• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Swansea district line?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
28 Feb 2017
Messages
240
Hi all,

I’d like to give the Swansea district line a go, from East of Swansea to Llanelli without stopping at Swansea. From a quick search there are such trains, eg

Monday 08 September 2025

22:27Cardiff Central(CDF)


23:38Llanelli(LLE)

But I can only find them at night, are there any in the daytime? And do any stop at Llangennech?

Thanks for the help!
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Kite159

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
22,737
Location
West of Andover
But I can only find them at night, are there any in the daytime? And do any stop at Llangennech
In the current timetable the only use are those at the extremes of the day. You might get lucky with engineering works around Gowerton on a weekend forcing a divert.

The days where there used to be a daytime Fishguard 'Express' service using that line have gone for the time being.
 

70014IronDuke

Established Member
Joined
13 Jun 2015
Messages
4,068
Hi all,

I’d like to give the Swansea district line a go, from East of Swansea to Llanelli without stopping at Swansea. From a quick search there are such trains, eg

Monday 08 September 2025

22:27Cardiff Central(CDF)


23:38Llanelli(LLE)

But I can only find them at night, are there any in the daytime?
Last time I looked, which was probably a year ago, there was at least one morning, daily Carmarthen - Manchester(?) train and I think something mid-day booked via the SDL. Presumably these have been rerouted via Swansea.

And do any stop at Llangennech?

No. Pretty sure that only HoWL trains do that, and so it's been for decades (ever?). If they introduced Port Talbot - Llangennech trains, even one a day, it might become a legal pain to drop them later - parliamentary service and all that legal stuff.
 
Joined
28 Feb 2017
Messages
240
No. Pretty sure that only HoWL trains do that, and so it's been for decades (ever?). If they introduced Port Talbot - Llangennech trains, even one a day, it might become a legal pain to drop them later - parliamentary service and all that legal stuff.

Thanks, that makes sense! It would be pretty odd for them to stop there anyway I guess.
 

GW43125

Established Member
Joined
8 Dec 2014
Messages
2,310
Last time I looked, which was probably a year ago, there was at least one morning, daily Carmarthen - Manchester(?) train and I think something mid-day booked via the SDL. Presumably these have been rerouted via Swansea.



No. Pretty sure that only HoWL trains do that, and so it's been for decades (ever?). If they introduced Port Talbot - Llangennech trains, even one a day, it might become a legal pain to drop them later - parliamentary service and all that legal stuff.
The handy lunchtime Fishguard rare track extravaganza (which also did the avoider at Carmarthen on the way out) ceased when the Swanline was rewritten (December last year?)
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
18,458
Location
Northampton
Isn't there a train from Carmarthen to Manchester via the district line at something like 6am?

If you want anything at a reasonable time than you'll likely need a railtour, some luck with engineering diverts, or to wait for the planned Swansea Bay Metro.
 
Joined
28 Feb 2017
Messages
240
Was that the 'boat train'? I hear the Southern ferry routes have become less important since Brexit so I wonder if there's a connection there?

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Isn't there a train from Carmarthen to Manchester via the district line at something like 6am?

If you want anything at a reasonable time than you'll likely need a railtour, some luck with engineering diverts, or to wait for the planned Swansea Bay Metro.

There is! Not worth the trek to Llanelli station at that hour IMO.
 

GW43125

Established Member
Joined
8 Dec 2014
Messages
2,310
Was that the 'boat train'? I hear the Southern ferry routes have become less important since Brexit so I wonder if there's a connection there?
Still runs, but now starts back from Cardiff and runs the "normal" route to serve Swansea & Carmarthen. Works back to Manchester now too. Has always been a connection at Swansea off the 7.48 (and before that the 7.45) departure from Paddington.
 

Jez

Established Member
Joined
22 Jan 2011
Messages
2,319
Location
Neath
The only time ive done the Swansea District Line was around 2012 when they had a weekend of engineering works West of Swansea and the Manchester's all diverted via the SDL to continue the journey to West Wales.

I did try around 2021/22 catching the Fishguard from Llanelli to Port Talbot but unfortunately on the day it went via Landore. I assume the train crew didnt sign the SDL or there was some other reason. I think that quite often happens now.

It used to be the first and last Manchester from Carmarthen (Mon-Thurs for the evening working only no doubt as Neath and Swansea were busy on a Friday and Saturday night) plus both workings on the Cardiff-Fishguard daytime boat train. Then they amended the timetable to have the boat train start at Swansea on the down journey so it was just the the return to Cardiff. On Sundays I think one of the Manchester/Cardiff-West Wales used to use the SDL around lunchtime. Not sure about a return working.

Currently I believe it is the Manchester service an hour later than it used to be (due to the first Manchester now being booked a MK4 and starting at Swansea) leaving Carmarthen at 0604 and the same evening working that now starts at Cardiff rather than Manchester. I think it still goes via Neath and Swansea on a Friday/Saturday. Unsure about Sundays. But worth checking RTT for any changes.

There are a couple of ECS workings. The evening Swansea-Llanelli booked for a Sprinter/AT set seems to run for the very reason of returning it via the SDL probably to keep train crew up to date. I think there is an early morning ECS as well for a 197 to get it to Llanelli for a Swanline service to Cardiff, again probably for train crew purposes.
 

fishwomp

Established Member
Joined
5 Jan 2020
Messages
1,277
Location
milton keynes
Was that the 'boat train'? I hear the Southern ferry routes have become less important since Brexit so I wonder if there's a connection there?
Unrelated to Brexit - the boat train has been getting worse since the 1990s. Back in the early '90s there were 2 IC125s a day to London from Fishguard. That changed to loco hauled Cardiff only daytime, but the overnighter was still a HST in around 1996. There hasn't been a HST on that service in decades.. just units with sometimes timing incompatible with the ferry :(
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,856
from East of Swansea to Llanelli without stopping at Swansea.
There are actually at least two different routes that can be done, so even if you find a service that is scheduled to do that there's no guarantee it will use the Swansea District Line (SDL). I made use of the Fishguard daytime 'boat train' a number of times during the Arriva Trains Wales franchise, sometimes it did used the SDL, other trips used the avoiding line around the back of Landore depot instead (and thus travelling non-stop through Neath and Gowerton rather than Bynea and Llangennech). A shake up of the timetable by TfW since the 197s entered service has now eliminated most of the odd services that don't fit the standard pattern though I think, so I'd be quite surprised if there are any daytime passenger services avoiding Swansea by either route now.

No. Pretty sure that only HoWL trains do that, and so it's been for decades (ever?). If they introduced Port Talbot - Llangennech trains, even one a day, it might become a legal pain to drop them later - parliamentary service and all that legal stuff.
The only time I can think of when non-HOWL services might have called at Bynea/Llangennech during Arriva's franchise is while the line through Gowerton was closed to replace the bridge and redouble the track (since HOWL services wouldn't have been able to take their normal route into Swansea). Even then, I'm not sure if they did call at all or just used replacement road transport and/or run the HOWL trains to Carmarthen (or terminated short at Llanelli) instead of Swansea.

The handy lunchtime Fishguard rare track extravaganza (which also did the avoider at Carmarthen on the way out) ceased when the Swanline was rewritten (December last year?)
For quite a while, there were two daytime passenger services using the Carmarthen avoider - both westbound and both headed for Fishguard! The 09:40ish arrival in Fishguard (which I think came from Swansea off a Heart Of Wales working) and the lunchtime 'boat train'. Not sure if there's any booked passenger work on the Carmarthen avoider anymore.

Presumably the class 37 and class 50 hauled 'boat train' under Wales & West and early Arriva days (which sadly was either before I'd moved to Wales or before I got into the Welsh rail scene, so I never got to see it for myself) would have ommited Carmarthen in both directions? Or did they run-round in Carmarthen station - is the avoider even passed for passenger use eastbound (I'm aware of occasional railtours into Pembrokeshire, but even those seem to work top & tailed and go into Carmarthen in one direction to turn the train so the steam loco is at the front for more of the trip)?

I did try around 2021/22 catching the Fishguard from Llanelli to Port Talbot but unfortunately on the day it went via Landore. I assume the train crew didnt sign the SDL or there was some other reason. I think that quite often happens now.
Go far enough back in time and the Fishguard 'boat train' didn't stop at Port Talbot either. I'm pretty certain that, for quite some time, Arriva's timetable had it as 10:57 Cardiff Central to Fishguard Harbour, calling only at Llanelli and Whitland, then returning as the 13:30 from Fishguard Harbour to Cheltenham Spa with the only stops before Cardiff being Whitland, Carmarthen and Llanelli before picking up the normal Cheltenham stopper pattern from Cardiff Central. Non-stop between Cardiff and Llanelli both ways - would have been quite something if only the rolling stock had been decent (sadly it was normally booked for a 150, and I think I have a photo or video somewhere when either 150+Pacer combo or a pair of Pacers turned up, though I've no idea if that was as-booked).

Unrelated to Brexit - the boat train has been getting worse since the 1990s. Back in the early '90s there were 2 IC125s a day to London from Fishguard. That changed to loco hauled Cardiff only daytime, but the overnighter was still a HST in around 1996. There hasn't been a HST on that service in decades.. just units with sometimes timing incompatible with the ferry :(
I'm fairly sure the overnight Arriva DMU from Fishguard to Swansea or Cardiff was still in the timetable (sometimes as a bus, possibly on Sundays?) when the extra trains to/from Fishguard were introduced in 2011. Unforuntely, Stena Line withdrew the Lynx (summer-only fast ferry) from Fishguard shortly before, so we never got to see a train service connecting with that; both year-round conventional sailings had rail connections in Fishguard in both directions though (as they did before) - not so much on the Irish side though maybe. Then, around the time of the UK's decision to leave the EU, Stena Line changed the long-standing ferry times. If I recall correctly, that change ultimately resulted in Fishguard losing a Mon-Sat train service (7 each way down to 6) - although I believe an oversight with the franchise spec meant ATW (or was it TfW by then?) were forced to keep running the 01:50 for a while even though the evening ferry was then connecting into the previous evening's last Fishguard to Swansea service instead. I think TfW's lastest timetable shakeup restored 7 trains each way to Fishguard but this was a long-absent mid-afternoon train and the evening/overnight ferry seems to miss the trains in Fishguard now (both ways). I think TfW are now advertising rail-sail tickets for the daytime sailing only in both directions.
 

norbitonflyer

Established Member
Joined
24 Mar 2020
Messages
5,677
Location
SW London
Was that the 'boat train'? I hear the Southern ferry routes have become less important since Brexit so I wonder if there's a connection there?
Unrelated to Brexit - the boat train has been getting worse since the 1990s.
The decline in all boat trains certainly started before Brexit, but the Irish ferries themselves have certainly taken a hit as thereb is less lorry traffic between the UK and ireland. Indeed a lot of lorry traffic between ireland and the continent now uses the longer crossings to northern France rather than using the UK as a land bridge as heretofore, thereby avoiding the time and expense of two customs checks as they leave and re-enter the EU.
 

tiptoptaff

Established Member
Joined
15 Feb 2013
Messages
3,224
The handy lunchtime Fishguard rare track extravaganza (which also did the avoider at Carmarthen on the way out) ceased when the Swanline was rewritten (December last year?)
Did it about 6years ago, on a dogbox. Hellfire! :lol:
 

GW43125

Established Member
Joined
8 Dec 2014
Messages
2,310
Did it about 6years ago, on a dogbox. Hellfire! :lol:
I think the single dogbox is a universal experience!

I went for it at the end of '23, but didn't realise at the time it was booked via Landore on a Saturday (doh!)

It was absolutely heaving on the way back...
 

tiptoptaff

Established Member
Joined
15 Feb 2013
Messages
3,224
I think the single dogbox is a universal experience!

I went for it at the end of '23, but didn't realise at the time it was booked via Landore on a Saturday (doh!)

It was absolutely heaving on the way back...
I bailed at Carmarthen on the way back to do Milford Haven

Ticked off Pembroke the following weekend on a HST

(Come to think of it, maybe it was longer than 6years, I'm getting old! o_O)
 

Jez

Established Member
Joined
22 Jan 2011
Messages
2,319
Location
Neath
Go far enough back in time and the Fishguard 'boat train' didn't stop at Port Talbot either. I'm pretty certain that, for quite some time, Arriva's timetable had it as 10:57 Cardiff Central to Fishguard Harbour, calling only at Llanelli and Whitland, then returning as the 13:30 from Fishguard Harbour to Cheltenham Spa with the only stops before Cardiff being Whitland, Carmarthen and Llanelli before picking up the normal Cheltenham stopper pattern from Cardiff Central. Non-stop between Cardiff and Llanelli both ways - would have been quite something if only the rolling stock had been decent (sadly it was normally booked for a 150, and I think I have a photo or video somewhere when either 150+Pacer combo or a pair of Pacers turned up, though I've no idea if that was as-booked).
Yes thats correct, thanks for reminding me! I remember now, it was non stop between Cardiff and Llanelli in both directions. Then they added Bridgend and then Port Talbot (certainly on the return working). The destination on the return working seemed to vary between Cardiff and Cheltenham depending on the timetable at the time. I also remember the down journey started at Newport for a while due to a morning Swanline terminating there and this was the return working. It may have been booked as a 158 during this time as i seem to remember 3 of them would work various services in the South over 3 days and then return North. One stabled at Carmarthen, one at Canton and 1 returned North each night. I seem to remember the Carmarthen starter did Pembroke Dock in the morning then Swanline then the boat train then possibly to Cheltenham before being at Canton.

I think what it was actually booked for again varied from timetable change to timetable change. I remember it was booked as a 158 but then due to a shortage was switched to a 150 as the Cambrian took priority for the 158s. 158s were much more appropriate than a 150 or pacer given the service was limited stop. Even when it was booked as a 158 it very often was a 150 that turned up.

Now of course the daytime 'boat train' is part of the Fishguard/Milford to Manchester pattern not a stand alone service any more sadly.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Not sure if there's any booked passenger work on the Carmarthen avoider anymore.
I dont think there is but not 100% sure. Its possible train crew could remain competent on that section with shunt moves around Carmarthen when various units are stabled overnight?
 
Last edited:

fishwomp

Established Member
Joined
5 Jan 2020
Messages
1,277
Location
milton keynes
The handy lunchtime Fishguard rare track extravaganza (which also did the avoider at Carmarthen on the way out) ceased when the Swanline was rewritten (December last year?)
In the 90's the day time service would also do the Leckwith loop round the other side of Cardiff Canton. Happy days, the summers of rare track with class 50s, or 37s.
 

Gloster

Veteran Member
Joined
4 Sep 2020
Messages
12,956
Location
Up the creek
Back in the early 1980s the Down Boat Train was a DMU from Cardiff which was non-stop to Llanelli via the Swansea District Line. In those days it had to wait in the loop at Goodwick until the Up cleared the platform: this could be a lengthy wait if customs and immigration were doing a lot of checks.

I think that the Up one ran via the Landore Curve except on Sundays as on other days it called Neath. I only caught it in a Sunday, which meant a run via the Rhubarb and Hawkeridge Curves and the Berks and Hants to Reading, and then back down to Exeter.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,856
You might get lucky with engineering works around Gowerton on a weekend forcing a divert.
The GWR journey planner is currently showing the following warning on services between Carmarthen and Cardiff in the next few weeks:
"If you are travelling in the Swansea area between Monday 26 January and Sunday 8 February, please be aware that engineering work is taking place on the outskirts of Swansea. There will be rail replacement buses in operation and timetable amendments. Check before you travel"
I make that a 14 day closure; rather more than a weekend. However, unlike when the Loughor viaduct was renewed (when, if I recall correctly, Arriva ran an hourly train service between Carmarthen and Cardiff (diverted via the Swansea District Line) throughout the day), this time the diverts appear to be limited to a handful of early-morning and late-evening workings. Nothing but replacement road transport between Llanelli and Port Talbot during the middle of the day - are the class 197s not cleared for the diversionary route and only 15x are available for diverted services?

GWR services also appear to be withdrawn this time around (terminating at Port Talbot Parkway), so presumably the work is further east than Gowerton (I can't remember for sure, but assume PAD-SWA was unaffected during the Loughor viaduct works), but does anyone know what exactly the engineering works "on the outskirts of Swansea" are on this occasion?
 

Kite159

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
22,737
Location
West of Andover
For the 2nd February at least it seems the engineering works is between Swansea & Neath as trains are running into Swansea from the West with a couple trains in the morning going via the District line.

197s are cleared that way.
 

Ian Hardy

Member
Joined
18 Nov 2009
Messages
450
GWR services also appear to be withdrawn this time around (terminating at Port Talbot Parkway), so presumably the work is further east than Gowerton (I can't remember for sure, but assume PAD-SWA was unaffected during the Loughor viaduct works), but does anyone know what exactly the engineering works "on the outskirts of Swansea" are on this occasion?
The Network Rail press release https://www.networkrailmediacentre....urbishment-works-take-place-in-swansea-area-1 has this:
From Monday 26 January to Friday 6 February, and again all day on Sunday 8 February, engineers will be working around the clock to renew the railway near Landore Viaduct, close to Swansea Football Stadium. To allow the work to be carried out safely, the railway will be closed between Port Talbot Parkway and Swansea during these periods.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top