• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

I used a student Oyster card that was not mine.

Status
Not open for further replies.

YoungAndDumb

New Member
Joined
17 Dec 2024
Messages
3
Location
London
Hi, please respond if anyone has had similar experiences, would love to hear how it played out:

I got caught using someone else’s (my mother’s) student Oyster and got a letter home (attached) saying TfL may take legal action against me. I am quite scared as I am just realizing now the severity of my actions and the possible consequences. I got stopped and caught with the wrong Oyster card at Euston Square station in London, I was travelling from Liverpool Street Station.

Recently turned 21, doing a degree apprenticeship. I study at University remotely and I commute to work into central London. My salary allows me to pay for my expenses and little more, so I had an apprentice Oyster for the first year of my apprenticeship (apprentice oyster cards have the same pricing as student oyster cards). After 1 year, my apprentice oyster expired and I just paid full price for a short period of time with my debit card. After, I realized that I could use my mother’s student card instead (she’s enrolled into a university course and got the Oyster card but she didn’t use it) as the pricing is the same. Meaning that I’d pay the same whether I applied for a new apprentice Oyster or if I used my mother’s. So that is what I did, I paid for monthly travelcards on my mother’s oyster instead of getting a new apprentice Oyster of my own. Partly because of the cost of getting a new apprentice card, and partly because of the bureaucracy I'd have to go through to renew it/get a new one. I also hold a valid 16-25 rail card in my name if that is relevant at all.

Now I understand that this logic was very wrong, and severely unethical, but at the time I didn’t realize the gravity of my actions. I have used her Oyster card for around a year and a half, until it got inspected by a revenue inspector at a tube station. He took it away from me and said I’d get a letter home. I got the letter and it is attached here. My father has a 60+ freedom pass, so if I really wanted to be fraudulent and scam the system, I could’ve used that pass, however I have never touched it because I knew that if provides free travel for senior members of society. I didn’t realize that using my mother’s would be equally wrong and unethical - because we're both "students".

I am incredibly worried about getting a criminal record and what that’d mean for my career and studies. Will I be expelled from uni only one year away from graduating? Will I be fired and struggle to find a job because of the criminal record? I am genuinely not able to sleep at night and I will probably seek advice from a lawyer.

I have read the revenue enforcement and prosecutions policy, but I am still so scared, I have never had any involvement with the law so this seems incredibly daunting. I am young and dumb I guess. I know that I have to admit my offence on the letter but I am just so paralyzed by the possible outcome. I didn’t ever think something like this could bring my life and career to a halt. Please let me know if you guys seem any reasonable way to not get a criminal record, from what I've been reading TfL send criminal convictions most of the time, and do not settle out of court. For me an ideal scenario would be to pay whatever TfL deems necessary to cover my wrongdoing, I am willing to do volunteer work or whatever it takes to correct my action, but I am just so scared of a possible criminal record and the downward spiral that it would bring to my life at this age.

Many thanks in advance to anyone who reads or tries to help.
 

Attachments

  • TFL letter censured.PNG
    TFL letter censured.PNG
    432.3 KB · Views: 72
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

alholmes

Member
Joined
4 Jun 2012
Messages
477
Location
London E3
Looks as though you’ve already done some research and discovered that TfL don’t settle out of court and usually go for prosecution.

I think this is a case where you may be better off speaking to lawyers - there’s a couple of firms that are frequently mentioned on these forums - as they may (and I stress, may) be able to present your case to TfL in such a way as to get a final warning, given that they may be able to argue there has been no financial loss to TfL. But be aware - their advice is not cheap (we’ve seen figures of £500 - £800 typically) and that’s payable regardless of the outcome.
 

YoungAndDumb

New Member
Joined
17 Dec 2024
Messages
3
Location
London
Looks as though you’ve already done some research and discovered that TfL don’t settle out of court and usually go for prosecution.

I think this is a case where you may be better off speaking to lawyers - there’s a couple of firms that are frequently mentioned on these forums - as they may (and I stress, may) be able to present your case to TfL in such a way as to get a final warning, given that they may be able to argue there has been no financial loss to TfL. But be aware - their advice is not cheap (we’ve seen figures of £500 - £800 typically) and that’s payable regardless of the outcome.
Do you mind sharing which law firms are usually mentioned in the forum?
 

furlong

Established Member
Joined
28 Mar 2013
Messages
5,330
Location
Reading
What circumstances did you have that might have allowed you to obtain another Apprentice Oyster Card? Normally you can only have one for one year.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Did you "change to a different level of apprenticeship or start a new apprenticeship" ?
 

MotCO

Established Member
Joined
25 Aug 2014
Messages
6,139
Were you entitled to an Apprentice Oyster, but just didn't apply for one, or were you not entitled after your first year?
 

YoungAndDumb

New Member
Joined
17 Dec 2024
Messages
3
Location
London
What circumstances did you have that might have allowed you to obtain another Apprentice Oyster Card? Normally you can only have one for one year.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Did you "change to a different level of apprenticeship or start a new apprenticeship" ?
I went from a level 4 to a level 6, so my Apprentice Oyster was valid for 1 year (duration of the level 4)

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Were you entitled to an Apprentice Oyster, but just didn't apply for one, or were you not entitled after your first year?
I was entitled to one, I just didn't apply for a new one once I entered my level 6 apprenticeship
 

Mrmt

Member
Joined
14 Apr 2023
Messages
10
On the TfL website it says that you only get an apprentice oyster photo card for the first 12 months of your apprenticeship. Therefore I’m not sure if you’re correct when you say you’d have paid ‘the same whether I applied for a new apprentice Oyster or if I used my mother’s’. I’m just making sure you’re not confused as ignorance is no defence. If you were not entitled to one then work out what you have actually done. The admissions department at your Uni would be able to give you their policy on criminal offences, so I would look at that to see if an early declaration helps.
 

WesternLancer

Veteran Member
Joined
12 Apr 2019
Messages
15,359
Do you mind sharing which law firms are usually mentioned in the forum?
3 solicitors firms typically get mentioned from time to time

Makwana solicitors

Manak solictors

Penman Sedgwick Solicitors

I have no connection with nor have ever used any of them. If you google the name of the firm and include 'fare evasion' you can probably read what they say for themselves

or if you use the forum search facility with their name you will be able to find some cases where people have reported back that they have used them to get a sense of the cases concerned - you need to look for ones involving TfL really.

If you are thinking of using a solicitor you should ring all of them and at least get a quote for the service they provide before committing yourself, in my opinion, because it's not cheap

You could compare their costs against the impact on you of being found guilty (which may still happen of course, and then you still have to pay the solictors fees) eg how long the conviction stays on your record, what impact it might have (which may be less than you fear)
 

30907

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Sep 2012
Messages
21,990
Location
Airedale
Just to add that, while TfL almost always prosecute, our experience is that they opt for the lowest level offence of travel without a valid ticket (or similar).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top