• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Railway books discussion

Iskra

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2014
Messages
10,731
Location
West Riding
Has anyone been able to read Christian Wolmar’s new book, The Liberation Line yet and share any thoughts on it? I wasn’t that impressed by his Engines of War, and I’m not overly keen on him due to his politics, but this seems an interesting and barely touched topic that I would like to know more about.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

12LDA28C

Established Member
Joined
14 Oct 2022
Messages
5,058
Has anyone been able to read Christian Wolmar’s new book, The Liberation Line yet and share any thoughts on it? I wasn’t that impressed by his Engines of War, and I’m not overly keen on him due to his politics, but this seems an interesting and barely touched topic that I would like to know more about.

I don't think I'd read any of his books on principle. He seems to be a rather pompous self-appointed 'railway expert' who regularly gets wheeled out on TV and radio to spout forth his opinion. Not a fan.
 

Iskra

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2014
Messages
10,731
Location
West Riding
I don't think I'd read any of his books on principle. He seems to be a rather pompous self-appointed 'railway expert' who regularly gets wheeled out on TV and radio to spout forth his opinion. Not a fan.
I quite agree, although as it's the only book on the topic, if anyone can vouch for it on here, I may have to set principles aside.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
This is the first that I'd heard of Wolmar's The Liberation Line (Googled it -- railroading at the military "sharp end" in freshly-liberated Europe, final year of World War II) -- don't think that I, rather a "wet nelly" about such stuff, would be eager to read it, no matter who had written it, and however well. Re Mr. Wolmar, I'm rather with you, @12LDA28C -- smug up-themselves self-styled "pundits" on any subject, tend to rub me the wrong way; have read a couple of books by Wolmar: reckoned them not terrible, but not wonderful either -- not moved to read any more.

I've posted some, about self and this author, a while ago on this thread (page 7). As told of there -- I took some pleasure in spotting a "medium-sized" error concerning railways in Poland, in one of his books which I read: wrote to him via his publisher, pointing same out. He was decent enough to respond, acknowledging the mistake and expressing an intention to rectify it in future editions; which has caused me to feel a bit better-disposed toward the man.
 

contrex

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2009
Messages
1,680
Location
St Werburghs, Bristol
I don't think I'd read any of his books on principle. He seems to be a rather pompous self-appointed 'railway expert' who regularly gets wheeled out on TV and radio to spout forth his opinion. Not a fan.
I find him more readable than Ossie Nock or C. Hamilton Ellis; his Cathedrals of Steam wasn't bad; I don't find him pompous. It's probably a mistake to expect great literature from railway writers, but I did enjoy LTC Rolt's Red for Danger. Some of the descriptions of accidents verge on the poetic 'Angrily Grand Parade leapt upon the hapless local train' or something like that.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
Am aware that this thread is essentially about factual, not fictional, railway books; but in the recent absence of much appearing hereon: wonder if I might stray a little, into the "fictional" ballpark -- mods, please "knock on the head" if deemed appropriate.

A "murder / mystery / detective" author with genuine railway links: Freeman Wills Crofts, 1879 -- 1957. This gentleman -- native of Northern Ireland -- trained for the engineering profession, and worked in that capacity for the Midland Railway / LMS Northern Counties Committee rail undertaking in relevant part of Ireland, approx. 1896 -- 1929; after which he converted his hitherto hobby of writing " 'tec" novels, into his main occupation. (There was some discussion of his such works -- including the one which is the subject of this post -- in a thread on this sub-forum, Fictional Railways in Media, which ran for some months in 2022: that thread now closed -- had that not been so, it's thereon that I would have made this post.)

The novel by Crofts, concerned (which I lately happened on, largely by chance): is Inspector French and Sir John Magills's Last Journey (how's that for a clunky title?), published 1930. The meticulous and astute Inspector Joseph French of Scotland Yard -- chief hero of Crofts's numerous "mystery" novels -- gets involved in the investigation of murky doings (non-political -- by inference, action taking place in the very late 1920s) in the general Belfast -- Larne area, involving the death of the mentioned local magnate Sir John Magill. This thread being basically about "railway", not "fiction-fancy", stuff -- will mostly confine self to that element.

The plot centres around complex and "dodgy" happenings in and around the general "narrow seas" area between Great Britain, and the north-eastern corner of Ireland. Poor old French finds himself seemingly endlessly trogging up and down by rail plus brief sea crossings -- usually involving overnight trains (although not a gricer, he seems to enjoy rail travel well enough -- few better alternatives circa 1929, anyway) -- between London and County Antrim. Interesting, though incidental, rail elements pop up now and again. A minor character -- a witness with potentially significant evidence -- shows up: a loco-cleaner in the NCC's employ, who tells of a chance night-time encounter in course of his doing his job at Larne MPD: tells of his having loco no. 50 to clean -- "she's broad gauge, ye understand, an' I was workin' in the broad gauge shed" -- at that time, NCC 5ft. 3in., and 3ft., both fully active at Larne: no explanation of this stuff furnished by the author -- presumably he put it in "just because": one reckons that 95%-plus of the readership, not into railways or their ramifications in Ireland, would just momentarily wonder, "what's this guy drivelling on about? -- doesn't matter, anyway", and move on.

On the "other island" -- copious and tortuous doings on the Portpatrick & Wigtownshire route, largely involving the overnight Euston -- Stranraer sleeper train. In course of their investigations, characters make a couple of journeys on the Stranraer -- Portpatrick branch (closed 1950, if I have things rightly) -- just mentioned in functional passing, its attractions not gone into. In the tale's complex narrative, much travel happens, by all means other than air: sea-borne characters put in at one point, at Campbeltown. No involvement, regrettably, of the Campbeltown & Machrichanish -- active then, though not for much longer.

I -- not a great detective-fiction buff, save for a couple-or-three favoured authors -- found this novel (rail matters aside) readable, well-enough written, but not compelling: Crofts, certainly a prolific author in this genre, seems generally reckoned by those in the "fancy", as "OK, but not one of the great stars" -- his writing style found competent, but rather humdrum. For me, this tale of the unfortunate Sir John and his villainous clandestine doing-to-death (financial gain, the motive) got so wildly complicated, geographically -- "rail, road and sea" -- and otherwise: super-super-ingenious strategy on part of the "baddies", and its laborious unravelling -- that well before book's finish, I was thinking, "oh, please, just make an end, right now -- I don't care any more".

The paperback copy of the book, which I have on loan from local library -- clearly produced in recent years, though actual date doesn't seem to be in evidence -- has on its front and back covers, an "illustration" (drawing, not photo) of a steam-hauled passenger train: whose locomotive has a very much, non-British aspect -- two domes, headlight in front of chimney: vaguely "Austro-Hungarian"-looking, I feel -- totally unlike anything which ever ran in the British Isles. Standard, I suppose -- the publishers think: "for 99% of the punters, 'a steam train is a steam train is a steam train' -- some of the 1% of rail nerds will whinge, no matter what we do: so, to hell with them". I have some sympathy here, with the publishers ...
 
Last edited:

Gloster

Veteran Member
Joined
4 Sep 2020
Messages
13,043
Location
Up the creek
Sir John Magill’s Last Journey (1930, but probably set in 1929), the reference to Inspector French is not on my Penguin Green copy, is definitely one of my favourite detective novels: certainly in my top ten and probably in the top three. Crofts started with the Belfast & Northern Counties before it became the NCC started writing as a diversion during a period of illness in 1919 and produced The Cask, regarded as a bit of a classic: my feeling is that it is good, but it is clear that he hadn’t yet found his feet. His style was, it is fair to say, not the most literary (he has been described as ‘the best of the humdrum’), but his plotting was first class. He often used timetables, railway and other, and continental journeys in his plots: one difference to many of his contemporaries was that he did not depict those from beyond the channel as ‘funny foreigners’. He also avoided the habitual fear of Bolsheviks that was common in detective novels: the one time the Russians appear, they act honestly.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
Basically, yes -- good stuff; as in my above post -- not very greatly favoured by me: as I'm wont to say, "probably me, not him" -- and he does indeed, not tend to stigmatise "other breeds", as "lesser". With "Sir John" being set in N.I. -- probably as you say, in 1929 -- picture got from the novel, is that the people there with whom French deals, are Protestants: "the other lot" then and there, mostly "hewing wood and drawing water"; but that point isn't laboured. Admit to having hoped a bit, that the Larne loco-cleaner might have been a token Catholic -- but a good guy and concerned citizen; his name, however, is William M'Atamney -- no doubt there was a Saint William, with lots of Catholics world-wide, named after him; but in Northern Ireland, one reckons, for obvious reasons, probably not ...

I have to think -- nothing to do with French and Sir John and the bad guys -- that 1929 would have been a wonderful "last-gasp" time in Northern Ireland, railway-wise: in 1930, the NCC began passenger closures on the less-useful of its narrow-gauge lines; then a bit later, the 1933 rail strike there, precipitating various closures -- downward slope from then on ...
 

AndrewE

Established Member
Joined
9 Nov 2015
Messages
7,365
Has anyone been able to read Christian Wolmar’s new book, The Liberation Line yet and share any thoughts on it? I wasn’t that impressed by his Engines of War, and I’m not overly keen on him due to his politics, but this seems an interesting and barely touched topic that I would like to know more about.
I have read it and enjoyed it, although it seems to have been rushed out (if I had edited it I would have tidied up several bits) but its content was pretty well all new to me.
Am aware that this thread is essentially about factual, not fictional, railway books; but in the recent absence of much appearing hereon: wonder if I might stray a little, into the "fictional" ballpark -- mods, please "knock on the head" if deemed appropriate.

A "murder / mystery / detective" author with genuine railway links: Freeman Wills Crofts, 1879 -- 1957. This gentleman -- native of Northern Ireland -- trained for the engineering profession, and worked in that capacity for the Midland Railway / LMS Northern Counties Committee rail undertaking in relevant part of Ireland, approx. 1896 -- 1929; after which he converted his hitherto hobby of writing " 'tec" novels, into his main occupation. (There was some discussion of his such works -- including the one which is the subject of this post -- in a thread on this sub-forum, Fictional Railways in Media, which ran for some months in 2022: that thread now closed -- had that not been so, it's thereon that I would have made this post.)

The novel by Crofts, concerned (which I lately happened on, largely by chance): is Inspector French and Sir John Magills's Last Journey (how's that for a clunky title?), published 1930. The meticulous and astute Inspector Joseph French of Scotland Yard -- chief hero of Crofts's numerous "mystery" novels -- gets involved in the investigation of murky doings (non-political -- by inference, action taking place in the very late 1920s) in the general Belfast -- Larne area, involving the death of the mentioned local magnate Sir John Magill. This thread being basically about "railway", not "fiction-fancy", stuff -- will mostly confine self to that element.
...

I -- not a great detective-fiction buff, save for a couple-or-three favoured authors -- found this novel (rail matters aside) readable, well-enough written, but not compelling: Crofts, certainly a prolific author in this genre, seems generally reckoned by those in the "fancy", as "OK, but not one of the great stars" -- his writing style found competent, but rather humdrum. For me, this tale of the unfortunate Sir John and his villainous clandestine doing-to-death (financial gain, the motive) got so wildly complicated, geographically -- "rail, road and sea" -- and otherwise: super-super-ingenious strategy on part of the "baddies", and its laborious unravelling -- that well before book's finish, I was thinking, "oh, please, just make an end, right now -- I don't care any more".
see post 132!
 
Last edited:

Dr Hoo

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2015
Messages
5,704
Location
Hope Valley
Having read a couple of Freeman Wills Croft books I would say that I appreciate his meticulous, if slightly plodding, style. But it’s really hard to find much of his stuff at reasonable prices/condition despite some being reprinted in this century. I often ask specialist secondhand book sellers but they all say that he seems to have almost disappeared from consciousness.
 

Gloster

Veteran Member
Joined
4 Sep 2020
Messages
13,043
Location
Up the creek
Having read a couple of Freeman Wills Croft books I would say that I appreciate his meticulous, if slightly plodding, style. But it’s really hard to find much of his stuff at reasonable prices/condition despite some being reprinted in this century. I often ask specialist secondhand book sellers but they all say that he seems to have almost disappeared from consciousness.

Odd, my local Waterstones, which is not a very large branch, had a couple only a few weeks ago. Perhaps they have only reprinted a few and they are the ones that you already have. I have the whole lot, in various editions, and almost all of his miscellaneous short stories in one collection ore another. (I have one of those large see-through plastic crates full of paperback collections and a pile of hardbacks a couple of feet high. I don’t bother with anything that is just post ca.1960, but a lot of short stories get anthologised over and over again.)
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
As mentioned upthread: the copy of "Sir John" which I've been reading, is borrowed from my local, suburban, branch library. While the staff there are pleasant and helpful; said library is on the whole, not wonderfully well-stocked -- as with many public libraries nowadays, they frequently chuck out (offering for sale dirt-cheap) numerous books which they judge no longer "worthwhile" -- tending rather, to favour "modern-day trash". However, as with the Crofts book, the occasional "gem" does show up there.
Odd, my local Waterstones, which is not a very large branch, had a couple only a few weeks ago. Perhaps they have only reprinted a few and they are the ones that you already have. I have the whole lot, in various editions, and almost all of his miscellaneous short stories in one collection ore another. (I have one of those large see-through plastic crates full of paperback collections and a pile of hardbacks a couple of feet high. I don’t bother with anything that is just post ca.1960, but a lot of short stories get anthologised over and over again.)
Would this be the Newport, IOW, Waterstones? I visit the Island, and Newport, frequently; and frankly, the branch of Waterstones there: has struck me as the worst, most ill-provided Waterstones which I've ever come across -- though I found the staff perfectly agreeable, and wishful to be of assistance.
 
Last edited:

EbbwJunction1

Established Member
Joined
25 Mar 2010
Messages
1,778
Location
Newport, South Wales
The British Library Crime Classics series includes several books by Freeman Willis Crofts, although I don't think there are any of the railway-dedicated titles amongst them.
 

Dr Hoo

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2015
Messages
5,704
Location
Hope Valley
The British Library Crime Classics series includes several books by Freeman Willis Crofts, although I don't think there are any of the railway-dedicated titles amongst them.
Thank you (and others) for the tips about Freeman Wills Croft's material. I have had several of the British Library Crime Classics by other authors. :smile:
 

AndrewE

Established Member
Joined
9 Nov 2015
Messages
7,365
Thank you (and others) for the tips about Freeman Wills Croft's material. I have had several of the British Library Crime Classics by other authors. :smile:
If you use your county library service and search their holdings I have sometimes found that a surviving copy of an old book I fancy reading is still available from their central book store for a £1.20 reservation fee.
After that, Biblio or Abebooks often turn a copy up for a couple of quid plus postage, not much more - and still less than the cost of a pint!
 

Dr Hoo

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2015
Messages
5,704
Location
Hope Valley
If you use your county library service and search their holdings I have sometimes found that a surviving copy of an old book I fancy reading is still available from their central book store for a £1.20 reservation fee.
After that, Biblio or Abebooks often turn a copy up for a couple of quid plus postage, not much more - and still less than the cost of a pint!
Thanks again. I have used both Biblio and Abebooks for quite a few things and got stuff for what I feel is good value. Just not had much luck with Croft. The search continues…
 

Madfly

New Member
Joined
17 Feb 2024
Messages
2
Location
Kenilworth
Thanks again. I have used both Biblio and Abebooks for quite a few things and got stuff for what I feel is good value. Just not had much luck with Croft. The search continues…
Bookfinder.com is usually my first port of call when looking for second-hand books. It searches most major sites and also includes one of the most extensive ISBN databases I've seen, which can be helpful for some of the more obscure titles.
 

Dr Hoo

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2015
Messages
5,704
Location
Hope Valley
Bookfinder.com is usually my first port of call when looking for second-hand books. It searches most major sites and also includes one of the most extensive ISBN databases I've seen, which can be helpful for some of the more obscure titles.
Thank you for that. Not come across it before.

At first glance it seems to be rather well populated with somewhat expensive first editions and so on but an amazing range of titles.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
17,306
Thank you for that. Not come across it before.

At first glance it seems to be rather well populated with somewhat expensive first editions and so on but an amazing range of titles.
Bookfinder is quite useful, albeit some of the retailers on there seem to over-optimistically evaluate the condition of the books they are listing. You also have to look out for dropshipping "sellers" who don't actually have the title that you're looking for and attempt to get your order fulfilled by arranging for a cheaper third party to supply it, making a turn on the transaction.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
I have on a recent visit to the Isle of Wight Steam Railway, enjoyed a "bonanza" of books of interest to me, acquired from the Railway's second-hand-book department at Havenstreet Station. One of same was a book, hitherto unknown to me: titled Irish Steam in the 1960s, by one Conrad Natzio. With my having a lifelong love of Ireland and its railways (involving, sadly, little first-hand experience); I bought it for the trifling sum asked, and have found it fascinating and delightful. Essentially, a book of colour photographs taken of the given subject-matter in the indicated era, with plentiful -- and readable / interesting / informative -- captions / commentary. I (no artistic-photography connoisseur) would say of the pics, "some artistically impressive, some 'record' rather than photographic masterpieces; but to me, all interesting because of subject-matter".

I would feel nonetheless, that the author appears to give himself a rather narrow "remit" for his subject; although of course, "it's his book..." Per his introduction: he commenced his university studies at Trinity College, Dublin, in autumn 1958 -- having previously, for whatever reason, seen very little of the railway scene anywhere in Ireland. One cannot but wonder what soon-to-vanish delights he may have experienced in late 1958 and throughout '59; however, all pictures in the book were taken between 1960 and 1965 inclusive. As is well known, steam action continued on a restricted scale, but regularly, in Northern Ireland until the early 1970s -- above all, with the renowned and sought-out 2-6-4T-worked spoil or "muck" trains between Magheramorne and just north of Belfast; but for whatever reason, the book's cut-off date is '65: more or less concurrent with abandonment of the ex-Great Northern of Ireland lines Portadown -- Omagh -- [London]derry, and the Warrenpoint branch (which feature in the book, mostly at the very end of their lives).

For such as me anyway, the book is nevertheless full of wonderful stuff. The bulk of it is from very early in the decade, 1960 -- 62; thereafter, the steam scene overall dwindled -- CIE's very last use of steam traction being in 1963. "Sixty to sixty-two" would seem though, to have been in a modest way, glorious -- after the demise of the GNR(I) as an entity in its own right, and the splitting of its remaining lines, and assets, between CIE and UTA: something of a wondrous mix-up of Great Northern steam locos (some in GN blue livery until surprisingly late) working on a great variety of duties -- including express passenger, and a great variety of passenger specials -- in the Six Counties and / or the Republic. The author and his fellow-enthusiasts clearly travelled widely to make the most then, of what was going on -- not neglecting the scene of Northern Ireland's former NCC lines, albeit those then using with very few exceptions, the standard and numerous 2-6-4Ts and 2-6-0s, painted in sober black livery. In the "South", the author sought out -- among other things -- CIE's couple of surviving steam-worked rural terminal branches: that to Ballaghaderreen, worked until late by elsewhere-vanished ancient 2-4-0s; and the Loughrea branch, preserve of scarcely younger 0-6-0s (this line survived into the diesel era -- diesel-hauled mixed trains -- closing as late as 1975). Also, in the very early sixties (the following, "chased", photted, and chronicled by the author and his pals): "low-level" non-passenger workings, ranging far and wide, for which CIE, for operational reasons, continued to use steam haulage -- usually, their various sturdy and versatile classes of 0-6-0. These were ballast workings originating at the couple of quarries whence CIE got its track ballast; and sugar-beet ditto, in the essentially autumn / winter beet season: trains wandering widely here and there -- in the case of beet, picking the stuff up at many remote rural locations, on generous and flexible (think "days") schedules -- at the very bottom of the heap -- anything else got higher "movement" priority; with the "consist" finally arriving at the appropriate sugar factory. "Strange but fascinating", eloquently described by the author, and with mouth-watering pictures. The sugar-beet scene involved, in Ireland's south-east, the (valued for this sole purpose) intriguingly weird and one has to feel for most ends, "who ever needed it?" branch from Mhuine Beag on the Dublin -- Kilkenny route, to Palace East on the erstwhile line -- owned by another pre-1925 company -- from Macmine Junction to Waterford: the MB -- PE branch having lost its passenger service as long ago as 1931; and basically post-World War II, having been retained for beet-season use only. Pictures in the book, of early-60s steam beet trains on this backwater.

A book which I would heartily recommend to anyone with a fondness for Ireland's railways "back then".
 
Last edited:

Dr Hoo

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2015
Messages
5,704
Location
Hope Valley
Thank you for this @Calthrop . I picked up a copy of Tom Ferris' Irish Railways in Colour - A Second Glance 1947-1970 (not just steam though, with plenty of diesel railcars, Hill of Howth tram, Giant's Causeway tram, even some railway-operated buses as well as early diesels). Very nice and informative. This was a follow-on from the same compiler's Irish Railways in Colour - From Steam to Diesel 1955-1967. I'm now on the (casual) lookout for that one. Both from Midland Counties Publications.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
17,306
Talking about Ireland, any news as to whether the new/revised "TrackMaps" railway track diagrams booklet for Ireland is likely to see the light of day, anytime soon,?
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
Thank you for this @Calthrop . I picked up a copy of Tom Ferris' Irish Railways in Colour - A Second Glance 1947-1970 (not just steam though, with plenty of diesel railcars, Hill of Howth tram, Giant's Causeway tram, even some railway-operated buses as well as early diesels). Very nice and informative. This was a follow-on from the same compiler's Irish Railways in Colour - From Steam to Diesel 1955-1967. I'm now on the (casual) lookout for that one. Both from Midland Counties Publications.
I've seen ...From Steam to Diesel 1955 -- 1967 as above: ... A Second Glance 1947... , I think not; would love to see same: would imagine for obvious reasons, not many colour photos from the earliest and most interesting part of the period concerned -- those that there are, must be fascinating: have seen a few colour photos of the Tralee & Dingle in its last, monthly-cattle-specials, years. I'm probably a miserable easily-annoyed so-and-so; Tom Ferris has tended to pee me off in books of his which I have encountered: an indefatigable railfan and photographer; but like IMO not a few railway authors, egotistic and with an irritating tendency to, in print, "yap on" about himself and his family, tangentially-at-best re rail matters -- I don't want to know ! (Natzio as in my above post, I found absolutely free of this vice -- his text, for me a pleasure to read.)

Colour photos of the Giants Causeway Tramway -- yes please ! I find it hugely regrettable that this line closed in 1949: had circumstances only been then better for it, that it might have lasted longer -- independent of, and able to give two fingers to, the rail-phobic-and-cidal UTA of the 1950s onward (which would however have accorded it still, a broad-gauge connection at Portrush): long enough, and it would have been in its entirety a treasure and visitor-attraction -- closure unthinkable, whether commercial concern or transferred into preservation -- still thriving and with us today -- and Ireland's last surviving "real" 3ft. gauge line: if only ... Being a purist misery-guts, I have no use whatever for the "revived" after decades, "heritage" remnant of the Tramway at the Causeway end -- good luck, and no rancour, to those who enjoy same; just so long as I don't have to go anywhere near it <D !
 

nanstallon

Member
Joined
18 Dec 2015
Messages
1,063
My interest in Ireland goes beyond steam - much though Irish steam is superb. There are several books that illustrate superbly the atmosphere of the remote lines of the west especially. Indeed my interest is very much the western chord from Rosslare through Waterford and Limerick to Claremorris and onto the 'Burma Road' to Sligo. Oh, how I kick myself for not riding the RPSI spring railtour in 1975, which covered that latter extremity! Colourpoint published 'Rails Through Tipperary' and 'Rails Through The West' and these books are superb in providing the atmosphere of these lines. Sadly, not found secondhand at a knockdown price, but I just paid out at full price to avoid the risk of them going out of print and becoming unobtainable!
 

LUYMun

Established Member
Joined
15 Jul 2018
Messages
1,391
Location
Cancelled
A while ago I finished reading Andy Chard's biography titled Winners & Losers: Loco Bashing Tales from the 1990s, recounting the author's memories when he actively participated in the art of rail bashing behind locos that were leaving the rail scene of the era. It's a sequel of an earlier book dating Mr. Chard's tales from the 1980s (I've been meaning to purchase a copy of this, however it has gone out of print and the author believes a reprint is unlikely in the near future :(), and goes into great detail of his journeys, namely chasing the various Class 50s that were fading into the limelight.

Alongside this, it also gives a very good explanation into what rail bashing involves and a deeper insight in the joys of bashing in a pre-World Wide Web era. A diverse selection of excellent lineside photos alongside amateur close-up shots are scattered throughout this publication, giving the book a contrast between the individuals participating in the hobby. I would admit that the book focuses too much on the early half of the 1990s for it to be given the title, but then again it is no more than a biography, in which the author loses interest in the railways towards the Millennium. Overall it's an interesting read, one that I'm certain would bring back memories for certain members here should they get the chance to purchase and read this book.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
My interest in Ireland goes beyond steam - much though Irish steam is superb. There are several books that illustrate superbly the atmosphere of the remote lines of the west especially. Indeed my interest is very much the western chord from Rosslare through Waterford and Limerick to Claremorris and onto the 'Burma Road' to Sligo. Oh, how I kick myself for not riding the RPSI spring railtour in 1975, which covered that latter extremity! Colourpoint published 'Rails Through Tipperary' and 'Rails Through The West' and these books are superb in providing the atmosphere of these lines. Sadly, not found secondhand at a knockdown price, but I just paid out at full price to avoid the risk of them going out of print and becoming unobtainable!
@nanstallon: for all my love of Irish railways -- to the best of my knowledge (and I don't think memory-depletion owing to advancing years, is in play here), I'd never before heard of these books. Although the likely cost, as per yours above, is tending to damp my ardour a little; I'd love to become acquainted with them -- especially Rails Through The West. It's fairly rare that any matter to do with Ireland, can come to feel a little humdrum compared to the equivalent anywhere else; but I experience a little of such a sentiment, over oddities and eccentricities of rail-company-ownership in times past. Even allowing for greater / smaller sizes of geographic bodies: Ireland before that island's equivalent of our Grouping had -- in the broad-gauge realm at any rate -- considerably less of numbers and variety of railway companies; and of sheer weirdness involving "what belonged to whom, where"; than, at all events, contemporary England and Wales. In Ireland (all parts thereof) the scene was basically a small handful of big and extensive companies; and a not outright tiny, but far from huge, number of lesser broad-gauge ones; and little in the way of joint-ownership strangeness. (The Irish narrow-gauge concerns did a fair bit of making-up in the "variety" department.)

In the light of the above-mentioned: I've always valued the oddity of the Great Southern & Western's eccentric, and extremely long, "tentacle" into Midland Great Western territory -- especially its more northerly reaches, through wondrously back-of-beyond areas -- "as per", the "Burma Road": running right to Sligo, physically all-but; and via running powers, all the way there. This involving the marvellous interchange-point of Collooney, a little way south of Sligo; there being met also here, a lesser broad-gauge undertaking: the Sligo, Leitrim & Northern Counties. This involving three different Collooney stations, of three different companies. And needless to say, I would have loved the chance of travelling in person, Athenry -- Claremorris -- Sligo; which however never came my way when it would have been possible.
 
Last edited:

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
A "gem" in my estimation, which has in recent months by happy chance come into my possession -- book which I had read and delighted in, decades ago, but had not then owned. The book is The Maine Two-Footers by Linwood W. Moody: a history / celebration (not -- agreeably for one of my "middle-brow" tastes -- voluminously and dauntingly learned re the "history" aspect): of the -- delectable, if one's tastes run that way -- public railroads of that gauge, five in number, which operated in the US State of Maine, between 1879 and 1943. This very narrow gauge was virtually unknown for public rail lines, anywhere else in the USA: it was very much a Maine speciality.

The author -- life-span 1905 to 1983, and a native of Maine -- was privileged to have known first-hand, in the first half of his lifetime, all of the 2ft. gauge lines in his state. He accordingly tells lovingly of them, in their interesting variety: shortest (and first to close ) a mere five miles long; at the opposite extreme, a magnificent system -- and in various ways, "2ft. gauge main line", of 125 miles at its peak -- last surviving sections thereof abandoned in 1935 (as it happened: just a few months before our own, same-gauge, Lynton & Barnstaple). The book offers, for me, much fascinating material, and pretty well "never a dull moment": author comes across as a writer of considerable talent, quite a "poet in prose" (perhaps surprisingly, he never in his long life produced another full book on this, or any other, subject; although many articles by him on various topics, appeared in American railroad-enthusiast magazines). His writing is exuberant, occasionally slightly "over-the-top" even for one such as me; with my taste for such material, rather than for what I see as plodding, dull, "worthy" prose going into great legal / administrative / technical detail -- other readers will prefer the latter, to superficial-in-comparison "verbal acrobatics and fireworks" -- "de gustibus" -- nobody's objectively right or wrong.

The state's "two-footers" were -- as would be expected vis-a-vis the period in which they were active; and as detailed by the author -- essentially steam-worked; with some introduction of railmotors for passenger working, on a couple of the more substantial of the lines in the last decade-and-some of their working lives. Their steam locos were of a fairly limited and homogenous selection of types and wheel arrangements -- appealing nonetheless, if "narrow-indeed" gauge is one's thing. (Five steamers, out of an original fair few dozens, survive today at various preservation venues.) The book is copiously illustrated with photographs: the lines would seem on the whole, to have been liberally "photted", their relatively early dates of prosperity and demise, notwithstanding; the pictures ranging from a good few taken in the 19th century, to some in the last lines' final years of the early 1940s. A British reader could well be taken aback by the large number of pictures which show scenes -- often quite dramatic -- of the aftermath of derailments and other mishaps. In the text, the author tells -- with characteristic gusto -- of numerous such events; per his accounts, though, it would seem that in such happenings, physical harm to passengers was negligible; and to operating staff infrequent, and virtually never lethal. Perhaps to some extent, on such a small gauge: slow speeds, un-weighty locos and stock, and sparse schedules, would lessen the likelihood of accidents' having horrific consequences. One feels, though, not altogether... thoughts generated, of "charmed lives", and / or just, "it must have been a different world".

Working preservation came about to a certain extent, re these lines or at least some of their stock -- a complicated story, partly told of in the book: nothing here went smoothly or smoothly-ish-ly -- a la various lines in Britain -- from closure as a commercial concern, to preserved operation on the same site. Such a process was thought of and hoped for by US enthusiasts re Maine, 80-plus years ago: but various factors then, added up to the Yankee saying, "you can't railroad till it comes time to railroad". A pity, one feels; and Mr. Moody in his book (published 1959) concurs. At all events: would reckon this book a delight for fans of the narrower of narrow-but-above-miniature gauges, and who don't mind verbal high-jinks as opposed to sober highly-concentrated-informational prose.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,689
At risk of branding self as an annoying curmudgeon / nitpicker / bore; but -- partly to do something toward keeping this thread going -- bit of an embarrassing confession, concerning a book lately acquired by me very cheaply, at the second-hand-book-sales section of an English preserved railway's venue (which purveys in the line of railway books, much superb material; but also some less so). Author's name should have been a warning to me; but will confess to having forgotten said name, re what should have been a "once bitten..." situation. The offender here, is one John Scott-Morgan. I find that I had already posted concerning him, some years ago, on this sub-forum -- subject, another book, this one co-authored by him. I being a computer-fool: any attempt by me at linking to thread concerned, would be guaranteed not to work -- so: thread is titled Lately got: great pictures, shame about the words -- OP, by myself, 12/9/2019. Book concerned here, is The Light Railways of Britain and Ireland: my title basically "says it" -- book fascinatingly illustrated, but riddled with -- often highly crass -- mis-spellings and misinformation.

The tome with which I lately lumbered myself, is The Light Railway Era, 1896 -- 1996; this one, by John Scott-Morgan alone: published 1997. Rather as with the work cited above (assuming one to be, like myself, basically a fan of light railways in their golden years and after): many photographs of considerable interest; but the text -- oh, dear. Mis-spellings and misinformation, come once again to rule here. Perhaps I'm a -- whatever; but I strongly feel that anyone writing what they see as any kind of non-fiction: should exert themselves to the maximum possible, to get things right.

This book by Scott-Morgan is divided approximately into two halves. The first half is about Colonel Stephens and his wide-ranging "light railways and associated / other doings". The second half, about non-Stephens light railways in England and Wales, plus the Channel Islands (in the nature of things, 95%-plus of the material is about standard-gauge lines). While a lover of the whole crazy Colonel Stephens scene; I tend to feel that it has already received pretty much saturation coverage -- so having bought the book, I turned first, to its second half. Found this, as with mentioned-in-post's-first-paragraph tome: full of mis-spellings, and various, at best, sloppy and ambiguous informing re line's histories, and clumsy / redundant phrasing.

Going on "in reverse", to coverage of the Colonel Stephens lines: in the section on the East Kent Railway, I found a reference concerning World War I, to [sic] "the Armistice in August 1918". WHAT THE ...??!!! That was it, for me -- I cast the book aside, and have read no more. Mr. Scott-Morgan is likely a lovely chap "in his private and personal capacity"; but I have to feel that as a non-fiction writer -- he is somewhat intellectually challenged, and / or almost criminally slapdash and "don't-care" -- and I'll never touch anything published under his name, which might come along in the future. The book goes to the charity shop, at the earliest opportunity; I'll recommend that they offer it for sale, at a maximum of 10p.
 
Last edited:

AndrewE

Established Member
Joined
9 Nov 2015
Messages
7,365
I'm currently trudging through "Inspector Colbeck's Casebook" by Edward Marston... not great, but I'll see it through to the end! He seems to have written loads of books with a railway setting...
 

John Webb

Established Member
Joined
5 Jun 2010
Messages
3,785
Location
St Albans
At risk of branding self as an annoying curmudgeon / nitpicker / bore; but -- partly to do something toward keeping this thread going.......
I always read your contributions with interest, being something of a book-lover myself.

I only have one Scott-Morgan book in my collection of 500+ railway books/booklets/pamphlets; it's his one on the BR 9F freight loco, published by Ian Allan in 1994. It is mainly captioned photos and I've not noticed any errors in it. For a more technical approach to these locos I prefer Colonel H.C.B. Rogers book "Riddles and the '9Fs'", also published by Ian Allan but in 1982.
 

Top