• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Paddington to Llanelli - "The St David"

Status
Not open for further replies.

Taunton

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Aug 2013
Messages
12,303
Had to make a day return trip from London to Llanelli, an interesting series of experiences.

Aware that the fares out on the 7.45 in the morning, and return in the evening, are very different, and beyond the capabilities of the automatic ticket machines to handle, I looked in at the Paddington ticket office to find a gargantuan queue and few windows open.

Back to the ticket machine to buy just a single at £124, noticing that indeed all it offered as a return was 2 x £124. I'll get the cheaper ticket on the way back - it will be revenue to Arriva instead of First.

At 7.35 still nothing on the indicator, the train was being "prepared". In fact its platform appeared only 7 minutes before departure, if you weren't glaring at the screens constantly, which flick between Page 1 and Page 2 almost faster than you can read them, you would miss it. Oh for the days when you could board at Paddington 20-30 minutes before departure. Anyway, in I get along with others.

Then here comes the reservations clerk with the seat reservations cards, which of course some people have sat in now - the cards are just pushed in behind their heads without a word being said. Also in hand were the large sticky labels for "The St David", which name this train bizarrely has added, presumably to justify the highest fares of the day. These were plonked across the front windows of the coach at a jaunty angle, where they half peeled off after a few minutes, and flapped in the breeze (what breeze? - see later).

The front rows were taken, so I sit behind, where I find the seat pitch is nowadays so tight that I can't open my laptop enough to see the screen. A recent HS2 document said that a justification was that "business travellers can work on the train". This must have been written by someone who remembers those old British Rail TV ads of the 1980s which showed how much space you had - matey, all that has gone now.

The laptop won't be much use anyway because none of the 13A power sockets, below the seat ahead or for the lucky few table occupants alongside the table, were working. Nor was the door at the front of the saloon which was jammed in the open position, allowing all the noise and draughts from the vestibule area to blow through. A bit more of the "preparing", this time aspects from overnight in the depot, not done.

Anyway, we're off, full speed to Reading East where we stop at a signal outside the station for a good 5 minutes. There is of course a PA announcement - that we're stopped at a signal outside Reading.

You may notice a lack of any mention of a refreshment trolley, and indeed this particular lack continued all the way to Swansea. Previously on this route there has been a service of this, but apparently a train even as grand as "The St David" doesn't run to this any more.

After the Swindon stop progress is a good deal colder and noisier until I go forward and close the door droplights left open - remember that jammed vestibule door.

After the Bristol Parkway stop there's a tight single line tunnel a mile or so beyond. The open (again) door droplights and the jammed vestibule door combine with an air draught (well, not all air, quite a bit of diesel fumes as well) to blast down the coach, nearly ripping the "St David" labels off the windows, and making all the antimacassars do a merry dance, until a passenger (guess who) once again goes forward again and shuts the windows.

We hop along through the Welsh stops, making distinctly slower progress than before. You can't beat the train by the M4 from London to Cardiff, but you certainly can from London all the way to Llanelli. I occupy the time with, inevitably, going down to the doors after each stop. I did notice the conductor no longer closes these when walking through. I wonder why the change of policy.

So, into Swansea station, where I get out and wait for the connection, which has actually followed us closely all the way from Newport. This is an Arriva Class 175, just two coaches but not that full. Amazingly, the seat pitch in this is better, to the extent that I can open my laptop adequately, despite just a 15 minute journey remaining. What's more, a fully-stocked refreshment trolley shortly crashes through from the next coach. What a shame I'm getting off in a few minutes. Plus the saloon is fully weatherproofed. Who would believe that a DMU would have a better ambience than an Inter City train, supposedly recently refurbished, with a grand name?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Temple Meads

Established Member
Joined
2 Sep 2010
Messages
2,283
Location
Devon
Sorry if I'm wrong, but are you one of these people who just like to complain about FGW as much as possible?

As I cannot find a single positive thing about them there...
 

jnjkerbin

Member
Joined
25 Apr 2012
Messages
842
Location
Down south
Would you rather they put out all the labels and then started the boarding process so that the train departed late? Presumeably, the delay was due to the previous service arriving late.

The fault with the interconnecting door may not have been a fault. The doors work using a pressure pad in the floor either side of the door. If a piece of luggage is protruding even slightly from the rack, then this can jam the door open.

However, I must agree on the generally fantastic level of service from ATW last time I was in the area.
 

CC 72100

Established Member
Joined
23 Jan 2012
Messages
3,851
And also there is a good reason for the lack of trolley... Hear the announcements about the express cafe? It's there instead.
 

Greenback

Emeritus Moderator
Joined
9 Aug 2009
Messages
15,268
Location
Llanelli
Just a few thoughts...

1. There hasn't been a refreshment trolley on FGW HST's for many years
2. The slower speed after Cardiff is due to the geographical nature of both the terrain and the line. The same phenomenon occurs after Exeter when heading down to the west country
3. I have never noticed a tight single line tunnel after Bristol parkway on any of my many journeys along this route
4. I do find the ATW 175's far more comfortable than the FGW HST's
5. I do not like the HST's. FGW is catering to the short distance commuters at the expense of the long distance traveller.
6. Unfortunately it is all too common to be held outside Reading in both directions. I hope the remodelling will prevent this once completed
7. I hope you were impressed with the quality of Llanelli, and visited one of the charming local cafes during your visit
 

heart-of-wessex

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2005
Messages
3,087
Location
Trowbridge
3. I have never noticed a tight single line tunnel after Bristol parkway on any of my many journeys along this route

You probably haven't noticed being in a dark tunnel, but I can assure you that you would have passed through it every time. Patchway (round the corner from Parkway) is a single bore tunnel on the up/down line, the reason is the line splits (you may notice for example that as you leave the tunnel heading to Cardiff, the Up line is a few meters below)
 

LexyBoy

Established Member
Joined
23 Jan 2009
Messages
4,478
Location
North of the rivers
You must have a massive laptop; I could work quite happily on my large-screened one. Did you notice the pull-out support on the tables? It's there for exactly this reason. As for the breeze (vestibule doors not closing) and lack of power - try moving to another coach.

Most of your complaints seem to be that the trains are old - hardly FGW's fault. If you had got a Sprinter or Pacer operated service in Wales you might have a different opinion!

It can be annoying if trains are only announced with minutes to go - but this was likely due to a delayed inbound train so the alternative would be to delay your train. The nature of the franchised system forces operators to keep turnarounds as tight as possible so this will happen from time to time (plus, trains occupying platforms for a long time means fewer services are able to run).
 

Greenback

Emeritus Moderator
Joined
9 Aug 2009
Messages
15,268
Location
Llanelli
You probably haven't noticed being in a dark tunnel, but I can assure you that you would have passed through it every time. Patchway (round the corner from Parkway) is a single bore tunnel on the up/down line, the reason is the line splits (you may notice for example that as you leave the tunnel heading to Cardiff, the Up line is a few meters below)

I have noticed that, but I was picking up on the use of the single line wording. The tunnel is single bore, but it remains a double line as there are two of them!

It's a bit pedantic I know, but others could get the impression from the wording that the double line from paddington suddenly becomes single to go through a tunnel, as on the Hastings line after Tunbridge Wells!
 

jnjkerbin

Member
Joined
25 Apr 2012
Messages
842
Location
Down south
It's a bit pedantic I know, but others could get the impression from the wording that the double line from paddington suddenly becomes single to go through a tunnel, as on the Hastings line after Tunbridge Wells!

If we're being pedantic then there's a single track tunnel on the Hastings Line before Tunbridge Wells as well.

Quite interesting is the number of people I hear on trains stopped outside the tunnel who think that the reason for the pause is that trains aren't allowed to pass on the bendy bit of perfectly straight track through the tunnel while the trains sitting on a 45mph curve to the north is waiting to pass the oncoming service

Sorry, couldn't resist ;)

Anyway, never had much of a problem with GW.
 
Last edited:
Joined
4 Dec 2011
Messages
600
I note your comments about poor seat pitch. Presumably you'd also complain about lack of seating capacity if every seat had better legroom?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top