• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

East Midlands Parkway - Failure?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Elybob

Member
Joined
31 Mar 2023
Messages
41
Location
Ely
Just wondering why this station was ever built. It cost £25m to build yet receives 300k passengers a year, less than my unstaffed village station, and it has no real link to the airport despite the name (Long Eaton and Loughborough have better bus links). In fact it doesn't appear to have any bus services to anywhere.

What was the initial purpose supposed to be?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

ChrisC

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2018
Messages
2,255
Location
Nottinghamshire
There have been so many discussions in various threads on this subject over the years but here are a few of my thoughts as to why passenger numbers are so low.

It now costs £8 a day to park there. The station has a wide catchment area and could attract people to park and ride from there into Nottingham, Derby and Leicester. People are not going to pay £8 to park plus train fares for that purpose. For example travelling into Nottingham using the tram from the park and ride sites at Clifton or Toton wins.

The regular Trent Barton Skylink Express bus passes right by the station but does not call in. This could provide a convenient link to the airport. It could also be useful for travel to London from areas of Nottingham such as West Bridgford and Clifton. For example it would be convenient for students from the Clifton Campus to use instead of having to travel into the city.

Ticket prices to many popular leisure destinations, especially to the north via Sheffield are extremely expensive. Reasonably priced Day Return fares, which are available from both Nottingham and Derby, are often not available from East Midlands Parkway resulting in some day trips costing almost double the price.

Although improved slightly in recent years the timetable and level of service has never been that convenient to many destinations.

Whether it should have been built is an interesting question. However, since it has been built, there has been little in recent years to encourage people to use it. East Midlands Trains in their early days did run a number of promotions to encourage passengers to use it.
 
Last edited:

edwin_m

Veteran Member
Joined
21 Apr 2013
Messages
28,620
Location
Nottingham
I believe the main intention was to attract London travellers, but most who needed to drive the station probably still went to Grantham for the quicker journey.

Airport custom was not seen to be significant and was never going to be enough to justify a connecting service - there just aren't many people needing to get to a medium-sized airport from somewhere far enough away to warrant considering the train, and who aren't travelling as a family or with large luggage which makes car or taxi more suitable. I don't know how well National Express serve the airport, but if they do then it would be more convenient for most than transferring from the train, and if they don't then it shows there's no market anyway. As well as Nottingham, Loughborough Leicester and Derby also have frequent direct airport buses.

Diversion of Skylink Express would add quite a bit of time to other passengers' journeys, mostly for the benefit of those few airport passengers. Any other journey can be accomplished much more conveniently and only slightly slower by staying on the bus to Nottingham station - the bus is fast so there's not much extra journey time.

One of the few benefits of the station was to provide Megatrain services linking London with various places less well connected by rail, by transfer between the then EMT Nottingham HSTs and Megabus. The two operators are now under different ownership, and the trains have gone from eight to mostly five cars of passenger space with fewer seats per car, so that's not coming back.
 

swt_passenger

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Apr 2010
Messages
34,259
It was definitely not built as an airport station, that was mentioned somewhere in the original planning application. AIUI the primary purpose was to be a park and ride station to draw in people from the wider area who were travelling to London down the M1, and secondly to act as a park and ride for people aiming for Nottingham who didn’t want to drive into the city centre.
 

edwin_m

Veteran Member
Joined
21 Apr 2013
Messages
28,620
Location
Nottingham
It was definitely not built as an airport station, that was mentioned somewhere in the original planning application. AIUI the primary purpose was to be a park and ride station to draw in people from the wider area who were travelling to London down the M1, and secondly to act as a park and ride for people aiming for Nottingham who didn’t want to drive into the city centre.
Park and ride into Nottingham was never realistic either, even before they started charging £8. A frequency of 2TPH, not at regular intervals, would give people too great a risk of missing the train and if they wanted to park and ride they'd just stay on the A453 to Clifton Bridge or more recently the Clifton tram site.
 

Nottingham59

Established Member
Joined
10 Dec 2019
Messages
3,330
Location
Nottingham
The regular Trent Barton Skylink Express bus passes right by the station but does not call in.
It's not really "right by". The bus from Nottingham to Derby would have to travel 2.9km from the dual carriageway, round three roundabouts (each one twice) and a reversing loop to reach the station forecourt.

1732211921362.png
[image shows Google map view with bus route diversion marked]
 

rower40

Member
Joined
1 Jan 2008
Messages
579
It's to provide a ringside seat for when Ratcliffe cooling towers are demolished.
 

Trainman40083

Established Member
Joined
29 Jan 2024
Messages
4,560
Location
Derby
I seem to recall that the "express" bus did once called, but that was when Premiere ran it. Suspect the only bus service that might use it now is the demand response service, unless the service that used to be run by Nottingham Coaches 865? still runs. As others have said £8 parking would people off. Add in the current £2 bus fare..
 

MCR247

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2008
Messages
10,291
As easy as it is to say it shouldn’t have been built, I’d say it came in pretty useful the Nottingham station works. Beeston wouldn’t have coped and Loughborough probably too far. Running buses to Derby to connect to London trains would’ve been the only option I imagine
 

Trainman40083

Established Member
Joined
29 Jan 2024
Messages
4,560
Location
Derby
As easy as it is to say it shouldn’t have been built, I’d say it came in pretty useful the Nottingham station works. Beeston wouldn’t have coped and Loughborough probably too far. Running buses to Derby to connect to London trains would’ve been the only option I imagine
Possibly too, when Derby area was remodeled. Does it get much use when such as the Download Festival is on at Donington Park?
 

DDB

Member
Joined
11 Sep 2011
Messages
726
One of the few benefits of the station was to provide Megatrain services linking London with various places less well connected by rail, by transfer between the then EMT Nottingham HSTs and Megabus. The two operators are now under different ownership, and the trains have gone from eight to mostly five cars of passenger space with fewer seats per car, so that's not coming back.
When the 810s come in they will be doubled up in the peaks. Someone here worked out that assuming a standard pattern that train diagrams going into London in the morning peak would naturally end up coming out of London in the afternoon peak.
I assume that means they may be left as double sets all day rather than coupling and uncoupling.
Therefore in the middle of the day some will have loads of spare capacity. They may just focus all the advance fares on these but there might be scope to bring a coach service back.
 

edwin_m

Veteran Member
Joined
21 Apr 2013
Messages
28,620
Location
Nottingham
When the 810s come in they will be doubled up in the peaks. Someone here worked out that assuming a standard pattern that train diagrams going into London in the morning peak would naturally end up coming out of London in the afternoon peak.
I assume that means they may be left as double sets all day rather than coupling and uncoupling.
Therefore in the middle of the day some will have loads of spare capacity. They may just focus all the advance fares on these but there might be scope to bring a coach service back.
Interesting. London-Nottingham is just over 90min so assume a round trip time of four hours including some layover each end. That means a train arriving in London at 0800 (roughly the start of the morning business peak) would them make two round trips during off-peak(ish) hours before arriving again at 1600 for the start of the evening business peak. It doesn't work so well for commuters because their day is longer, but most of them will be on the Corby service. However, unlike the indivisible HSTs, they do have the option of splitting them in the off-peak, so it may be a question of whether the extra (very low) fares pay for the extra mileage and crewing costs for a coupled unit. My hunch is that it won't - I don't think Megatrain ever used more than one Standard class coach of the HST, so even if they could fill it completely each round trip would only generate a part share in about 160 low fares.
 

Trainman40083

Established Member
Joined
29 Jan 2024
Messages
4,560
Location
Derby
When the 810s come in they will be doubled up in the peaks. Someone here worked out that assuming a standard pattern that train diagrams going into London in the morning peak would naturally end up coming out of London in the afternoon peak.
I assume that means they may be left as double sets all day rather than coupling and uncoupling.
Therefore in the middle of the day some will have loads of spare capacity. They may just focus all the advance fares on these but there might be scope to bring a coach service back.
Maybe it will be just as it is now. A 10 car arrives from one location, then another 10 car. One set goes to Cricklewood to stable between the peaks, the other set will split and serve two destinations.
 

duffield

Established Member
Joined
31 Jul 2013
Messages
3,280
Location
East Midlands
It's to provide a ringside seat for when Ratcliffe cooling towers are demolished.
That would be great, I'd be there for that - except I'll bet it (and the railway) will be closed when they blow them up. It'll all be within the cordon. They'll probably do it first thing Sunday morning when no trains are running anyhow.

But maybe we've got a demolitions expert on here who can confirm or deny my suspicions. :)

Anyhow East Midlands Parkway may come into its own when the Ratcliffe site is redeveloped.
 

pint

Member
Joined
11 Aug 2019
Messages
41
It now costs £8 a day to park there. The station has a wide catchment area and could attract people to park and ride from there into Nottingham, Derby and Leicester. People are not going to pay £8 to park plus train fares for that purpose. For example travelling into Nottingham using the tram from the park and ride sites at Clifton or Toton wins.
£8 a day to park is absolutely scandalous for that location, as above you can get the tram park and ride for £5.40 all day , or slightly further in the bus park and ride for £6 a car load or £4 per person ( based on the £2 bus ticket price cap one ticket in, another out) or £5.30 all day bus ticket per person
Parking at that site should be free if they want people to use it
 

Nottingham59

Established Member
Joined
10 Dec 2019
Messages
3,330
Location
Nottingham
£8 a day to park is absolutely scandalous for that location, as above you can get the tram park and ride for £5.40 all day , or slightly further in the bus park and ride for £6 a car load or £4 per person ( based on the £2 bus ticket price cap one ticket in, another out) or £5.30 all day bus ticket per person
Parking at that site should be free if they want people to use it
It's become a useful railhead for people who live in places like East Leake and Gotham who have business in London. I expect the parking charge is targeted at people like them, mostly on expenses.
 

DDB

Member
Joined
11 Sep 2011
Messages
726
Interesting. London-Nottingham is just over 90min so assume a round trip time of four hours including some layover each end. That means a train arriving in London at 0800 (roughly the start of the morning business peak) would them make two round trips during off-peak(ish) hours before arriving again at 1600 for the start of the evening business peak. It doesn't work so well for commuters because their day is longer, but most of them will be on the Corby service. However, unlike the indivisible HSTs, they do have the option of splitting them in the off-peak, so it may be a question of whether the extra (very low) fares pay for the extra mileage and crewing costs for a coupled unit. My hunch is that it won't - I don't think Megatrain ever used more than one Standard class coach of the HST, so even if they could fill it completely each round trip would only generate a part share in about 160 low fares.
I think the assumption was the cycle would be some version of Nottingham London Sheffield London and repeat.
 

Nottingham59

Established Member
Joined
10 Dec 2019
Messages
3,330
Location
Nottingham
I think the assumption was the cycle would be some version of Nottingham London Sheffield London and repeat.
That was my understanding too.

Assuming a nine hour cycle (4 to Nottingham plus 5 to Sheffield), the ten-car 810s arriving in London between 7 and 9am carrying the morning peak arrive back in London between 4 and 6pm just in time for the evening peak home again.
 
Last edited:

pint

Member
Joined
11 Aug 2019
Messages
41
It's become a useful railhead for people who live in places like East Leake and Gotham who have business in London. I expect the parking charge is targeted at people like them, mostly on expenses.
Still an absolute scandal price wise, and one of the many things thats wrong with rail travel
extortionate parking
expensive tickets
overly complex tickets
no guarantee of a seat/overcrowding
multiple ways that you can be fined for mistakes and errors
 

Trainman40083

Established Member
Joined
29 Jan 2024
Messages
4,560
Location
Derby
It's become a useful railhead for people who live in places like East Leake and Gotham who have business in London. I expect the parking charge is targeted at people like them, mostly on expenses.
Were they going to build lots of houses between Gotham and the A453.
 

Dr Hoo

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2015
Messages
5,621
Location
Hope Valley
Parking at East Midlands Parkway (EMD) for £8 is a steal compared with Chesterfield station at £15 (less after 1000 and at weekends)!
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Trainman40083

Established Member
Joined
29 Jan 2024
Messages
4,560
Location
Derby
Parking at East Midlands Parkway (EMD) for £8 is a steal compared with Chesterfield station at £15 (less after 1000 and at weekends)!
Derby must be the same. It was £14.50 a day last year. £7.50 off peak. Yet it still seems full of cars.
 

156421

On Moderation
Joined
23 Aug 2022
Messages
342
Location
Weſtmorland 'n' Furneß
I seem to recall that the "express" bus did once called, but that was when Premiere ran it. Suspect the only bus service that might use it now is the demand response service, unless the service that used to be run by Nottingham Coaches 865? still runs. As others have said £8 parking would people off. Add in the current £2 bus fare..
Skylink Nottingham used to call there I think but was rerouted via M1/A52 due to chronic congestion on the A453... which was since alleviated when the road was "dualled" however the original route wasn't reverted to.
 

edwin_m

Veteran Member
Joined
21 Apr 2013
Messages
28,620
Location
Nottingham
Skylink Nottingham used to call there I think but was rerouted via M1/A52 due to chronic congestion on the A453... which was since alleviated when the road was "dualled" however the original route wasn't reverted to.
There have been many variations of Skylink between EMA and Nottingham since it started in about 2006, including use of either the A453 or the A6005. I don't think it ever routinely used the A52 but one benefit of avoiding intermediate stops was that it allowed "real time" diversion in the event of congestion. Likely less of a concern since the dualling, but IMHO still not enough of a reason to divert to the Parkway.
 

cle

Established Member
Joined
17 Nov 2010
Messages
5,619
It's a shame because the HS2 EMP plan would have been a good use for it. Plenty of space for splitting, passing, changing... if no demand to enter oe exit, really. But then would have become an actually useful railhead with sub 1hr London journeys and very quick to Birmingham. Then, build a city there - Radcliffe dependent.
 

ChrisC

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2018
Messages
2,255
Location
Nottinghamshire
Parking at East Midlands Parkway (EMD) for £8 is a steal compared with Chesterfield station at £15 (less after 1000 and at weekends)!
I stopped using Chesterfield station years ago because of the high parking charges. Perhaps £15 isn’t too high for a station car park at large city station but not at a town like Chesterfield. It‘s the same price at Newark Northgate. I suppose that’s what happens when a station is situated on a busy inter city route. If I’m going out for the day to somewhere to the north, as I have a drive of around 30 minutes to either Chesterfield or Newark I just stay in my car and drive the whole way. Sometimes, if the train fare isn’t considerably higher than from Chesterfield I do pay the £5 parking charge at Alfreton station.

The difference with East Midlands Parkway is that although it’s less at £8, it is a parkway station with a huge car park and loads of space, right out in the country and not in a town or city. When it first opened the then East Midlands Trains sold quite reasonably priced day returns to Nottingham, Derby and Leicester which included parking.

If the Skylink Express bus from Nottingham to East Midlands Airport was to call in at the station, would add any more than 5 minutes to come off the A453 dual carriageway to do that?
 

MCR247

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2008
Messages
10,291
Skylink express is quite tightly timed and 5 minutes each way would likely break the timings
 

BrianW

Established Member
Joined
22 Mar 2017
Messages
2,131
I believe the main intention was to attract London travellers, but most who needed to drive the station probably still went to Grantham for the quicker journey.

Airport custom was not seen to be significant and was never going to be enough to justify a connecting service - there just aren't many people needing to get to a medium-sized airport from somewhere far enough away to warrant considering the train, and who aren't travelling as a family or with large luggage which makes car or taxi more suitable. I don't know how well National Express serve the airport, but if they do then it would be more convenient for most than transferring from the train, and if they don't then it shows there's no market anyway. As well as Nottingham, Loughborough Leicester and Derby also have frequent direct airport buses.

Diversion of Skylink Express would add quite a bit of time to other passengers' journeys, mostly for the benefit of those few airport passengers. Any other journey can be accomplished much more conveniently and only slightly slower by staying on the bus to Nottingham station - the bus is fast so there's not much extra journey time.

One of the few benefits of the station was to provide Megatrain services linking London with various places less well connected by rail, by transfer between the then EMT Nottingham HSTs and Megabus. The two operators are now under different ownership, and the trains have gone from eight to mostly five cars of passenger space with fewer seats per car, so that's not coming back.
Presumably a 'Business case' was developed, approved and turned into what we now have. No doubt much will have changed since.

I wonder what a retrospective review of the expectations, and hopes, will 'say' about such Cases for Support. Investments of time and money in this development, and what could have been achieved had it been spent elsewhere- the 'Opportunity Costs'? I suspect there may have been a lot of 'political considerations, 'optimism bias' and inadequate 'testing', questioning, etc.
 

pint

Member
Joined
11 Aug 2019
Messages
41
I stopped using Chesterfield station years ago because of the high parking charges. Perhaps £15 isn’t too high for a station car park at large city station but not at a town like Chesterfield. It‘s the same price at Newark Northgate. I suppose that’s what happens when a station is situated on a busy inter city route. If I’m going out for the day to somewhere to the north, as I have a drive of around 30 minutes to either Chesterfield or Newark I just stay in my car and drive the whole way. Sometimes, if the train fare isn’t considerably higher than from Chesterfield I do pay the £5 parking charge at Alfreton station.

The difference with East Midlands Parkway is that although it’s less at £8, it is a parkway station with a huge car park and loads of space, right out in the country and not in a town or city. When it first opened the then East Midlands Trains sold quite reasonably priced day returns to Nottingham, Derby and Leicester which included parking.

If the Skylink Express bus from Nottingham to East Midlands Airport was to call in at the station, would add any more than 5 minutes to come off the A453 dual carriageway to do that?
East midlands parkway can only be accessed by car, and once there, there is nothing else there apart from the railway station, unless you wanted to walk to Redhill marina and visit the coffee shop - but if you wanted to do that then go a little further down the lane and you can park at the marina.
I would consider the pakrway station to be among my main local(ish) railway stations, but I have absolutely no reason to use it as it is at the moment , now if they were to extend the number 9 midalnd classic route ( now Diamond bus) service a little further to there, it could open up some public transport options. but for as it is its just a bit of a lost cause.
For those who dont kow the Number 9 bus currently goes from:
Burton upon Trent
Winshill ( just outside Burton)
Newhall ( near swadlincote)
Swadlincote
Woodville ( near swadlincote)
Ashby de-la-zouch ( other bus services to Coalville, Loughborough, Leicester)
Melbourne ( bus services to Derby)
East Midlands Airport
East Midlands Gateway (EMG) less than 5 minutes from there is East midlands parkway
 

GRALISTAIR

Established Member
Joined
11 Apr 2012
Messages
10,491
Location
Preston Lancs
Still an absolute scandal price wise, and one of the many things thats wrong with rail travel
extortionate parking
expensive tickets
overly complex tickets
no guarantee of a seat/overcrowding
multiple ways that you can be fined for mistakes and errors
Summed up perfectly imho
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top