• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Proposed new Channel Tunnel services discussion

SHD

Member
Joined
18 Jul 2012
Messages
572
Look at a map and you will see that just south of the existing Lille Europe TGV station is the huge Lille Flandres rail complex where there is a fair bit of former sidings and waste land much of which is rarely used. OK its SNCF land so nothing happens quickly but there is the potential for the land to be made available to UK and continental operators to prepare and operate additional high speed services to destinations running right across Europe from Lille Europe. As these services would then be entirely within the EU/Schengen they would not need any Border passport control costs and permit sale of tickets for travel between intermediate stations.

If you are thinking of the site of the former Lille Saint Sauveur station, it is no more "SNCF" land, it was sold to Greater Lille (the Métropole Européenne de Lille in French) in 2017. At Fives, there's not much land available either. Lille Délivrance (west of the city, the site of the marshalling yard) would be more appropriate.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

NCT

Established Member
Joined
18 Apr 2025
Messages
2,322
Location
London
This would unfortunately require SNCF to run a passenger-centric railway that acknowledges people might not want to travel to or from Paris

It's not even that. There is a respectable number of Brussels - France Paris avoiding TGVs already running (granted there probably should be more). All that needs doing is putting them in standard hourly paths through Lille and Eurostar being proactive in selling connections.
 

Trainbike46

Established Member
Joined
18 Sep 2021
Messages
4,377
Location
belfast
Eurostar offering a service to Lille every hour would also help, e.g. by increasing the number of Brussels(-Amsterdam/Germany) services, or by introducing Lille calls on selected Paris services.
 

NCT

Established Member
Joined
18 Apr 2025
Messages
2,322
Location
London
Eurostar offering a service to Lille every hour would also help, e.g. by increasing the number of Brussels(-Amsterdam/Germany) services, or by introducing Lille calls on selected Paris services.

Connecting existing Eurostars and TGVs properly would have a greater impact than adding frequency to trains that don't connect.
 

30907

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Sep 2012
Messages
21,988
Location
Airedale
It's not even that. There is a respectable number of Brussels - France Paris avoiding TGVs already running (granted there probably should be more). All that needs doing is putting them in standard hourly paths through Lille and Eurostar being proactive in selling connections.
The service to Lyon is pretty standardised if not hourly (and would be better if Ouigo reverted to Inoui) - but then SNCF will only offer hourly if there is a massive demand (off-hand I think only Lyon and Lille meet that criterion).
 

NCT

Established Member
Joined
18 Apr 2025
Messages
2,322
Location
London
The service to Lyon is pretty standardised if not hourly (and would be better if Ouigo reverted to Inoui) - but then SNCF will only offer hourly if there is a massive demand (off-hand I think only Lyon and Lille meet that criterion).

I didn't mean all Brussels TGV routes should be hourly, but when a train runs it runs in a standard path of that hour, which based on Eurostar times at Lille, should be around xx30.
 

SynthD

Established Member
Joined
4 Apr 2020
Messages
2,057
Location
UK
So how can the UK offer better rail connections to Europe?
Agreed. I wonder if there is enough demand for these trains to start at Calais, a parkway station for those who have taken a car through the tunnel.

Taktfahrplan with British characteristics (border control and customs) is tricky to imagine. There would be a seemingly arbitrary division on which trains the ex London Eurostars can or can’t connect with, and based on variable queues this could be wildly inaccurate.
 

michael8

Member
Joined
13 Feb 2021
Messages
236
Location
UK
I may be wrong but I don't believe there is any stock left to run more services, both on the red and the blue sides.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==


That doesn't exist anymore, the fastest ferry outside of Dover-Calais/Dunkirk is Poole to Cherbourg at 4h30 and the overall cheapest for a foot passenger is Dieppe to Newhaven at between 4h30 and 5h (findable around £30)
I just found a crossing from Portsmouth to Cherbourg for £15 each way (return trip) but it is a 5h30 journey.
Maybe the fastcat option only exists in the summer months.
 

Austriantrain

Established Member
Joined
13 Aug 2018
Messages
1,812
Taktfahrplan with British characteristics (border control and customs) is tricky to imagine. There would be a seemingly arbitrary division on which trains the ex London Eurostars can or can’t connect with, and based on variable queues this could be wildly inaccurate.

I don‘t see why. 60 minutes in Lille on the return journey from France should always be sufficient. In any case, due to advance booking necessary on E*, they always can control what connections to offer. No one can simply walk up at Marseille to buy a ticket to London.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

I didn't mean all Brussels TGV routes should be hourly, but when a train runs it runs in a standard path of that hour, which based on Eurostar times at Lille, should be around xx30.

There is the additional issue with many trains now being Ouigo without any kind of through-ticketing, and starting from Lille Flandres. Of course, easy to change. If someone wanted too. So we are back to zero. Probably every single European railway (including the British) would do it, because it is so simple to do… every one except SNCF (and RENFE).

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

If you are thinking of the site of the former Lille Saint Sauveur station, it is no more "SNCF" land, it was sold to Greater Lille (the Métropole Européenne de Lille in French) in 2017. At Fives, there's not much land available either. Lille Délivrance (west of the city, the site of the marshalling yard) would be more appropriate.

In any case, a further station is not needed. What might help is a couple of stabling and servicing roads to the West of Europe so that TGV that don’t come from Brussels can stable there and not sit on a platform or back up to Fives.
 
Last edited:

NCT

Established Member
Joined
18 Apr 2025
Messages
2,322
Location
London
There is one potentially difficult issue.

In an unrestricted perfect takt world, a France - Brussels arrive on platform 43 at xx:27, Brussels - London service would arrive at Lille on platform 45 at xx:30, London service departs at xx:35, France - Brussels depart at xx:35. With passengers stepping back an hour, you'll have the TGV discharging 'dirty' passengers and Eurostar boarding 'sterile' passengers on the same platform island.

The TGV paths might have to be 20 minutes offset from the Eurostars (as most are now). The Lille shuffle interchange time would there fore be 80 minutes.
 

30907

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Sep 2012
Messages
21,988
Location
Airedale
I didn't mean all Brussels TGV routes should be hourly, but when a train runs it runs in a standard path of that hour, which based on Eurostar times at Lille, should be around xx30.
+/- xx50 is currently the norm, which I think is about right, giving a 20min connection from London. Not so good the other way though :(
 
Joined
7 Aug 2025
Messages
359
Location
Portsmouth
I just found a crossing from Portsmouth to Cherbourg for £15 each way (return trip) but it is a 5h30 journey.
Maybe the fastcat option only exists in the summer months.
Hasn't been a fast cat for a few years now - its on the Guernsey route. Fastest now is 4 hours Poole- Cherbourg, one a day
 

Austriantrain

Established Member
Joined
13 Aug 2018
Messages
1,812
There is one potentially difficult issue.

In an unrestricted perfect takt world, a France - Brussels arrive on platform 43 at xx:27, Brussels - London service would arrive at Lille on platform 45 at xx:30, London service departs at xx:35, France - Brussels depart at xx:35. With passengers stepping back an hour, you'll have the TGV discharging 'dirty' passengers and Eurostar boarding 'sterile' passengers on the same platform island.

The TGV paths might have to be 20 minutes offset from the Eurostars (as most are now). The Lille shuffle interchange time would there fore be 80 minutes.

SNCF would not vary much from the standard „full“ (occasionally „half“)-hour in Lyon - if there is a Takt in France, it is here (not least because the paths for the Massy - Lyon/CDG interconnections are fixed and it follows from there).

So Lille dep would be somewhere between xx:53 and xx:58 (xx:00 at the latest) as now. The typical E* arrives in Lille around xx:25, although it might be possible to use the xx:16 path ex St Pancras, meaning arr in Lille around xx:40 (but probably bad for connections in Brussels? I didn’t look it up).

Arrival from Lyon at Lille at xx:05 and departure to London at xx:35 would allow good separation on the „sterile“ platform, but realistically 90 minute interchange time, unless the process for border and security control can be speeded up a lot (and reliably).
 
Last edited:

NCT

Established Member
Joined
18 Apr 2025
Messages
2,322
Location
London
SNCF would not vary much from the standard „full“ (occasionally „half“)-hour in Lyon - if there is a Takt in France, it is here (not least because the paths for the Massy - Lyon/CDG interconnections are fixed and it follows from there).

So Lille dep would be somewhere between xx:53 and xx:58 (xx:00 at the latest) as now. The typical E* arrives in Lille around xx:25, although it might be possible to use the xx:16 path ex St Pancras, meaning arr in Lille around xx:40 (but probably bad for connections in Brussels? I didn’t look it up).

Arrival from Lyon at Lille at xx:05 and departure to London at xx:35 would allow good separation on the „sterile“ platform, but realistically 90 minute interchange time, unless the process for border and security control can be speeded up a lot (and reliably).


Hmmm, not sure the Lyon takt is all that tight. The Geneva direction has a /30 symmetry (22 arr 38 dep); Chambery is 15/45 (hourly); Macon and St Etienne are 15/45 (half hourly but with typical French holes). It feels more like a loose Dutch node than a tight Swiss node - it doesn't matter when your train arrives or leaves as long as the pattern is symmetrical and consistent (consistent calling pattern between Lyon and Lille, no randomness at Arras or Haute Picardie).

But yes, there probably will have to be sufficient daylight between sterile Eurostar and 'dirty' TGV trains, and the London direction Lille shuffle will have to be 1 hour + daylight.
 
Last edited:

Austriantrain

Established Member
Joined
13 Aug 2018
Messages
1,812
Hmmm, not sure the Lyon takt is all that tight. The Geneva direction has a /30 symmetry (22 arr 38 dep); Chambery is 15/45 (hourly); Macon and St Etienne are 15/45 (half hourly but with typical French holes). It feels more like a loose Dutch node than a tight Swiss node - it doesn't matter when your train arrives or leaves as long as the pattern is symmetrical and consistent (consistent calling pattern between Lyon and Lille, no randomness at Arras or Haute Picardie).

But yes, there probably will have to be sufficient daylight between sterile Eurostar and 'dirty' TGV trains, and the London direction Lille shuffle will have to be 1 hour + daylight.

From what I gather from French discussions and Blogs over the years, the Massy - Grande Ceinture - LGV line is one of the most significant timetabling factors for French TGV timetabling (the other one being, no surprise, Lyon Part-Dieu), because of the interplay with RER C and freight. Not much moving around there (although I always thought you should be able to move the path by 15 minutes, but I really don’t know if I am right). From there, in a Takt (and SNCF reseau has a Takt of course on the LGVs in timetable planning) everything else follows and it pretty much dictates a Lille - Lyon at the full hour in Lyon.
 

Alpine Rider

Member
Joined
2 Jan 2023
Messages
57
Location
Abondance France
As you will see the potential transfer times for outward journeys from UK Eurostar arriving at Lille Europe and TGV departures range widely - between 30 minutes and well over an hour.

https://showmethejourney.com/train-...ance/cities/lille/rail-stations/lille-europe/

The short connection time on Sunday is usually doable as passenger numbers are lower than weekdays and of course all passport and border formalities were completed in the UK. The train manager will usually be able to advise the Lille Europe platform for your connecting service.

However in the reverse direction - anyone planning to board a service to the UK - it is wise to allow at least one hour for a connection - most of which will be fighting through EU and then UK Border Force checks. Note catering at Lille Europe is dismal and seating limited.

In theory the border process should get quicker once most travellers have already registered for EES, ETIAS and the UK Electronic Travel Authorisation systems. Time will tell.

The other thing to be aware of is that some "value" TGV services operated by Ouigo depart from the nearby Lille Flandres station (about 10 minutes walk).
 

WibbleWobble

Member
Joined
19 Aug 2022
Messages
617
Location
.
The other thing to be aware of is that some "value" TGV services operated by Ouigo depart from the nearby Lille Flandres station (about 10 minutes walk).
Not sure if still the case, but I've used Lille Flandres on regular inOui TGV services in the past.
 

Snow1964

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2019
Messages
11,233
Location
West Wiltshire
SNCF voyagers has ordered 15 Avelia Horizon trains from Alstom, quad voltage versions which suggests they are for International services.

Probably not for channel tunnel, but I thought it worth posting as it might be more services and destinations that could potentially be reached from Lille or Paris.

However at this stage can't rule out the Board of SNCF secretly giving itself option to reach London, by not yet announcing where they will be deployed

  • This optional tranche of the framework contract between SNCF Voyageurs and Alstom is worth approximately 600 million euros
  • The new Avelia Horizon trains will be operated in Europe.
19 January 2026 – The Board of Directors of SNCF Voyageurs has approved an additional order for 15 new-generation Avelia Horizon very high-speed trains (known in France as TGV), worth approximately 600 million euros1 . Deliveries are expected in 2029.

This order is for the quad-voltage version of the new generation of high-speed trains, which meets European traffic requirements. The Avelia Horizon range meets ambitious objectives in terms of competitiveness in the rail sector and profitability for SNCF Voyageurs.​
 

Birkonian

Member
Joined
19 Sep 2017
Messages
292
All the Paris services plus some "cross-country" ones.
Europe is quiet and rather impersonal. Flandres is a busy 'proper' station. I'd say 7 minutes walk maximum from Europe. Flandres has plenty of bars over the road for refreshments. There are many better bars elsewhere in the city, but the ones nearest to the station stock acceptabe local/Belgian beers.
 

Austriantrain

Established Member
Joined
13 Aug 2018
Messages
1,812
Europe is quiet and rather impersonal. Flandres is a busy 'proper' station. I'd say 7 minutes walk maximum from Europe. Flandres has plenty of bars over the road for refreshments. There are many better bars elsewhere in the city, but the ones nearest to the station stock acceptabe local/Belgian beers.

Yes, and for people with luggage and no local knowledge, the walk (or VAL) will be enough to put them off using a connection from E* to a TGV, never mind the beer.
 

Birkonian

Member
Joined
19 Sep 2017
Messages
292
Yes, and for people with luggage and no local knowledge, the walk (or VAL) will be enough to put them off using a connection from E* to a TGV, never mind the beer.
I've walked from Europe to Flandres. It couldn't be easier. Go down the escalator and keep walking. Easier and quicker than, for instance, finding your way to the Eurostar terminal at St. Pancras from the tube.
 

TheWierdOne

Member
Joined
30 Oct 2020
Messages
424
Location
Yorkshire
Well after a period of silence Eurostar appears to have learnt how to share their toys with Virgin Trains. Rail magazine reporting today that a draft depot access agreement has been submitted to the ORR. No word on any details of the agreement but it is said the ORR will be getting things moving within a few weeks on directing the contract.


In a joint statement, the two operators said: “Following productive discussions with the ORR, we’re pleased this first milestone towards the depot access agreement has been met.

“We will continue to work collaboratively going forward on all the technical work necessary and to prepare the depot.”

ORR will now review the documents with both parties before directing the contract in a few weeks’ time.
 

MarkyT

Established Member
Joined
20 May 2012
Messages
7,609
Location
Torbay
I've walked from Europe to Flandres. It couldn't be easier.
~350m to the side entrance at Flandres. Shorter than a Eurostar. About 5 mins on foot. Obvious and visible. No roads to cross. Can be mostly under cover if desired, first under the elevated highway spans of Ave Le Corbusier, then cutting across to the higher level walkway beneath the office and hotel blocks on the north west side of the huge shopping centre. It's MUCH nicer than St Martins Queensway and you don't feel pressured into wasting time and money going through the shopping centre, though it's there, just to the side if you need to buy something or have some time to kill.
 

Sorcerer

Established Member
Joined
20 May 2022
Messages
2,197
Location
Liverpool
Well after a period of silence Eurostar appears to have learnt how to share their toys with Virgin Trains. Rail magazine reporting today that a draft depot access agreement has been submitted to the ORR. No word on any details of the agreement but it is said the ORR will be getting things moving within a few weeks on directing the contract.

Great news actually, the lack of silence means things have been productive. I would expect dramatic headlines if Eurostar weren't playing ball. I suspect the biggest obstacle will be SNCF agreeing to track access on the LGV Nord given they're not too keen on competition even if by EU law they have to allow it.
 

NCT

Established Member
Joined
18 Apr 2025
Messages
2,322
Location
London
Great news actually, the lack of silence means things have been productive. I would expect dramatic headlines if Eurostar weren't playing ball. I suspect the biggest obstacle will be SNCF agreeing to track access on the LGV Nord given they're not too keen on competition even if by EU law they have to allow it.

Have SNCF Reseaux been historically obstructive? That's not the general impression I'm getting (a complete outsider's impression I hasten to add) - given the numerous new entrants that have secured access agreements.
 

TheWierdOne

Member
Joined
30 Oct 2020
Messages
424
Location
Yorkshire
Great news actually, the lack of silence means things have been productive. I would expect dramatic headlines if Eurostar weren't playing ball. I suspect the biggest obstacle will be SNCF agreeing to track access on the LGV Nord given they're not too keen on competition even if by EU law they have to allow it.
It Eurostar have capitulated I would hope SNCF, being the majority owner of Eurostar, have given up on trying to completely shut down any competitors. Blocking access to LGV Nord would almost certainly provoke a legal challenge, and in any case SNCF didn’t try to pull that with Trenitalia on LGV Sud-Est so I’d be surprised if they start now, even if they’re up against a private company rather than a state-backed operator.
 

Sorcerer

Established Member
Joined
20 May 2022
Messages
2,197
Location
Liverpool
Have SNCF Reseaux been historically obstructive? That's not the general impression I'm getting (a complete outsider's impression I hasten to add) - given the numerous new entrants that have secured access agreements.
The impression I've gotten is that SNCF aren't too keen on competition, though to be fair it's an understandable view given that they're financing an entire network while open-access operators are cherry-picking the profitable routes (though this has worked both ways, especially in Spain). I might be overestimating their view on competition though so my word is about as reliable as anyone else's. If Jon Worth told me otherwise tomorrow I'd believe him.

It Eurostar have capitulated I would hope SNCF, being the majority owner of Eurostar, have given up on trying to completely shut down any competitors. Blocking access to LGV Nord would almost certainly provoke a legal challenge, and in any case SNCF didn’t try to pull that with Trenitalia on LGV Sud-Est so I’d be surprised if they start now, even if they’re up against a private company rather than a state-backed operator.
Eurostar still has capacity as an independent company even if it is owned largely by SNCF. But in any case I think you're right. Again I might be overestimating their reluctance to accept competition.
 

Austriantrain

Established Member
Joined
13 Aug 2018
Messages
1,812
Have SNCF Reseaux been historically obstructive? That's not the general impression I'm getting (a complete outsider's impression I hasten to add) - given the numerous new entrants that have secured access agreements.

It has been said here recently by someone who seemed well informed that SNCF Réseau have changed their tune in recent years because they want and need the track access income. Obviously SNCF Voyageurs is still not keen on it.
 

Top