We have had closed stations but only those in recent times the last 30 years or so otherwise there is no chance of it being guessed. If it closed in the 1960s there is realistically no one is going to get it.
I have done a few Tilbury Riverside, Addiscombe.
You have to be realistic if no one is getting it you are going to have to give clues otherwise everyone getes bored and disappears.
Pontefract Baghill