I am looking to plan a 2017 holiday for me and my mum. I usually plan too far in depth far too soon (as this post may show you). My dad will be driving us to Dumfries station for 09:00 to catch the train to carlisle, once I arrive here... well... that's the purpose of this post. I have several options that have thought up of and I will be very grateful of any help you can give me! I am looking for the cheapest option that will give us a reasonable tour of England. I plan on staying at Premier Inn.
Option 1 - Tour of England by rails
This option would involve getting a train from Carlisle to a city (I thought either Liverpool, Manchester or York) and checking in here. Over the next few days I will travel to the two other cities, spending one night at each. I would then catch a train from the last city I visit (out of the listed three) to London, and spend 2 days in London. On the full day in London I would catch a train to Brighton. I would then catch a Virgin Train (preferably voyager) back to Carlisle. Let me know if you have any suggestions/amendments to this plan and I will be very grateful
Option 2 - Central Rail Hub
This option involves travelling from Carlisle to a Central Rail Hub (I thought either Crewe or Birmingham) and travelling from here to Manchester, Liverpool and London. Can anyone suggest another good rail hub that I may not have thought of yet? Any information would be appreciated, also if knows any of these buttress well, please let me know as I have some questions.
Option 3 - London and Visits
This option involves catching a Virgin Train from Carlisle all the way to Euston (preferably voyager) and then travelling from London to various places (Brighton, possibly Eurostar one day, any other suggestions?) I would then on the 2nd last day catch a train halfway up the country and stay at a premier inn in a city, I would then spend the last day here before getting an evening train up to Carlisle and back home.
I looking for the cheapest and most exciting option (with as much variety of traction as is possible.) Any assistance or advice will be hugely appreciated!
Option 1 - Tour of England by rails
This option would involve getting a train from Carlisle to a city (I thought either Liverpool, Manchester or York) and checking in here. Over the next few days I will travel to the two other cities, spending one night at each. I would then catch a train from the last city I visit (out of the listed three) to London, and spend 2 days in London. On the full day in London I would catch a train to Brighton. I would then catch a Virgin Train (preferably voyager) back to Carlisle. Let me know if you have any suggestions/amendments to this plan and I will be very grateful

Option 2 - Central Rail Hub
This option involves travelling from Carlisle to a Central Rail Hub (I thought either Crewe or Birmingham) and travelling from here to Manchester, Liverpool and London. Can anyone suggest another good rail hub that I may not have thought of yet? Any information would be appreciated, also if knows any of these buttress well, please let me know as I have some questions.
Option 3 - London and Visits
This option involves catching a Virgin Train from Carlisle all the way to Euston (preferably voyager) and then travelling from London to various places (Brighton, possibly Eurostar one day, any other suggestions?) I would then on the 2nd last day catch a train halfway up the country and stay at a premier inn in a city, I would then spend the last day here before getting an evening train up to Carlisle and back home.
I looking for the cheapest and most exciting option (with as much variety of traction as is possible.) Any assistance or advice will be hugely appreciated!