Wagon Review of the year 2024
Continued from post #39, a somewhat delayed installment...
------------------------
Box wagons off hire
------------------------
At the start of 2024, there were 146 modern JNA-T wagons operating on the HS2 spoil trains from Willesden Euroterminal, with VTG reporting that the final delivery took place in October 2023. The pool has wagons from several different batches built between 2019 and 2023, with this being the most recent:
817059328119 JNAT JN063B OL:046FT/13.970M IL:00.000M OW:2.742M IW:0.000M
DW:00.000M HT:0.000M
CP: DSGN 077.8T ACTL 077.3T CU:00.0 TARE: DSGN 23.750T ACTL 24.250T
46BSU MS 75MPH RA1 VBF00 ABF16 BKEFCE CHG: 00.000T SPDCHG: 24.500T
GROSS DATA: GLW101.550T MS 60MPH RA0 VBF00 ABF47 BUILT: 23 CCS00
COUPLING DETAILS: TYPE: D STRENGTH:C ( 56.000T) AXLES: 4.0 NO. UNITS: 1
*BRAKE DISTRIBUTOR DATA NOT AVAILABLE* REG.DTLS: 80VTG
The pool also included 23 JNA-A wagons (VTG 34xx and VTG 35xx), which were displaced by the newer JNA-T wagons. As mentioned in post #22, the last use of the JNA-A set (on the Willesden to Cliffe spoil circuit) was in February 2023, after which they had been stored at Willesden. They are seen here on the left, languishing behind the newer JNA-Ts in this October 2023 shot of Willesden Euroterminal:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/tayrail/53270885219/ (Photo: Jim Ramsay)
The 23 JNA-As were moved to Sunderland Docks behind 66075 on 12th December 2024 as 6L03 - reported in post #6 to be for assessment of condition before a decision to keep or scrap.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/jonhorrocks/54199033512/ (Photo: Jon Horrocks)
---------------------------------
Mendip box wagons off hire
---------------------------------
The VTG Newsletter (No. 41) that talked about the new HOA Hoppers for Mendip Rail also mentioned the earlier replacement of box wagons, with "155 new JNA-T box wagons introduced to replace and/or supplement old fleets in 2022." For this section I think it's worth going back to 2022 to look at the older box wagons displaced from Mendip traffic (some of which, mainly the KEAs, are relevant to 2024 developments).
A snapshot of the changeover period is seen in this October 2022 post on the "47soton" blog:
https://www.47soton.co.uk/2022/10/mendip-rail-workings-and-wagons-week-of.html
The initial deliveries of the new box wagons are discussed, together with a breakdown of the 206 older "non Greenbrier" box wagons in service at the time. Of these, 90 were JNA-As and JNA-Ds in the NACO / VTG (originally CAIB) 39xx series dating from 2000. These wagons (which themselves replaced former iron ore tipplers) were unaffected by the new deliveries. It's worth noting that both Nacco and CAIB were taken over by VTG in the years since the wagons were produced (CAIB in 2002 and
Nacco in 2018). N.B. Both the NACO 39xx bogie boxes and the VTG 34xx / 35xx bogie boxes are classified as JNA-A, but all other references to JNA-As in this 2024 review are talking about the VTG 34xx / VTG 35xx wagons.
With the NACO / VTG 39xx wagons unaffected, that left 116 older Mendip box wagons to be displaced by the new arrivals:
>24 KEA
>2 JNA-N (practically identical to KEA)
>57 JYA
>33 JNA-A in the VTG 34xx / 35xx number series
This LTSV profile on pre-1990 open wagons has some good information on the older types under discussion:
https://www.ltsv.com/rd/profile_detail.php?id=62
First to go for storage were the Mendip KEAs (along with the two lookalike JNA-N wagons, VTG 3160 and VTG 3167).
19 KEAs (plus JNA-N wagon VTG 3167) moved to Gascoigne Wood in summer 2022, as follows:
04/07/22 6A26 Whatley - Wembley Yard
04/07/22 6M51 Wembley Yard - Crewe Basford Hall
05/07/22 6E53 Crewe Basford Hall - Gascoigne Wood
The remaining 5 KEAs, plus JNA-N wagon VTG 3160, followed three weeks later:
25/07/22 6A26 Whatley - Wembley Yard, 66538 + 5 KEA, 1 JNA-N
https://www.flickr.com/photos/192176924@N02/52241197346/ (Photo: Oliver Keeves)
25/07/22 6M51 Wembley Yard - Crewe Basford Hall
28/07/22 6E53 Crewe Basford Hall - Gascoigne Wood
Some of these KEAs were taken out of storage during 2024, to be discussed later...
Next of the Mendip box wagons to be taken out of traffic in 2022 were the 45mph O&K JYA wagons.
https://www.47soton.co.uk/2022/10/jya-disposal-commences-october-2022.html
Delving into the movements of JYAs for storage / scrapping at Gascoigne Wood, I was startled to come across an image of 90003 hauling 22 JYAs from Wembley to Crewe Basford Hall (the wagons went forward to Gascoigne Wood the following day):
13/10/22 7M51 Wembley Yard - Crewe Basford Hall (90003 + 22 JYAs)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/mkrail/52490557711/ (Photo: MKRail)
14/10/22 7E53 Crewe Basford Hall - Gascoigne Wood
Another batch of 25 JYAs were moved to Gascoigne Wood in November 2022, as follows:
04/11/22 7C61 Merehead - Westbury Tarmac sidings (25 JYA)
14/11/22 7M36 Westbury Tarmac Sidings - Crewe Basford Hall
https://www.flickr.com/photos/50022anson/52510524051/ (Photo: Westerleigh Westie)
15/11/22 7E53 Crewe Basford Hall - Gascoigne Wood
A final batch of 9 JYAs reached Gascoigne Wood in February 2023:
06/02/11 7A91 Merehead - Hanwell Bridge Loops (most likely as part of a jumbo working)
07/02/11 7Z66 Hanwell Bridge Loops - Wembley Yard
Unknown working from Wembley Yard to Crewe Basford Hall
08/02/11 7E53 Crewe Basford Hall - Hunslet Sidings
09/02/23 7D52 Hunslet Sidings - Gascoigne Wood (70016 + 1 Hanson JHA, 9 JYAs)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/140584851@N08/52680273381/ (Photo: chris.mark.gee)
The JYAs have since disappeared from TOPS. As 45mph wagons built in the late 80s, it's not surprising for them to be scrapped.
Finally, the Mendip VTG 34xx / 35xx JNA-A wagons moved to Gascoigne Wood in a 32-wagon block at the end of 2023:
27/11/23 6F51 Whatley - Westbury Tarmac
01/12/23 6A57 Westbury Tarmac - Wembley Yard (32 JNA-A)
02/12/23 7M05 03:02 Wembley Yard - Crewe Basford Hall, 66415 + 32 JNA-A
04/12/23 6E53 10:20 Crewe Basford Hall - Gascoigne Wood Sdgs, 70016 + 32 JNA-A (via Stockport, Guide Bridge, Huddersfield)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/robstibz/53374447762/ (Photo: Rob.S)
See also this post on the 47soton blog:
https://www.47soton.co.uk/2023/12/mendip-jna-wagons-moved-to-storage-at.html
Although the 34xx / 35xx JNA-A wagons are not that old (built in 1998 by Marcroft Engineering at Stoke) they were technically conversions, with some of the components re-used from older wagons, as described in the caption to this photo of VTG 3486 by Adrian Nicholls:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/36034969@N08/44422274224
Those 32 ex-Mendip JNA-As are still in storage at Gascoigne Wood, and 60 JNA-A wagons are included in a document on the VTG website (resembling "top trumps" cards) showing which wagons are currently available for hire. Scroll down to the newsletters at
https://uk.vtg.com/news, click on issue 44 to view it as a PDF, and within the newsletter click the red link for the wagon catalogue on page 14 (the catalogue is periodically updated so the link may stop working at some point).
-----------------------------
Non Mendip box wagons
-----------------------------
Other VTG 34xx / 35xx JNA-As have been displaced by new JNA-Ts on DB Cargo workings around London, mainly the FCC spoil workings (from Neasden / Cricklewood / Bow / Barking) and the Brett sea-dredged aggregate workings from Newhaven and Cliffe. Most of these JNA-As were removed from traffic during 2023 and tripped in batches from Acton to Wembley for storage by the beginning of 2024, along with some JXA and KEA types described in post #11 and #22. For example, a movement of 33 wagons occurred on 5th December 2023, when 66116 hauled a 6Z32 09:52 Acton to Wembley Yard with 2 JXA, 10 KEA, 17 JNA-A, 3 JNA-N and 1 JNA-G.
Unlike the JNA-A wagons mentioned earlier which reached Sunderland Docks from Willesden Euroterminal for assessment of condition, two movements of box wagons from Wembley to Sunderland Docks occurred last year which were destined straight for scrap (the wagons had been shunted around at Wembley and their fate had probably been decided there). Info from marty56110 in post #21:
An initial movement of 15 wagons from Wembley to Sunderland Docks occurred in June. It had 15 wagons in total - fourteen of the VTG 34xx / VTG 35xx JNA-A types but also VTG 3259, probably the last JNA-G (originally PXA -
https://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/trlpxatml)
The TML Roundel is still visible in this picture of another wagon from the 3248-3259 batch, VTG 3254 in 2019:
https://wagons-library.weebly.com/uploads/6/9/2/9/6929845/jna-vtg-3254-03-04-19-6m76_orig.jpg
These 15 JNAs moved from Wembley as follows:
06/06/24 6Z26 Wembley Yard - Tyne Yard, 66009 + 14 JNA-A and 1 JNA-G (VTG 3259)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/92001115@N06/53774701035/ (Photo: Martin Simmons)
18/06/24 - 6Z90 Tyne Yard - Sunderland Docks, 66109 + 14 JNA-A and 1 JNA-G (VTG 3259)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/northbritonrailways/53799810309/ (Photo: Michael's North Briton Railways)
Another movement from Wembley started as a 6Z26 10:27 Wembley - Tees Yard on 4th September, with 66085 hauling a mixed rake of 9 JNA / 7 KEA / 4 JXA.
After some issues with the brakes at Welwyn, it reached Doncaster Belmont over 7 hours late where it was cancelled.
Video of it on the ECML here:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/32297024@N08/53971294846/ (Video: LNERGE1)
The wagons eventually reached Sunderland as follows:
10/09/24 6Z45 07:00 Doncaster Belmont - Tees Yard, 66161 + 9 JNA / 7 KEA / 4 JXA
18/09/24 6Z90 Tees Yard - Sunderland Docks, 66005 + 9 JNA / 7 KEA / 4 JXA
Wagon numbers in that move are noted in this sighting report on the LTSV website -
https://www.ltsv.com/rd/sighting_detail.php?id=41999
Most of the wagons discussed here had previously been in use on the FCC spoil trains mentioned above.
In addition to seven JNA-As there were two JNA-Ns (3162 & 3168) from the 3160-3169 batch built for Foster Yeoman (originally PXA) which are very similar to KEAs:
https://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/prpxayeoman
There were seven KEAs on the train, including VTG 3246 seen here when in traffic:
https://wagons-library.weebly.com/uploads/6/9/2/9/6929845/kea-vtg-3246-21-12-18-6c12_orig.jpg
Those were PXAs originally, and you could just about make out the TML Roundels under the dirt on some of them...
https://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/pxatmlyeoman
There were also four JXAs, including VTG 3144 pictured here when in traffic:
https://wagons-library.weebly.com/uploads/6/9/2/9/6929845/jxa-vtg-3144-07-11-13-6z57_orig.jpg
That type of JXA (3140-3149) were originally PXAs for Yeoman:
https://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/pxapxo29c
Another of the JXAs in the train was VTG 3157, seen here when in traffic:
https://ukrailwaypics.smugmug.com/U...ex-Sheerness-Steel-newbuild-boxes/i-m9kMdVT/A
It's last recorded working was in the
Newhaven ash set before GBRF took over those workings.
Those JXAs in the 3150-3159 batch were originally PXAs for Sheerness steel, and slightly different to the other JXA type (3100-3139) which were originally POAs:
https://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/sheernesssteelpxa
Some of these small batches of pre-1990 box wagons are now passing into history. TOPS shows 3 KEAs and 28 of the later VTG 34xx / VTG 35xx JNA-As still at Wembley, plus VTG 3166, another JNA-N from the 3160-3169 batch built for Foster Yeoman as PXAs.
-------------------
KEA movements
-------------------
KEAs starting 2024 at Gascoigne Wood were mainly ex-Mendip, as discussed earlier. The KEAs stored at Wembley were last used on FCC spoil workings, and like many of the other box wagons, were tripped there from Acton for storage. As an example, this was a movement in August:
19/08/24 6Z42 10:47 Acton Yard - Wembley Yard, 66073 + 2 KEA (VTG 3187 + VTG 3246)
Four KEA wagons, previously in storage at Gascoigne Wood, had an outing to Margam and back in the summer.
The numbers were VTG 3167 (actually a JNA-N of very similar design) / 3170 / 3181 / 3196, moving as follows:
14/06/24 6K77 Gas Wood - Milford Sdgs
15/06/24 6Z18 Milford Sdgs - Immingham Sorting Sidings
21/06/24 6J99 22:40 Immingham Sorting Sidings - Rotherham Steel Terminal, 66182 + 3 KEA / 1 JNA-N
24/06/24 6Z02 Rotherham Steel Terminal - Margam (The normal 6V02 Tees - Margam steel empties amended to call at Rotherham to pick these up)
I believe this movement was for Tata to assess the wagons. They were not used on any traffic in South Wales and returned to Gas Wood as follows:
27/08/24 6Z20 15:51 Margam - Immingham, 66121 + 9 IHAs for Hull (detached at Rotherham), 8 IHAs for Immingham Nordic, 3 KEA / 1 JNA-N)
02/09/24 6Z18 06:35 Immingham - Milford Sdgs, 66006 + 3 KEA / 1 JNA-N
07/09/24 6K77 12:30 Milford Sdgs - Gascoigne Wood, 66190 + 3 KEA / 1 JNA-N
The LTSV website reported on the possible Tata interest in their
News section in November:
This was later confirmed in the Rail Freight Flows and News thread, when GBRF took 9 KEAs from Margam to Portbury on 4th Feb 2025.
There's a photo taken by DBS92042 of a reduced-height KEA in
Post #1641 of that thread.
In order for the conversions to take place, there were several movements of KEAs to Shirebrook in 2024, from both Gascoigne Wood and Wembley, featuring some unlikely traction:
06/09/24 6Z44 04:55 Wembley Yard - Shirebrook, 43423 & 43467 + 9 KEA (VTG 3200,3193,3225,3194,3192,3185,3226,3180,3207)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/40263244@N04/53999942212/ (Photo: Peter Foster)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/darrenjb/53988819969/ (Photo: Darren JB)
04/10/24 6Z43 07:55 Gascoigne Wood - Shirebrook, 43423 & 43467 + 5 KEA (VTG 3173,3208,3224,3243,3244)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/195339731@N04/54049074245/ (Photo: Vincent Hardy)
29/10/24 6Z43 08:08 Wembley Yard - Shirebrook, 43465 & 43484 + 7 KEA (VTG 3199,3216,3182,3184,3237,3221,3209,)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/141634695@N02/54176460604/ (Photo: Lincs Trainspotter)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/65580215@N02/54108286534/ (Photo: John Rudd)
After being cut down for use as slab carriers, 9 of the KEAs were moved from Shirebrook to Margam as follows:
10/12/24 6N03 Shirebrook to Doncaster Down Decoy
10/12/24 6V24 14:21 Doncaster Down Decoy - Margam, 66789 + 9 KEA (VTG 3173,3224,3226,3194,3192,3237,3221,3216,3196)
Three more KEAs moved from Wembley to Shirebrook in December (with the orientation of inner vs outer couplings being the most likely reason they moved one-by-one):
16/12/24 6E01 04:02 Wembley Yard to Doncaster Down Decoy, 66789 + 1 KEA (VTG 3198)
16/12/24 6N02 Doncaster Down Decoy to Shirebrook, 66789 + 1 KEA (VTG 3198)
17/12/24 6Z16 03:23 Wembley Yard to Doncaster Down Decoy, 66789 + 1 KEA (VTG 3211)
17/12/24 6N02 Doncaster Down Decoy to Shirebrook, 66789 + 1 KEA (VTG 3211)
18/12/24 6Z16 03:14 Wembley Yard to Doncaster Down Decoy, 66789 + 1 KEA (VTG 3210)
18/12/24 6N02 Doncaster Down Decoy to Shirebrook, 66789 + 1 KEA (VTG 3210)
The use of KEAs on slab traffic has yet to commence (as of 13/02/25) and we await further movements of converted KEAs from Shirebrook to South Wales.
The next post will look at JRAs and the varied types of box wagon that have been used in the FCC spoil sets...