Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!
I don't care for putting flags on everything but taking the design as it is, it's a little bit like the (much better colours) Transpennine Express livery. The front should be red or white though.
- Far too busy and full on
- Jarring angles and no use of soft curves akin to a flag fluttering in the breeze - see British Airways for more details
- No flow along the length of the train, so no impression of speed and sleekness
- The overuse of a deep blue and red combination - best used sparingly in my opinion - makes the trains look dark, heavy and slow, surely the opposite of what ought to be the main idea?
I'd run an open competition where professional design houses pitch their ideas with the best going forward to a public consultation. It's our railway (so we're being told) after all.
- Far too busy and full on
- Jarring angles and no use of soft curves akin to a flag fluttering in the breeze - see British Airways for more details
- No flow along the length of the train, so no impression of speed and sleekness
- The overuse of a deep blue and red combination - best used sparingly in my opinion - makes the trains look dark, heavy and slow, surely the opposite of what ought to be the main idea?
I'd run an open competition where professional design houses pitch their ideas with the best going forward to a public consultation. It's our railway (so we're being told) after all.
For me it's not the colours that are the problem, they could be made to look really nice. It's the angular design, with some colours being stark contrasts whereas others barely noticeable. It feels rushed and rather amateur. I'm sure using curves, or blending colour changes a bit more would make it look less harsh and more organic. And I agree with others than the end car designs should not be replicated within the rest of the sets.
That's going to go down well with the Nationalists (including of course the Scottish Government). I look forward to the front page of tomorrow's National 'newspaper'.....
But I’d always seen flag waving as something a nation insecure in their identity has to do (eg the US, or a military dictatorship somewhere). I’d always seen the UK as more grown up. Not any more…
You need to get out more, respectfully. There are national flags everywhere in many tolerant and liberal countries, and the vacation of our national flag from mainstream places is what has left it open to be used as a signal of intolerance by people on the fringe.
Sadly, the livery as depicted looks tacky and cheap to me. The intermediate coaches' arrows look awkward and the colours themselves are garish and lack any elegance. I really hope the opportunity is taken to make this better before we are doomed to this for xx years to come.
That's going to go down well with the Nationalists (including of course the Scottish Government). I look forward to the front page of tomorrow's National 'newspaper'.....
Disagree. Rail Alphabet 2 is a utilitarian font totally unsuitable for a logotype. By all means (much as I dislike it with a passion) use it on signage and the likes because while it looks utterly awful it is clear and easy to read, but a logo needs a more designer font to work well. See also Avanti's awful use of a Helvetica like font on the abbreviated (just "A") logo.
Yes, SBB works well with a Helvetica font, but that's (a) because Helvetica is specifically associated to Switzerland, (b) because Helvetica, unlike RA2, is actually a nice font (OK, this is opinion), and (c) the livery it sits on is in line with the font's utilitarian design in being basic and understated despite using some bright colour.
It would look a lot better without any of the lettering and just the double arrow.
I suspect no train will ever wear that specific design given the utter slating it is getting, even from the Reformers and the likes. They'll try again before anything gets painted in it.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
I doubt it will be applied to ScotRail, TfW, TfL or Merseyrail, aside from where you see Network Rail branding on those now. In essence it will just replace any Network Rail branding in those devolved areas. I'd also expect not to see it on any Bee Network, Weaver Network (nee Metro), Tyne and Wear or West Midlands devolved services and other areas which may devolve their GBR operated services in a similar way, just as those areas had dedicated liveries in BR days.
But I’d always seen flag waving as something a nation insecure in their identity has to do (eg the US, or a military dictatorship somewhere). I’d always seen the UK as more grown up. Not any more…
Alright, so I’ve seen the display they’ve got at London Bridge station. They’ve got a small Hornby layout with an IET in the new livery. It DOES look a bit better on a model, I see what they’re getting at. But it’s still a bit too much.
Glasgow Central's had GBR branding put all over it this morning, interesting considering how Scotland''s in large part excluded from GBR related things with the devolution of ScotRail and the like.
You need to get out more, respectfully. There are national flags everywhere in many tolerant and liberal countries, and the vacation of our national flag from mainstream places is what has left it open to be used as a signal of intolerance by people on the fringe.
I'm at a 150 countries ticked off, so have been out plenty! But it's an interest take with a lot of merit that not using the flag has allowed the takeover.
We are aware of an issue with emails from the Forum to Microsoft-based email accounts (hotmail/outlook/live.com email addresses). This is being looked into currently, thanks for your patience meanwhile.