• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Reuse of Mk2 and Mk3 Sleeper stock

Status
Not open for further replies.

PYROOGOBBO

Member
Joined
31 May 2015
Messages
152
Location
Central scotland
Heyo!, i'm wondering. if any of the MK2 MK3 sleeper stock that is being sold could maybe be used as a once on occasion sleeper service?, just thinking of maybe an inverness to london christmas eve sleeper maybe using 37's and 47's, Might even be handy for people wanting to travel at night to visit family south or north for christmas, or maybe for other times of year.

Would be nice to see the 89 Joining in too. Say, Double headed 37's or a 37 - 47 Multiple takes some MK2 and MK3's down from inverness to edinburgh, then they all get hooked upto a 89 at Edinburgh for the travel down to london
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

JonathanH

Veteran Member
Joined
29 May 2011
Messages
23,397
Heyo!, i'm wondering. if any of the MK2 MK3 sleeper stock that is being sold could maybe be used as a once on occasion sleeper service?, just thinking of maybe an inverness to london christmas eve sleeper maybe using 37's and 47's, Might even be handy for people wanting to travel at night to visit family south or north for christmas, or maybe for other times of year.

Would be nice to see the 89 Joining in too. Say, Double headed 37's or a 37 - 47 Multiple takes some MK2 and MK3's down from inverness to edinburgh, then they all get hooked upto a 89 at Edinburgh for the travel down to london

Would be really cute maybe as a charity service? like all profits/funds goes to say a homeless charity or that for christmas c:


also decorate it with some lights like the canadian christmas train so it gets people out to see it.
Maybe have a word with Locomotive Services Limited who appear to have bought a set of Mark 3 sleepers. It won't be cheap to travel on the services you suggest. Generally keeping rolling stock just for 'fancy' or 'occasional' services isn't very economic.

If money is to go to charity, that would need to be loaded into the ticket price.

This thread explains where the sleeping coaches have gone following their sale. They aren't just lying around ready to be used as you suggest.
 

Speed43125

Member
Joined
20 Jul 2019
Messages
1,172
Location
Dunblane
I suppose there are some Mk.3 SLEPs lying around on various heritage lines as mess rooms/rest quarters. I suppose it wouldn't be completely impossible to get a bunch of them together. I was also assuming LSL were planning to create a luxury rail tour train incorporating their sleeping cars, I'm not sure if that is what you're imagining?
How up market would this service be? It would presumably have to cost quite a lot of money to make work, LSL seem to be targeting quite a luxurious niche, my impression is your idea is meant to be relatively cheap, rather than a Belmond Royal Scotsman type affair.
There are no scheduled sleepers that run on Saturday night/Sunday morning, so I suppose you could run down on a similar timetable to the Inverness Highlander. To be honest, this sounds a little like the sort of thing LSL would have a bash at.
 

DB

Guest
Joined
18 Nov 2009
Messages
5,036
I suppose there are some Mk.3 SLEPs lying around on various heritage lines as mess rooms/rest quarters. I suppose it wouldn't be completely impossible to get a bunch of them together.

Quite a few - some long-standing, some recent. The longer standing ones in some cases are on accommodatiom bogies as the original ones were removed before sale. Some won't have moved for years and may well not be in a state where they could be returned to mainline use.

It remains to be seen what LSL are going to use theirs for (no doubt they have plans). The Royal Scotsman has a couple of Mk3 sleepers in it (part generator vans, part passenger cabins). There are also two with the Northern Belle but I believe they are staff accommodation.

Can't really see that, given the low occupancy of sleepers, it would be viable to use them on privately-operated trains for anything other than high-end tours. The ecomonics wouldn't stack up for anything cheaper.
 

Philip Phlopp

Established Member
Joined
31 May 2015
Messages
3,003
Heyo!, i'm wondering. if any of the MK2 MK3 sleeper stock that is being sold could maybe be used as a once on occasion sleeper service?, just thinking of maybe an inverness to london christmas eve sleeper maybe using 37's and 47's, Might even be handy for people wanting to travel at night to visit family south or north for christmas, or maybe for other times of year.

Would be nice to see the 89 Joining in too. Say, Double headed 37's or a 37 - 47 Multiple takes some MK2 and MK3's down from inverness to edinburgh, then they all get hooked upto a 89 at Edinburgh for the travel down to london

Would be really cute maybe as a charity service? like all profits/funds goes to say a homeless charity or that for christmas c:


also decorate it with some lights like the canadian christmas train so it gets people out to see it.

Charity service ? Is that the same as a basket case.

The enthusiasm is admirable, but reality here is going to land you with a multi million pound bill before your sleeper service has turned a wheel in revenue service. The Mark 3 stock is life expired, rotten and will need significant corrosion repairs (as is normal for any Mark 3 vehicle now), the bogies and wheelsets will be coming up for refurbishment/replacement, the electrics on a Mark 3 loco hauled vehicle are well known weak points, particularly the motor-alternator sets which turn 1000V ETS into 415V three-phase and were already pretty getting difficult to maintain in service, there are disability access requirements which will make regular passenger service with slam-door stock problematic and there are safety, training and minimum staffing requirements for sleeper vehicles which will need to be undertaken before any passenger use is permitted by ORR.

Class 37/4s, even in double-headed formation, aren't fitted with suitable ETS equipment (wiring, mainly) to power a lengthy rake of vehicles. Class 47s and Class 89s are problematic from a safety case perspective, who still has traction and route knowledge on them. It suddenly needs additional staff to combine traction and route knowledge.

It's OK for the likes of LSL who if they refurbish the vehicles to a high standard, and using existing assets, facilities and staff, can make a business case for a higher end luxury touring experience, but to make the sums work on these sorts of trains, we're looking at £2,500 tickets, not £25 tickets.

And as I've pointed out elsewhere, sleepers lose money. Serco Caledonian Sleeper is only covering around half of their total costs through ticket and catering sales, the rest comes from the Scottish Government.
 

Speed43125

Member
Joined
20 Jul 2019
Messages
1,172
Location
Dunblane
Quite a few - some long-standing, some recent. The longer standing ones in some cases are on accommodatiom bogies as the original ones were removed before sale. Some won't have moved for years and may well not be in a state where they could be returned to mainline use.
I agree, I was imagining the odd Ex- Caly sleeper Mk.3 which will have arrived relatively recently, but as you say, none of have really been maintained to anything resembling mainline standard.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top