• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

UK switching to electric vehicles discussion

Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

E27007

Member
Joined
25 May 2018
Messages
1,044
Government announces subsidy grant for EVs priced under £37k



The headline news of the launch of Govt subsidy funding worth £650mn needs expansion "the small print", the subsidy funding is for the purchase of new ZEVs until 2029, .
The FT reports, there will be eligibility scoring for ZEVs, the score will be based on, vehicle RRP with a maximum of £37,000, manufacturing -sustainability, carbon emissions of of the electricity grid of the country of origin.
ZEVs which meet the highest scores will be eligible a subsidy of up to £3750, some which are below the highest scores eligible for a subsidy of up to £1500, others will receive zero subsidy, the FT reports most Chinese-made ZEVs will receive zero subsidy.
Manufacturers to enter the funding scheme must have a net-zero target for their models , under the criteria for elegibilty, battery production and vehicle assembly will be treated as individual processes.
 

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,912
Tell that to Americans in the midwest who drive for 19 hours and take one or two breaks.
Irrelevant in the context of the thread discussion about the UK transition to EVs.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

There are three toilets in my house. My in laws have two. There are toilets in lots of shops, pubs and car parks.

At the Norwich & Norfolk Hospital Zapmap says there are 25 charging points in the multistory car park at the top of this map. There are lots of other car parks, which don't have chargers, and they are more convenient for many of the wards. There are lots of toilets.

View attachment 183944

It is easier to find a toilet in Norfolk than it is to find a charger for an electric car.
So what? It's also easier to find a toilet than a petrol pump.
 

Snow1964

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2019
Messages
11,255
Location
West Wiltshire
There is update of the number of public chargers in UK

82,002 chargers, of which 16,677 are rapid (over 50kw)


Doesn't give any indication of geographic spread, although the average is about 120 per parliamentary constituency, it is known to be a very uneven distribution.
 

styles

Established Member
Joined
7 Dec 2014
Messages
4,961
Location
Gwynedd
There is update of the number of public chargers in UK

82,002 chargers, of which 16,677 are rapid (over 50kw)


Doesn't give any indication of geographic spread, although the average is about 120 per parliamentary constituency, it is known to be a very uneven distribution.
In 2023, London had just under a third of all the UK's EV chargers. Even factoring in different EV ownership rates and populations, London has 3x as many EV chargers per EV owned as the national average.

The Mayor also claims that by volume and by proportion, London has the most rapid and public EV chargers of any European city, which is a bold claim, but even if it's slightly off, it's a pretty good achievement.. for London.

The rest of the UK is lacking in comparison. Though equally I don't think it's as bad as some EV opponents make out. I know plenty of EV owners and none of them have mentioned finding a place to charge as a downside, except in remote places (e.g. one pal staying at Glenbrittle SYHA found both the Portree chargers were out of action).
 

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,912
The rest of the UK is lacking in comparison. Though equally I don't think it's as bad as some EV opponents make out. I know plenty of EV owners and none of them have mentioned finding a place to charge as a downside, except in remote places (e.g. one pal staying at Glenbrittle SYHA found both the Portree chargers were out of action).
As an EV driver I think current provision is adequate and getting better all the time as new chargers are going in all over the place.
I haven't queued for a charge for over 2 years now.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,951
Location
UK
As an EV driver I think current provision is adequate and getting better all the time as new chargers are going in all over the place.
I haven't queued for a charge for over 2 years now.

I noticed a small queue for the Ionity charges at Peterborough services, where there were only 6 bays.. but they are in the process of adding what appears to be another 10-20 bays so I doubt there will be queues then. There was also a small Gridserve area too, but these were chargers with CCS + CHAdeMO, so if you needed one charger type over another and it was already used by the adjacent bay, you couldn't charge.

Newer ones will have two CCS and maybe a third CHAdeMO, so only two CHAdeMO users will have to wait for a cable. I expect in due course, they'll all become CCS only and users of cars with CHAdeMO will just need to carry an adapter.
 

bspahh

Established Member
Joined
5 Jan 2017
Messages
2,444
The rest of the UK is lacking in comparison. Though equally I don't think it's as bad as some EV opponents make out. I know plenty of EV owners and none of them have mentioned finding a place to charge as a downside, except in remote places (e.g. one pal staying at Glenbrittle SYHA found both the Portree chargers were out of action).
The British Vehicle Rental & Leasing Association has a campaign to increase the number of destination chargers It has a link to write to your MP.

It says:"EV charging infrastructure is expanding rapidly, but destination chargers, where drivers park for hours, are still underrepresented, affecting user trust."

The installation of EV chargers at the end-point of journeys (hotels, tourist sites, etc.) is critical to building confidence in electric vehicles. EV charging infrastructure is expanding rapidly, but destination chargers, where drivers park for hours, are still underrepresented, affecting user trust.

The Bon VoyCharge destination charging campaign, launched by BVRLA in coalition with Autotrader, ChargeUK, EVA England, UK Hospitality, UKinbound, and Zapmap, aims to:
  • Raise awareness about the importance of destination charging;
  • Work with policymakers and the hospitality/tourism sector to significantly boost installation of destination chargepoints;
  • Celebrate businesses already delivering excellent charger infrastructure and inspire others to follow suit.
The campaign officially launched on 2 July at the Fleets in Charge Conference and is continuing throughout the summer with a special World EV Day Parliamentary Reception on 9 September, kindly hosted by Sarah Green MP.

Members are asked to share their stories of visiting tourist sites, hotels, or airports and either finding a reliable charger - or being disappointed when none were available. These will be used to help persuade policymakers that destination charging is not just a “nice-to-have” but a necessity for EV adoption.

Members can help by:
  1. Submitting your story and photos via the Bon VoyCharge website, highlighting both good and missed experiences with destination chargers.
  2. Write to your MP using the ready-to-go postcard tool - invite them to attend the 9 September Parliamentary Reception and see first-hand why destination charging needs their support
 
Last edited:

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,951
Location
UK
Given how much easier and cheaper it is to install a 3-7kWh charger than a 350kWh one, it certainly makes sense to push destination chargers - especially when most cars are sitting doing nothing for the majority of the day/night.

A look on Zapmap does reveal that there are still many more sub-50kWh chargers than rapid/ultra-rapid ones, and I've noticed that many Anti-EV posters are quick to point out that there are so few ultra rapids and that you'll need to wait 4 or 5 hours to charge your car. Because, naturally, you'd stop at a slow charger when doing your urgent 500 mile trip to visit your sick nan.
 

martin butler

Member
Joined
9 Oct 2018
Messages
883
The charging network needs to improve, and how vehicles charge possibly at the same time, The biggest issue is when you can't charge at home, because you can't guarantee a parking spot, if like many you have on street parking, so you will need to have somewhere where you can fast charge your car, So battery technology will have to change, to allow fast charging, in say 5 minutes,

It's the lack of infrastructure to support electric cars, that's the drawback, what's needed are a mixture of charging stations, with ultra fast chargers, and for longer stay car parks to have a plug in and leave capacity so that you can charge your car, whilst its parked, but I would guess for the majority, who for whom , home charging isn't possible then the only option has to be fast charging stations,
 
Joined
1 Nov 2021
Messages
312
Location
Berwick
As an EV driver my biggest gripe is where chargers are not maintained. Often local authority car parks have none working ones that never get sorted. Kirklees being particularly bad for this. Fortunately lots more chargers are appearing. In the two years I have always managed but sometimes it takes a visit to two or three different sites to find a working charger.

That said 90% of my mileage is done by home charging so most of the time it doesn’t matter.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,951
Location
UK
Councils seem to be very good (sarcasm) at doing deals with somewhat dodgy firms. There are many councils that are finding the slow charging stations they outsourced to go in their car parks aren't working most of the time - despite being the cheapest and easiest ones to install.

The companies seem to do very little to fix things (maybe little incentive to do so as they made their money installing the chargers paid for through council tax - which I assume is likely the case, rather than a firm taking on the risk themselves) until the media picks up, then they say 'sorry, we're working on it' and maybe does or doesn't do anything.

Our council is now getting involved with the Solar Together scheme, where potentially the worst of the worst low-end contractors and sub-contractors get to fit solar panels and batteries badly (if you look at numerous reports and videos online) and get the work because of the supposed endorsement of the local authority. The LA has no control over the work, and quite often the prices aren't even that good - but it's all done as if it's a community supported scheme and you're benefitting from economy of scale. Sadly, you're quite possibly getting badly fitted panels and batteries and electrical work that at best is untidy, and at worst potentially dangerous.

I do hope more hotels, pubs, restaurants, shopping malls and leisure centres look at installing destination chargers. There's a clear incentive to do so when their visitors are looking to charge and might pick you over someone who doesn't have chargers - and may also encourage people to stay around for longer. An extra hour can add a lot more miles, so after shopping, why don't we eat here too? Make it cheap enough so people will pick you over someone else, and you're now encouraging people to make more visits as few people are going to stay in their vehicle for slow charges.
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
30,951
Location
UK
Hired EVs in my experience seem to be grossly overpriced across the board. Shame, really.

Can you hire any sort of car for a good price these days, and not get stung with all the extra fees, covers, waivers and someone trying to claim damages when you return?
 

styles

Established Member
Joined
7 Dec 2014
Messages
4,961
Location
Gwynedd
Can you hire any sort of car for a good price these days, and not get stung with all the extra fees, covers, waivers and someone trying to claim damages when you return?
I've never had any issues with Enterprise. I take out my own hire car insurance for about £40/year with RAC. Don't bother with any extras.

Only once had someone from Enterprise try to claim some tyre damage - I showed the original video/photos I took and they agreed it was already there. I hadn't actually spotted it myself when I took the photos/video so it was easily missed.

They're not the cheapest to hire from but nevermind. Part of the reason I started using them was they let you hire the day you pass your test, whereas most others require 1+ or 2+ years gap between passing your test and hiring a car. They do have a minimum age policy instead. I was in my early 30s and needed to hire a car about 2 months after passing.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
113,816
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
I've used Enterprise too (solely because they're the one directly outside Bletchley station) and found them fine (domestic car hire is nothing like as disreputable as that in holiday resort type places), but hiring EVs is much costlier than an equivalent ICE at present. Even an automatic adds a significant cost most of the time.
 

61653 HTAFC

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Dec 2012
Messages
19,373
Location
Yorkshire
As an EV driver my biggest gripe is where chargers are not maintained. Often local authority car parks have none working ones that never get sorted. Kirklees being particularly bad for this. Fortunately lots more chargers are appearing. In the two years I have always managed but sometimes it takes a visit to two or three different sites to find a working charger.

That said 90% of my mileage is done by home charging so most of the time it doesn’t matter.
I wouldn't trust Kirklees Council to change a 9v battery in a smoke alarm, let alone handle the high voltage connections to an EV charger!

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

I've used Enterprise too (solely because they're the one directly outside Bletchley station) and found them fine (domestic car hire is nothing like as disreputable as that in holiday resort type places), but hiring EVs is much costlier than an equivalent ICE at present. Even an automatic adds a significant cost most of the time.
Didn't all the big hire firms make a big stink about going electric a few years ago? You'd think they'd want to encourage customers to select EVs rather than ICEVs... The EV advocates keep telling us how much cheaper an EV is to own, so why do they cost so much to hire?
A cynic might say that it was all just greenwashing, and the hire firms now find themselves in a financial hole due to depreciation. I couldn't possibly comment!
 
Last edited:

Brubulus

Member
Joined
13 Oct 2022
Messages
974
Location
Cambridge
I wouldn't trust Kirklees Council to change a 9v battery in a smoke alarm, let alone handle the high voltage connections to an EV charger!

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==


Didn't all the big hire firms make a big stink about going electric a few years ago? You'd think they'd want to encourage customers to select EVs rather than ICEVs... The EV advocates keep telling us how much cheaper an EV is to own, so why do they cost so much to hire?
A cynic might say that it was all just greenwashing, and the hire firms now find themselves in a financial hole due to depreciation. I couldn't possibly comment!
Hiring EVs tends to be a bit of a disaster, given how many hotels don't have charging and that the rental companies usually insist that they are returned with a high state of charge. Not to mention trying to find and use chargers abroad. Don't have any experience of it personally or in the UK though.
 

61653 HTAFC

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Dec 2012
Messages
19,373
Location
Yorkshire
Hiring EVs tends to be a bit of a disaster, given how many hotels don't have charging and that the rental companies usually insist that they are returned with a high state of charge. Not to mention trying to find and use chargers abroad. Don't have any experience of it personally or in the UK though.
That's really something that needs sorting out if a wholesale transition is desired. With an ICE car, pretty much everything is familiar enough when you hire a car on holiday, but if an ICE owner hires an EV they'll have to adapt years-long routines and habits in an unfamiliar environment.
This will also be many people's first experience of living with an EV, and a poor experience (whether that's down to lack of preparedness, lack of charging facilities in the area, or poor customer service/support from the hire company) will likely put people off switching.
 

MicroLithium

Member
Joined
30 Jul 2024
Messages
109
Location
UK
A cynic might say that it was all just greenwashing, and the hire firms now find themselves in a financial hole due to depreciation
The pandemic was a problem (Hertz went bankrupt, for example), and they also bought a lot of Teslas which turned out to be a bad idea due to higher than average repair costs and big cuts to the list price of new vehicles cutting into residual values
 

Bikeman78

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2018
Messages
6,196
Councils seem to be very good (sarcasm) at doing deals with somewhat dodgy firms. There are many councils that are finding the slow charging stations they outsourced to go in their car parks aren't working most of the time - despite being the cheapest and easiest ones to install.

The companies seem to do very little to fix things (maybe little incentive to do so as they made their money installing the chargers paid for through council tax - which I assume is likely the case, rather than a firm taking on the risk themselves) until the media picks up, then they say 'sorry, we're working on it' and maybe does or doesn't do anything.
Given how inept they are at everything else, I wouldn't trust Cardiff Council to charge my phone, let alone a car. Thankfully I have a driveway at home so when I buy an electric car, I will charge it here.
 

Noddy

Established Member
Joined
11 Oct 2014
Messages
1,656
Location
UK
How do you tell by looking if a car in an EV?

As other have said the green stripe on a licence plate is the best at a glance indicator although a lot of EV don’t have it especially if they are older.

Many many models are built as EVs only. For example the entire VW iD series, the Kia EV series, all Polestars (apart from the Polestar 1), the Ford Mustang Mach E, MG4, Volvo EX30.

For some models where there are both ICE and EV versions of the same model there are ‘tells’. For example the Ford Puma ICE has a grill at the front to allow airflow to the radiator, but this is blanked off with a solid plate in the EV version.
 

martin butler

Member
Joined
9 Oct 2018
Messages
883
A dead giveaway is that there is no gear lever, even automatics will have some way of changing from Park to drive, and reverse, electric cars don't have anything, only a two-way switch, for go and reverse. that, and the numberplate, blanked off grills, often with the charge point in the grill on some models, but the model designation, often, will have some clues,
 

GusB

Established Member
Joined
9 Jul 2016
Messages
8,177
Location
Elginshire
There's a an interesting review of the BAW Pony on the Hubnut YouTube channel. It's a "quadricycle" rather than a car, but the price point is reckoned to be around the £12-14k mark. Range isn't huge, but it looks like a useful runabout for short trips; possibly more suitable as a delivery vehicle.

The video is here:

My only issue is with the manufacturer's name; the marketing team probably haven't considered how the name "BAW" will be received in Scotland... :D
 

Top