• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Search results

  1. Fawkes Cat

    Unable to produce 16 - 25 railcard

    Our general advice is that it's important to engage with the process. In this case, as you have a slip asking you to send details of your Railcard, I would suggest you need to respond to that to say that you now realise you don't have one. Also explain that it was stolen with your purse (give...
  2. Fawkes Cat

    TIR Advice Please

    Just correcting a typo: but also to express a little doubt about the wording. I am fully on board that it's not a great idea to try to tell the railway what to do - but 'I will pay whatever you think is reasonable' does feel rather like opening your wallet and saying 'help yourself'. But...
  3. Fawkes Cat

    Train Fine IRCAS Chiltern Railways

    Unfortunately, you are in a weak position: your daughter is being offered alternatives to prosecution (a prosecution that the railway would most likely win) so the railway doesn't need to extend courtesies to you. Your daughter has two options: to pay up, or be taken to court. There is no third...
  4. Fawkes Cat

    Fare Dodging Govia Thameslink

    If you are going to do that, the railway will want to know that the family member is acting on your behalf. So before you go away, write (and sign) a brief letter saying this: all it needs to say is something like This letter is to confirm that I have authorised <name of family member> to act...
  5. Fawkes Cat

    Notice of Intended Prosecution Chilterns!! Avoiding correct fare!

    Practically speaking, the railway want to deal with this fairly quickly from their point of view, so they don't want mountains of documentation if they can avoid it. So when you respond, confirm what journeys you have evidence for, but don't send it in yet. If the railway want to see the...
  6. Fawkes Cat

    Penalty fare appeal

    It's a while since this was posted, so sorry if you've already moved on - but as you have worked out, you cannot specifically appeal against this £140. You are entitled to someone taking a second look at it - but the way to do that is by the railway prosecuting you for fare dodging (so you have...
  7. Fawkes Cat

    Using a fake Railcard

    Quite often, we don't get to hear the final outcome. Given the age of this thread, that could be because the final outcome isn't there yet - or it might be that the OP has resolved things and wants to move on from it. It's really useful if people can tell us how things ended up as that points...
  8. Fawkes Cat

    EMR Court Fines Received 1 year later from Marston Recovery

    Others may be along later with other advice, but I would expect a court to see this as you putting yourself in the wrong: you didn't find out about the prosecution because you gave false details. So if this is the case where your SD is late, then the court is unlikely to extend sympathy, and for...
  9. Fawkes Cat

    Govia Thameslink Railway witness statement

    I don't think anyone's come back on this - apologies if I'm treading on someone's toes. Given that you don't want to mention what happened the next day, I think that this is fine. But you need to bear in mind that the railway may put their records together and realise that there was also an...
  10. Fawkes Cat

    Special Offers Discussion

    For this, Uber are rather more generous than you imagine - you get your 10% on the full cost of the ticket including what you have paid for with Uber credits. So if I buy a ticket for £20, I get £2 in Uber credits: when I next buy the same ticket for £18 from my credit card plus £2 in Uber...
  11. Fawkes Cat

    My misrecollection and Thameslink ticket

    Welcome to the forum! Although it's not something you've said, please be assured that you won't be going to prison for this. The worst that can happen will be that Thameslink or the courts need you to pay some money to them. You've already made a note in your post to us of what went on today...
  12. Fawkes Cat

    Penalty Fare Notice Help Needed - Birmingham New Street to University, missed stop and got off train at Selly Oak 2 minutes after - 2nd Appeal Help

    Trying to put myself into the shoes of the third appeal panel, I would prefer the whole argument to be presented anew. Otherwise it would feel like being asked to review the second appeal rather than doing a new job - which is hardly a way to get the third panel on your side. And you can't be...
  13. Fawkes Cat

    Fine from Short Fare Evasion received - Table and evidence from WMR incorrect

    Welcome to the forum! It would be really helpful if you could show us the paperwork that you have received: make sure you redact it so that we (and the whole internet) don't see your personal details. For the moment, one point that stands out is the question of the £1000 limit for the fine...
  14. Fawkes Cat

    TIR For incorrect date on ticket.

    Really sorry if I suggested your son lied: while the practical upshot is the same (i.e. the case carries on) it's entirely possible that the inspector misheard or mistyped what your son said.
  15. Fawkes Cat

    Penalty Fare Appeal - Station was Unknowingly Open

    I think we may be rather at cross purposes (and apologies to OP for this digression): Merseyrail isn't too worried about how you obtain your ticket - but (for practical purposes) only paper tickets are valid. So a ticket to Kirkby must be a small orange piece of cardboard, as it is only served...
  16. Fawkes Cat

    Penalty Fare Appeal - Station was Unknowingly Open

    Kirkby now only has Merseyrail services as the Northern service to Manchester now starts at Headbolt Lane. So as Merseyrail doesn't do e-tickets, paper (i.e. ToD) will now be needed.
  17. Fawkes Cat

    TIR For incorrect date on ticket.

    A wrong day (or date of birth) won't stop anything going ahead. There's a couple of reasons for this: - the practical one: if all you had to do to stop legal action was have the wrong name/date of birth, then no one would ever give the right details - everyone would say that they're called...
  18. Fawkes Cat

    Urgent Help Needed: Thameslink Fare Evasion Notice Received Late Due to Address Change

    That sounds like a good plan. Explain that you are seeking a statutory declaration, and ask if they will stop pursuing the debt for the moment. They may agree to do so (n.b. for frequent readers and contributors - I don't know if they will hold off on collection - but it seems to me that asking...
  19. Fawkes Cat

    Penalty Fare Appeal - Station was Unknowingly Open

    Just a point - in the local dialect, the name of the main station in Liverpool reduces to 'Lime Street' rather than 'Lime'. Similarly, I would expect Headbolt Lane to remain as that rather than 'Headbolt': it's fairly standard in British English (including Scouse) for street names to retain the...
  20. Fawkes Cat

    Penalty Fare Notice Help Needed - Birmingham New Street to University, missed stop and got off train at Selly Oak 2 minutes after - 2nd Appeal Help

    At the risk of drifting off topic, while that might be what the law says, it doesn't seem to be how appeal panels (even the third level panels) interpret it. A few months ago we did see a number of appeals upheld on other grounds when in practice 'incorrect wording' seemed to be the real...

Top