• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

UK switching to electric vehicles discussion

Peter Sarf

Established Member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
9,842
Location
Croydon

Report on UK (and Australia) dealers refusing to take many diesel cars in for part exchange and resale values falling up to 30% because, most likely due to fuel prices, very few people want one.

I'm definitely glad I got rid of mine when I did.
Interesting. A friend of mine has just changed his non-ULEZ compliant diesel for a newer compliant diesel. He lives in the leafy suburbs of Guildford but comes to London occasionally. I wonder what he got for his old diesel !.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
113,923
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
Interesting. A friend of mine has just changed his non-ULEZ compliant diesel for a newer compliant diesel. He lives in the leafy suburbs of Guildford but comes to London occasionally. I wonder what he got for his old diesel !.

Out of curiosity I put my petrol estate car into WeBuyAnyCar's website about 2 months ago and it offered £8K ish, I thought crikey, that's depreciated.

A couple of days ago I was bored and clicked the link in one of their spam emails about the valuation having updated...now £12K.

I assume this is probably related to diesel being even more out of favour than ever, and so people who like ICE cars are after petrol in their droves, given that WBAC prices are very closely driven by what they'll get for the cars at auction and on Cinch.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,989
Location
UK
WBAC offer low prices. You can always do better on a trade-in or selling privately.

I took a car to them to see what they'd offer (I wasn't desperate to sell, which I think many people are). They give the usual quote online and then you make an appointment etc. I turned up and without even opening the doors he dropped the price saying it wasn't what they were looking for but they could organise payment quickly if I went inside.

I know they won't always test drive or thoroughly inspect (would the staff member even know how to?) but this was a joke. It wasn't even a few quid off - it was about two grand off.

I said forget it, and he said he'd call the boss to try and negotiate a better deal but I said no thanks - and he started cursing me for wasting his time.

Sadly I don't trust their figures any more, and when I came to sell the car and didn't want any fuss I went through Motorway and got more than they'd estimated. Car picked up shortly after and money in the account within seconds.

Could I have got more private? Possibly, but I was happy and got more than the estimate (which was based on a huge number of photos and questions and answers to give them an idea of the car condition - something WBAC didn't do when when they had the car in front of them!).
 

Peter Sarf

Established Member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
9,842
Location
Croydon
I took a car to them to see what they'd offer (I wasn't desperate to sell, which I think many people are). They give the usual quote online and then you make an appointment etc. I turned up and without even opening the doors he dropped the price saying it wasn't what they were looking for but they could organise payment quickly if I went inside.

I know they won't always test drive or thoroughly inspect (would the staff member even know how to?) but this was a joke. It wasn't even a few quid off - it was about two grand off.

I said forget it, and he said he'd call the boss to try and negotiate a better deal but I said no thanks - and he started cursing me for wasting his time.

Sadly I don't trust their figures any more, and when I came to sell the car and didn't want any fuss I went through Motorway and got more than they'd estimated. Car picked up shortly after and money in the account within seconds.

Could I have got more private? Possibly, but I was happy and got more than the estimate (which was based on a huge number of photos and questions and answers to give them an idea of the car condition - something WBAC didn't do when when they had the car in front of them!).
The only use for We Buy Any Car (.con) is if you can offer slightly more to someone who has got a derisory face to face offer from them.
They will always offer enough on the web to get you to trek over to their lair. You are now at risk of being hooked in. They then offer you less but still boast of quick payment, no time wasting and its all done asap. Take it or leave it. Biggest bunch of tyre kickers.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,989
Location
UK
The only use for We Buy Any Car (.con) is if you can offer slightly more to someone who has got a derisory face to face offer from them.
They will always offer enough on the web to get you to trek over to their lair. You are now at risk of being hooked in. They then offer you less but still boast of quick payment, no time wasting and its all done asap. Take it or leave it. Biggest bunch of tyre kickers.

Yup they were exactly as I feared, but if you want a fairer deal then Motorway (there are others now too, although they could be 'white labels' for the same auction companies?) is also pretty quick and they come to you.

They find out everything about your vehicle ahead of time and so won't do the 'hmmmm, well, sorry but this isn't in good enough condition' before they've even fully stepped out of their hut or office.

My advice for any of these options is to not try and sell when you're desperate. Obviously easier said than done because there might be a sudden emergency need for money, but what I mean is if you're considering a sale then don't rush. There are other options than WBAC despite their slick advertising and their more recent strategy of having tiny cabins in car parks up and down the country (rather than previously hiring offices in the likes of Regus).

This means they must get people passing by who are tempted and don't do any research at all.
 

cactustwirly

Established Member
Joined
10 Apr 2013
Messages
8,427
Location
UK
Out of curiosity I put my petrol estate car into WeBuyAnyCar's website about 2 months ago and it offered £8K ish, I thought crikey, that's depreciated.

A couple of days ago I was bored and clicked the link in one of their spam emails about the valuation having updated...now £12K.

I assume this is probably related to diesel being even more out of favour than ever, and so people who like ICE cars are after petrol in their droves, given that WBAC prices are very closely driven by what they'll get for the cars at auction and on Cinch.

We buy any car are the same company as BCA and Cinch.
It is nowhere what the car is worth. It's the auction price minus the BCA cut.
Just like part exchanging a car
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,989
Location
UK
I think we're seeing 100kW or thereabouts becoming a sweet spot for smaller cars with 40-50kWh batteries.

I do think we'll see some small battery cars come with faster charging in the future, which would allow a car offering only 150 miles or so a rapid petrol station like top up, but that will probably be more because increased competition forces it to become another selling point that it being demanded by customers.
 

birchesgreen

Established Member
Joined
18 Aug 2015
Messages
7,692
Location
Solihull
Pity Rover isn't still around, they could have done a retro e-Metro or e-Maestro, i've love something like that! As for the 2EV i like it though i'd still rather have a Renault 5.
 

JamesT

Established Member
Joined
25 Feb 2015
Messages
4,919
Pity Rover isn't still around, they could have done a retro e-Metro or e-Maestro, i've love something like that! As for the 2EV i like it though i'd still rather have a Renault 5.
The Rover brand has ended up with Tata as part of Jaguar Land Rover. So they could launch something under that name if they wanted to.
But I think most people would have a negative association with a Rover car rather than a positive one!
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,989
Location
UK
The Everything Electric show has featured the new Citroen 2CV.


Dear Santa...

Also great to see the Smart #2 announced (which goes on sale quite soon). A more premium small car but very likely to sell very well even if it's more expensive than other cars in its class.
 

Mawkie

Established Member
Joined
17 Feb 2016
Messages
1,299
Indeed. The only Austin/Rover car that people associate strongly positively with is the Mini, and there are a load of modern versions of that, many of which aren't particularly mini! :)
I can't see an Austin 'E-leggro' selling well, although square steering wheels seem de rigueur these days. :D
 

johncrossley

Established Member
Joined
30 Mar 2021
Messages
4,476
Location
London
There are now quite a few videos about the new Smart #2 (pronounced "hashtag two" it seems, whereas the petrol Smart that most people know was called the "Fortwo"), for example this one from What Car:


We've seen the new Smart #2! Smart's tiny two-seat city car is back for 2027, with a more modern look, a rear-mounted 80bhp motor and a likely range of around 180 miles. But how does it compare against the likes of the Honda Super N and Renault Twingo? In this first look review, we tell you everything we know so far about the Smart #2.

The range is not officially confirmed but they have a "target" of 180 miles. The video says charging is capped at 65 kWh and will take 20 minutes to charge from 10-80% at that speed. So 20 minutes charge to go 127 miles. Is that good? The video says this is good compared to the Honda Super N and Renault Twingo.
 

The Ham

Veteran Member
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
12,064
There are now quite a few videos about the new Smart #2 (pronounced "hashtag two" it seems, whereas the petrol Smart that most people know was called the "Fortwo"), for example this one from What Car:




The range is not officially confirmed but they have a "target" of 180 miles. The video says charging is capped at 65 kWh and will take 20 minutes to charge from 10-80% at that speed. So 20 minutes charge to go 127 miles. Is that good? The video says this is good compared to the Honda Super N and Renault Twingo.

That's likely to mean a circa 2 hour trip should be doable without charging (in the winter, rough ballpark of usable milage being 55% of quoted range) and you'll then need 20 minutes to do circa 3.25 hours of driving.

However, as I highlight, typically most people would be best to stop for a break in that time anyway (even if it's just a loo break) and from parked to back to the car can easily be 10 minutes anyway (especially at larger motorway services).

Also, someone owning such a car probably are the reason we can do 6 return trips of 240 miles each way a year and the average number of trips of over 50 miles is lower than that.

That's not to say they won't do them, it's just that it'll be fairly unusual, as that would likely be the small run around with a larger car for other trips.

If its £13,000 new (even £14,000) that's going to be very much in the price range which could mean £120/month lease costs and so a good entry level EV for commuting up to 30 miles a day (might just get away with charging twice a week, or 5 times a fortnight).

That would compare with a fuel bill of around £95 a month, and so the cost of say £25 a month plus £1,600 up front, would mean a cost of £2,500 for 3 years.

Even allowing for some resale value that's quite a cheap car to buy second hand as an alternative and finding one where you do well and there's no major maintenance needed.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,989
Location
UK
Possibly worth noting that smart is no longer a Mercedes brand

It's now a joint venture. Despite Geely's involvement, there are distinct differences between a Smart car and, say, the Volvo version built on the same platform. It's not like Stellantis where you'd expect to see loads of components shared.

It will be interesting to see if Geely makes any other versions of the Smart #2 for its other brands. Probably not Volvo though!

In any case, the Smart #2 is the perfect successor to the previous model (and now it has a suitable battery to go with). I've always liked the car since I got one of the first generation models to review for a magazine (we were using it to test Bluetooth car kits and equipment, not the car itself) and if it wasn't for the fact they're pretty expensive for what they are, I'd have maybe had one as a second car. Now they're fully electric, I expect they'll be stupidly cheap to maintain and a second or third hand model could be a real bargain.
 

Noddy

Established Member
Joined
11 Oct 2014
Messages
1,660
Location
UK
If its £13,000 new (even £14,000) that's going to be very much in the price range which could mean £120/month lease costs and so a good entry level EV for commuting up to 30 miles a day (might just get away with charging twice a week, or 5 times a fortnight).
That would compare with a fuel bill of around £95 a month, and so the cost of say £25 a month plus £1,600 up front, would mean a cost of £2,500 for 3 years.

It’s worth noting that in an urban commuting context achievable mileage will often exceed the WLTP range figure as the typical speeds are rarely in excess of 40 mph (and are often much lower). I regularly see 5.5-6kwh per mile on these types of journeys in a larger car so these lighter A segment cars should achieve even higher figures.
 

Mawkie

Established Member
Joined
17 Feb 2016
Messages
1,299
It’s worth noting that in an urban commuting context achievable mileage will often exceed the WLTP range figure as the typical speeds are rarely in excess of 40 mph (and are often much lower). I regularly see 5.5-6kwh per mile on these types of journeys in a larger car so these lighter A segment cars should achieve even higher figures.
Do you mean miles per kWh?

I regularly achieve good efficiency in my Tesla - urban driving, approximately 10 miles each way commute.

Screenshot_2026-10-14-08-54-48-36_92460851df6f172a4592fca41cc2d2e6.jpg
121.6 wh/miles = 8.2 miles per kWh (was my best efficiency over summer).

169.1 wh/miles = 5.91 miles per kWh (over a slightly longer distance).

Worse in winter of course.
 

Snow1964

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2019
Messages
11,292
Location
West Wiltshire
There are now quite a few videos about the new Smart #2 (pronounced "hashtag two" it seems, whereas the petrol Smart that most people know was called the "Fortwo"), for example this one from What Car:




The range is not officially confirmed but they have a "target" of 180 miles. The video says charging is capped at 65 kWh and will take 20 minutes to charge from 10-80% at that speed. So 20 minutes charge to go 127 miles. Is that good? The video says this is good compared to the Honda Super N and Renault Twingo.
The range would be more than adequate for those who need a second car, or a car that is easy to park in congested city streets.

It is actually small enough that most people could get it in their garage (assuming it's not more than third full of junk) which might be relevant for those charging at home.

Alternatively getting a Smart #2 and a normal size car on some drives, that don't fit 2 normal sized cars might tip balance for some that need 2 cars.

As a guide a normal home charger (7kw) adds about 25-30 miles of range per hour, so usual 5-6 hour overnight EV cheap electricity tariff would add 130-180 miles, and for many will mean only plugging in every few days.

For occasional long trips, the 20 min adding around 130 miles at rapid chargers will not be unacceptable, and if fully charged before leaving home, would be able to do 300 miles with one well timed charging stop, and anyone doing a 4+ hour trip is generally going to stop somewhere anyway (even if it just toilet or coffee stop)
 

johncrossley

Established Member
Joined
30 Mar 2021
Messages
4,476
Location
London
Partnerships are normal for the Smart brand. The second generation Smart Fortwo had a Mitsubishi engine and the third generation was a partnership with Renault and shares a large proportion of components with the Renault Twingo.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

For occasional long trips, the 20 min adding around 130 miles at rapid chargers will not be unacceptable

I'm guessing you meant "will be acceptable"?
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,989
Location
UK
The good thing about a small car with a smaller battery is that the 20 minute charge will be cheaper than a 20 minute charge on a larger car with a huge battery needing more power.

It's often forgotten or not considered. These huge EVs with 100kWh batteries to add range, often at the expense of the miles per kWh, are less efficient and more costly.

We current compare EVs with ICE, but in the future when ICE is more or less not talked about, it will be an important factor to consider when choosing a car.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,989
Location
UK
The Smart battery has a 35.8 kWh capacity, so if the range is 180 miles that is approximately 5.03 miles per kWh.

That's excellent. Quite likely it could manage that or more if used in town at low speeds (especially 20mph zones).
 

Top