Competition 411 :: Voting

[Jordy]

http://www.railforums.co.uk/gallery/thumbnails.php?album=134

Votes in by 1900 next Sunday please

Cheers

 

[Pumbaa]

9, 10 and 16 were all excellent shots.

 

[bengley]

4, oh my god... 4 is incredible...

 

[Lampshade]

I had a dream last night mine would be that number

 

[transportphoto]

How is 03 an Excursion?

Same goes for No 15!

I am however still undecided!

 

[EltonRoad]

Very good subject matter this week.

 

[Swiss Toni]

4, oh my god... 4 is incredible...

More attempted sarcasm again, or are you just being a prat?

 

[Lampshade]

4, oh my god... 4 is incredible...

Why don't you naff off? 4 is a cracking shot and got my vote.

 

[Ivo]

4 is actually a pretty good shot, so (for Swiss Toni) it is neither sarcastic or bengley being "a prat". However, it does not get my vote, which goes to 9.

 

[Swiss Toni]

4 is actually a pretty good shot, so (for Swiss Toni) it is neither sarcastic or bengley being "a prat".

You're very naive if you think he meant what he said.

 

[Ivo]

Just to clarify, and then I'm saying no more on the matter, I'm not naive, I'm autistic. I find sarcasm very difficult to follow. But this one did not appear to be sarcastic; just an exaggeration.

 

[bengley]

Why don't you guys shut up for once? I was actually being serious. The mountains in the background are stunning. I even voted for it. I'm only sarcastic if something is really bad and this isn't even close to bad.
--- old post above --- --- new post below ---

Just to clarify, and then I'm saying no more on the matter, I'm not naive, I'm autistic. I find sarcasm very difficult to follow. But this one did not appear to be sarcastic; just an exaggeration.

You're the only one here that realised that I was serious, despite being autistic so well done.

 

[90019]

I'm autistic.

So you keep saying.

 

[Ivo]

Sorry...

 

[devon_metro]

4, oh my god... 4 is incredible...

I wouldn't got that far, its rather under-exposed. I'm sure it would be far nicer touched up in photoshop.

 

[mumrar]

I wouldn't got that far, its rather under-exposed. I'm sure it would be far nicer touched up in photoshop.

The sky looks like it already has been touched up to a degree. It's been done as such that I can tell who's entry it actually is, obviously I won't say who, but the overall image is left looking a bit flat.

 

[bengley]

I wouldn't got that far, its rather under-exposed. I'm sure it would be far nicer touched up in photoshop.

I agree that it's a bit dark, but damn, the scenery and the angle of the picture is awesome.

 

[Multiple Unit]

Number 3 is 57601 aprochind platform 1xxx at Crewe about to be coupled upto WCR MK1 Coaching Stock rake and then to Depart on an Excursion / Tour not my photo but was probably there on this day.

 

[mumrar]

Number 3 is 57601 aprochind platform 1xxx at Crewe about to be coupled upto WCR MK1 Coaching Stock rake and then to Depart on an Excursion / Tour not my photo but was probably there on this day.

I gathered something like that would be the case, but you'd hardl accept a picture of a 37 leaving Carlisle Kingmoor to be of a nuclear train would you. At the end of the day, if people don't think it fits the category, then don't vote for it. Personally, as the photo doesn't show an excursion, it's not up for voting.

 

[madannie77]

Number 3 is 57601 aprochind platform 1xxx at Crewe about to be coupled upto WCR MK1 Coaching Stock rake and then to Depart on an Excursion / Tour not my photo but was probably there on this day.

It is actually at Carlisle, probably taken on the 7th February 2009. Not my shot, but I was there with a camera. All five locos involved on the tour are in shot (3 x 20 and 1 x 37 as well as the 57), but none of them is attached to the stock. Not really a photograph of an excursion train in my opinion.

 

[37401]

How is 03 an Excursion?

Same goes for No 15!

I am however still undecided!

Pays to read the description, it was never stated the fit had to be of the charter itself so 3 and 15 are fitting for the comp

 

[Jordy]

But if you don't think they are, don't vote for them

 

[almark]

A couple of good shots this week,the one that gets my vote is 10,closely followed by 9. The main reason i didn't vote for 9 is the mix of coach liveries (obviously beyond the control of the fotter without spending crazy amounts of time in PS),it just seems to distract me from the main fot somehow.

There are a couple in there that make me wonder if people think they have got to enter the POTW comp,i guess the usual "if you don't like it don't vote for it" rule applies all the same.

 

[Jordy]

Congrats to Ferret

01 - EltonRoad
02 - TGVDUDE
03 - 2030720310
04 - almark
05 - GNERman
06 - ladysue
07 - curly42
08 - 91107
09 - Ferret
10 - Swiss Toni
11 - 90019
12 - steve 46010
13 - GB
14 - Chester025
15 - 37401
16 - mumrar
17 - Multiple Unit

 

[2030720310]

It is actually at Carlisle, probably taken on the 7th February 2009. Not my shot, but I was there with a camera. All five locos involved on the tour are in shot (3 x 20 and 1 x 37 as well as the 57), but none of them is attached to the stock. Not really a photograph of an excursion train in my opinion.

Yep, on 7th Feb....

All the locos were being used on the excurision (bar 57303 (?) on the end)....