I thought the FGW still had a few interesting things and went into more depth than I'd have expected. Despite the continuity issues, it really did seem to show much more than simply what FGW does.
The Sky one seems to be very dumbed down, not really going into any level of depth whatsoever. When you have a section about celebrities, and many of said celebrities being filmed (and even if they're trying to pretend they've not been noticed, they clearly have) then you begin to wonder how much else is set up. I mean, was the bag dropped on the track deliberately, for example?
What is good (but somewhat OTT as if it's a paid-for advertorial for East Coast) is that when something goes wrong, Richard Wilson - one minute lambasting the railway for loads of things - is really defending the railway. And we haven't seen or heard loads of people complaining - in fact, in episode one, it appears as if everyone was quite happy
I did like the man who helped clean the train and pointed out the state it was left in by others, and referring to airlines not tolerating such a thing.
Anyway, it's only one episode of ten, and despite having repeat shots of the same group on a hen night and loads of other repeated stuff (as well as what I'm sure was a swap from an HST to Mk4 to HST - the first continuity error?), it might get better.
I would have just expected much more from the first show - especially if Sky put it out as a preview on Sky Go and On Demand.
The problem is that Sky seems to have done it all about the people, so I'm not sure we'll get much more on anything other than more rather mundane stories and anecdotes. There's loads of establishing shots and music that is just padding, and without ads on On Demand it was only 43 minutes as it was.
Take out the padding and it's probably going to be nearer 30. Yes, I know most TV is like that - but.. well, I've said my opinion and now it's over to others to share their opinions that might differ greatly!