Enough water has flowed under the bridge since 1962 to raise this matter.
My late father was the P-Way Asst. to the District Engineer, Lancaster.
He was asked to provide figures for the Silloth branch.
Back in the 1950's when still under Scottish Region control a J39 hauling a passenger train was derailed on poor track.
In consequence father had it 90% relaid, with concrete sleepers on good bullhead rail, So his response was that track renewal and maintenance was a one mile length between Abbeytown and Silloth, and accordingly no heavy expendiure was forseen.
Euston responded that these figures were unacceptable. Could father please give an amount for an average run down branch.
It fell to me to attend the redundant assets meeting, and watch sound track being torn up.
The closure was so contravercial that several lengths were ripped out at Canal Jct, as soon as approval to close the line was given and implemented.
There was egg on face when it was realised that two rakes of wagons were stranded at Silloth Docks.
There was also about this time an enquiry for a daily trainload of freight contenet I forget, through the docks, but an excessive rate was quoted, and that was the end of the matter.
How many other lines were so treated, and in the article I am writing, when the oil runs out, either the line will have to be put back, or more likely a roadside electric tramway built. It was a long time ago, but it can still get to me.
Andrew