DarloRich
Veteran Member
Rich, I won't pretend to know too much about your situation and from what I have read you've not been treated well but one thing that you don't seem to realise is that fans don't matter. I'm not going to try to show you some kind of analogy but I've learned enough around the non-league circuit over the years that they simply don't matter!
My real gripe here is seeing how clubs have taken a two division relegation hit and won promotion back to where they were within two or three seasons. The current system is a mockery.
I agree! There needs to be a punishment. God knows the various people in charge of the club have shown a less than prudent approach to financial affairs!
If only the FA would follow the rules they have set themselves. Mind you the rules make the encyclopaedia Britannica look slim! I make no further comment on what has gone before but:
IF we are a new club (a Phoenix club I think they are termed by the FA) then the highest we can start is the Northern League. We could be placed lower. This seems to be to do with the issuing of a new "footballing share"
IF we are not a new club but play at Shildon the highest we can play is the Northern League as this is the highest level their ground is rated at.
IF we are not a new club but agree a CVA then we should play at BSN level. (if we had a suitable ground and they accept us)
IF we are a new club then we have no need to try for a CVA but will have to start at Northern League Level or lower.
IF we are not a new club and have no CVA we should be placed in the Evo Stick Premier league. It would be likely in this case that we would be demoted from here as the BSN rightly follow the same rules as the BSP with regard to the exit of administration and would throw us out.
The FA then has the power to impose any sanction they feel is appropriate in exceptional circumstances. They have used this and a combination of the above! To me a fair punishment would be demotion to the Evo Stick league, most likely league 1, perhaps with a suspended point deduction against our future financial behaviour and exclusion from FA cup competitions for the first season. This would suggest a sensible threat of future punishment to other wrong doers mitigated in our case by the fact that the fans saved the club with their own resources and are seeking to run the club sensibly, democratically and correctly in the future Further acknowledgement that the fans raised money to ensure we completed the season and preserved the integrity of the FA completion would also be sensible and warmly welcomed.. A financial penalty would be of little practical purpose as we have little money.
An appeal based on three points is to be lodged but the new board say that they can not reveal the basis of that appeal before it is heard. One strand is expected to be the potential for crowd unpleasantness if large numbers of fans travel to games. For once in my life we have a prospect of being the big club! There is a further potential unpleasantness based upon the fact that many northern league teams are based on the Durham coast which is close to our great rivals Hartlepooh United. The police appear less than happy about this prospect!
Finally, I would also like an acknowledgement from the FA that their "fit and proper persons test" and the sanctions they can impose on those who have a hand in causing these problems is insufficient and they have no choice but to punish those trying to sort the mess out.
I have long suspected that football fans are a mere inconvenience to the FA but this action has confirmed the same!