hurrying along FGW, but where services are frequent, the effect is lost because of bunching. The new 2tph at LWH and SRD is half hourly going one way, but the other the 2 trains are 10 min apart. Also see Filton Abbey Wood's 4tph, they leave FIT something like xx41, xx45, xx51, xx09.
 

VTDan

Member
Joined
20 Mar 2007
Messages
208
First Great Western are Brilliant!! A few months back every Monday I used to catch a train around 0700?? cant remember exactly, Oxford to Paddington normally an Adelante sometimes a HST. Used to get busy, but always, always it ran to time!

Coming back I used to get a FGW to Cardiff to see some friends, never ever a problem. Only complain I have about FGW now are the leather seats in first class. They're horrid!
 

andel

Member
Joined
8 Feb 2006
Messages
173
FGW are great....


... if compared to travelling on Connex in the 90s. Elsewise, sorry - no.
 

87015

Established Member
Joined
3 Mar 2006
Messages
5,078
Location
GEML/WCML/SR
FGW are great....


... if compared to travelling on Connex in the 90s. Elsewise, sorry - no.
Virgin CrossCountry would also be up there for the "Most Incompetent TOC" award. Operation Princess was bad, but you could argue what came before it was even worse - the bashing was quite good though!
 

devon_metro

Established Member
Joined
11 Oct 2005
Messages
7,715
Location
London
I've never had a problem that is their fault. Its normally a mess up at Reading or some NR cock up!
 

Jim

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2005
Messages
3,490
Location
Wick
I've never had a problem that is their fault. Its normally a mess up at Reading or some NR cock up!


So who's fault is it when they have a shortage of traincrew??

Who's fault is it when the train is short formed??

Who's fault is it when there's no Dispatch Staff??

Who's fault is it they messed up the timetable!
 

omega3

Member
Joined
11 Dec 2006
Messages
42
Location
Ipswich.
FGW are actually awesome.

Mainly because I can travel anywhere on their network for £2.

but they don't mind if you eat all their food trolley in first class.

and they're just great.
 

devon_metro

Established Member
Joined
11 Oct 2005
Messages
7,715
Location
London
So who's fault is it when they have a shortage of traincrew??

Who's fault is it when the train is short formed??

Who's fault is it when there's no Dispatch Staff??

Who's fault is it they messed up the timetable!

Did I say they had occured to me?
 

1D53

Established Member
Joined
2 Apr 2006
Messages
2,892
Only had a couple of experiences with them on the Exeter - Paignton runs where they were quite good (only delayed by TSR's!) and two runs on Pad - Temple Meads and Newport - Padd which were both on time and refurbish First class. Plus Bristol - Newport on a ATW 143 on a FGW service through Severn Tunnel! <D which was absolutely wedged and spent all trip crammed in a footwell chatting to the guard (who was ATW!)
 

Jim

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2005
Messages
3,490
Location
Wick
Did I say they had occured to me?
Nope. But they have to me!
--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
Only had a couple of experiences with them on the Exeter - Paignton runs where they were quite good (only delayed by TSR's!) and two runs on Pad - Temple Meads and Newport - Padd which were both on time and refurbish First class. Plus Bristol - Newport on a ATW 143 on a FGW service through Severn Tunnel! <D which was absolutely wedged and spent all trip crammed in a footwell chatting to the guard (who was ATW!)

Note the difference there, good runs on which HSS operate, but bad runs on Local
 

Mojo

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
7 Aug 2005
Messages
21,190
Location
0035
The 0722 Severn Beach to Temple Meads was CANCELLED yesterday.

I couldn't believe it, as this one's never been cancelled, given it's always so busy.

The info point at Redland was saying "The time is 0740. This station is Redland. From the station forecourt." And then cut off.

I texted Traintracker (25p!) which said the train was cancelled, so told people on the platform. About 30 or so people walked off looking angry, some going home, some towards where the number 8/9 bus stops. A taxi minibus pulled up at about 0755 beeping it's horn, and about 10 or so people gathered round the front door and got on. I am assuming this was the replacement service.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top