If asked if I'm an idiot I usually try to respond that I am not. However I have bought both Hornby and Bachmann coaling towers....Both! This is caused by pre-ordering off mail order sites and not keeping note...as I said an idiot. This means however that I can make a comparison - both are very good. The Bachmann one if ordered through the mail may well arrive in 10 000 pieces so be warned. Hornby is more robust. I am lucky to have space but you'll need a small holding to fit the 4 lane Bachmann into a realistic setting. I usually prefer Bachmann over Hornby and, in this instance,Bachmann provide more for your hard earned. More railings, more steps, more bits and a decent attempt at recreating the wagon lifting mechanism. Hornby does not but it is less expensive, a better colour and does the job.
In summary - for the loot I'd go with Hornby unless you plan to stare lovingly at it for all times and make it the centre piece of your layout - then....I'd still go with Hornby. However if you want to prove you are a complete idiot - buy both.
In summary - for the loot I'd go with Hornby unless you plan to stare lovingly at it for all times and make it the centre piece of your layout - then....I'd still go with Hornby. However if you want to prove you are a complete idiot - buy both.
