Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!
You would only avoid it, though, if you did a major renaming, like to Selly Oak North or something. If it still had University in the name it wouldn't solve it. The solution is for staff to use a bit of nous.
In the example I gave, it would certainly have been resolved by the inclusion of the word Birmingham. Had that been there, the chances of anyone being directed towards a Clifton-bound bus at Bristol Temple Meads would, I suspect have been zero. I’m sure that even without my intervention both parties would have realised they were at cross purposes, but possibly not until the would be traveller had reached the bus stop.
It's probably just as well that systems are generally only GB-wide rather than UK. Or someone asking for University might be sold a ticket that includes SailRail
I know - the point I was trying to make that it is probably closer to New Street than the University of Birmingham so the argument “it’s 5 minutes short of New Street, so of course ‘University’ must mean The University of Birmingham” doesn’t hold water.
Indeed there are multiple universities in the West Midlands area, and several universities that have campuses remote from the place they take their name from. It's all very well for us on a rail forum to say "it doesn't need changing because it's obvious" when we're clearly going to be more informed about which institutions have stations serving them. Students who aren't transport nerds, or are from overseas where things are done differently, wouldn't necessarily be as au fait with the quirks of our national rail system or our esoteric naming conventions for HE establishments. To suggest that "maybe higher education isn't for you" as someone did, is ridiculously myopic.
My alma mater, Edge Hill University (though it was just a satellite college of Lancaster University in my day) is in Ormskirk- and has notes on the website and in the prospectus warning potential students not to alight at Edge Hill station in Liverpool. Admittedly EHU isn't the school of choice for the best and brightest, but my point still stands. What's obvious to us on here isn't necessarily obvious to everyone else, and that doesn't make everyone else stupid.
But the basic answer is that City Thameslink is a London Terminal from the South (replacing Holborn Viaduct) but Farringdon is a Thameslink Station only. Moorgate
I know - the point I was trying to make that it is probably closer to Nee Street than the University of Birmingham so the argument “it’s 5 minutes short of New Street, so of course ‘University’ must mean The University of Birmingham” doesn’t hold water.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
But why does the fact that it is 5 minutes short of New Street automatically mean to someone who has no knowledge of the geography of Birmingham, that the University concerned is “obviously” Birmingham University? There is no ban on other universities being 5 minutes short of New Street.
But why does the fact that it is 5 minutes short of New Street automatically mean to someone who has no knowledge of the geography of Birmingham, that the University concerned is “obviously” Birmingham University? There is no ban on other universities being 5 minutes short of New Street.
That assumes a degree of local knowledge - you know, and I know that there is more than 1 University in Birmingham. Someone heading for one of the others might not. You clearly think that it is “obvious” that “University” means “located near the University of Birmingham” (even in an announcement at Cardiff, for example). I (and apparently others) do not - I don’t think that’s going to change, so will leave it there.
That assumes a degree of local knowledge - you know, and I know that there is more than 1 University in Birmingham. Someone heading for one of the others might not. You clearly think that it is “obvious” that “University” means “located near the University of Birmingham” (even in an announcement at Cardiff, for example). I (and apparently others) do not - I don’t think that’s going to change, so will leave it there.
Thinking aloud, are there other cases of a terminus station that’s named after a road and doesn’t have a prefix before it? This used to be the case for most London termini. Fenchurch Street is often heard on its own. Any others?
It's probably just as well that systems are generally only GB-wide rather than UK. Or someone asking for University might be sold a ticket that includes SailRail
I presume that you are alluding to University station on the Coleraine to Portrush branch line, serving the University of Ulster, which as in Birmingham has no qualifier in its name. Personally, I think that both these heavy rail stations need to have a more specific identifier.
10 pages and nobody's mentioned Stratford International, with no international services?
Or am I missing something!
I'd suggest renaming it Stratford East Village or Stratford Olympic Park.
Although it would make trips to France easier if they just made it an international station, given that I can see onto the platforms from my living room!
The 'old uni of' will always have the default status whereas those 'polytechnics of university standards' will always be referred to by their qualifiers.
0 pages and nobody's mentioned Stratford International, with no international services?
Or am I missing something!
I'd suggest renaming it Stratford East Village or Stratford Olympic Park.
Although it would make trips to France easier if they just made it an international station, given that I can see onto the platforms from my living room!
I agree it should be called Stratford Olympic Park. It would make more sense than International as it pays homage to the Olympic legacy and has a nice ring to it as a name.
Streatham to Streatham Wells
Tooting to South Tooting
Old Oak Common to North Pole Junction
Chiswick to Chiswick South
Goodge Street to Fitzrovia
Old Street to West Shoreditch
I’d rename Catford to something. Maybe something like Catford Chatham or Catford High Level or something
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
On the London Underground Turnham Green and Chiswick Park have always seemed to be the wrong way round. Chiswick Park station is nearer to the open space called Turnham Green. Turnham Green station is opposite Chiswick Common and the nearest station for the High Street.
I was going to mention this. Given that the original settlement of Chiswick was by the Thames, nearer to the SWR station, maybe it could be called Old Chiswick? Needless to say, I wish Turnham Green was called New Chiswick or something
I’d also rename the Bethnal Green on the overground something like Whitechapel North, Bethnal Green Junction or Bethnal Great Eastern
I agree it should be called Stratford Olympic Park. It would make more sense than International as it pays homage to the Olympic legacy and has a nice ring to it as a name.
You'd probably have to call it Stratford Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park if doing that. I don't think the International name is a particular problem, as you have to book International trains in advance so will know to go to St Pancras.
If we were renaming trains to reflect whether they had accurate services we'd have had to rename Ebbsfleet and Ashford when COVID started and then back again if they ever restart.
You'd probably have to call it Stratford Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park if doing that. I don't think the International name is a particular problem, as you have to book International trains in advance so will know to go to St Pancras.
If we were renaming trains to reflect whether they had accurate services we'd have had to rename Ebbsfleet and Ashford when COVID started and then back again if they ever restart.
Well, the New Street in Birmingham was first laid out in the 11th century and was named in Latin. People alive today should live to see its millennial anniversary.
Ah yes, but this thread is about station names, Birmingham New Street is named after the street, thus renaming the street is outside the scope of this thread.
We are aware of an issue with emails from the Forum to Microsoft-based email accounts (hotmail/outlook/live.com email addresses). This is being looked into currently, thanks for your patience meanwhile.