• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Eurostar delay meaning missed connection; no network will take responsibility

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
7 Oct 2024
Messages
7
Location
Newcastle
Last month I travelled on Eurostar from Brussels to London, and then planned to take a Lumo train north to Newcastle. However, due to huge disruption in Brussels there were significant delays along the tunnel. All trains were delayed, and mine was delayed 50 minutes.

My connection in London was around 50 minutes and it was obvious I wasn't going to make it, so as recommended by Eurostar I contacted the train manager who gave me a HOTNAT form which is an agreement with train companies that Eurostar takes blame and I can travel freely on the next available service. The train manager specifically told me twice that it shouldn't be an issue, and if I am forced to buy a new ticket then Eurostar will refund me as it's their fault I was late.

When I reached London, I hopped on the next available service. The sticking point here is that it was an LNER train, not Lumo. There were no more Lumo trains that night and the alternative was I am stuck in London late at night.

After an hour into the journey I was approached by the LNER train manager who understood my situation but still needed to charge me for an extra ticket. After initially charging me over £150 for the journey, we negotiated and he changed the ticket type and destination to bring it under £100. I was reassured that I could claim this back because of my Eurostar interaction.

Following this, I've communicated with all parties involved and nobody will take responsibility. Eurostar have insisted that LNER should have accepted this and not charged me and issued me a form to show my Eurostar was late at HOTNAT should have applied. LNER has rejected this and said their train manager was right to charge me for a new ticket and I should pursue a refund with Eurostar. Eurostar have gone back on what the train manager told me. It's a constant back and forth. Eurostar's policy on 'delay repay' is the train must be 60+ minutes late for anything, but this is to refund the Eurostar ticket - not following journeys where HOTNAT comes into play.

I suppose my questions are;

-Who exactly should be to blame? Should I be focusing on Eurostar or LNER?

-Is there any independent body that can help settle such things?

-If the sticking point is the different train networks, what should I be doing in future if my original train network (Lumo) has no more services?

-Is it just a case where there's nothing I can do and suck it up?

Thank you!
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

realemil

Member
Joined
14 Feb 2021
Messages
471
Location
Glasgow
I would definitely fight back on this one.

If there were no more Lumo trains for the rest of the day - as you say - LNER has to step in and help you, without charging you for a new ticket. Can you confirm what time you were travelling? This might help / be important.

This is not about Delay Repay, so if either TOCs mention that, it's irrelevant.

I would push back, probably from both Eurostar and LNER, to get the refund. However, I would personally focus on LNER based on the information that we have, as they should not have charged you for a new ticket if there were no further LUMO trains that day.

Edit:
Can you also confirm for us what tickets you hold exactly? As in the exact origin / destination points, a picture would be great. This is because depending on what the tickets are, it may change your rights.
 
Joined
7 Oct 2024
Messages
7
Location
Newcastle
I would definitely fight back on this one.

If there were no more Lumo trains for the rest of the day - as you say - LNER has to step in and help you, without charging you for a new ticket. Can you confirm what time you were travelling? This might help / be important.

This is not about Delay Repay, so if either TOCs mention that, it's irrelevant.

I would push back, probably from both Eurostar and LNER, to get the refund. However, I would personally focus on LNER based on the information that we have, as they should not have charged you for a new ticket if there were no further LUMO trains that day.

Edit:
Can you also confirm for us what tickets you hold exactly? As in the exact origin / destination points, a picture would be great. This is because depending on what the tickets are, it may change your rights.
My last communication is that Eurostar will now communicate with LNER about this and ask why it wasn't accepted, so that is something.

The original Lumo ticket was a Standard Class fixed ticket. The new one I bought on the day is an LNER Super Off-Peak Single. The original journey was London Kings Cross to Newcastle, the new ticket was London Kings Cross to Darlington.

Thanks!
 

AlterEgo

Verified Rep - Wingin' It! Paul Lucas
Joined
30 Dec 2008
Messages
29,672
Location
LBK
My last communication is that Eurostar will now communicate with LNER about this and ask why it wasn't accepted, so that is something.
HOTNAT does not apply to LNER unless there is a local agreement between the two; if one exists I am unaware of it. This is why London International (CIV) tickets are sold for domestic travel.

The original Lumo ticket was a Standard Class fixed ticket. The new one I bought on the day is an LNER Super Off-Peak Single. The original journey was London Kings Cross to Newcastle, the new ticket was London Kings Cross to Darlington.
Did you buy the ticket with the origin of London Terminals, London King's Cross, or London International? If it is the latter you would have been undoubtedly protected.

I would definitely fight back on this one.

If there were no more Lumo trains for the rest of the day - as you say - LNER has to step in and help you, without charging you for a new ticket.
They don't if the OP doesn't have a London International (CIV) ticket, because the delay causing the "stranding" occurred outside the network and outside the NRCoT.
 

Fawkes Cat

Established Member
Joined
8 May 2017
Messages
5,342
I would definitely fight back on this one.

If there were no more Lumo trains for the rest of the day - as you say - LNER has to step in and help you, without charging you for a new ticket. Can you confirm what time you were travelling? This might help / be important.

This is not about Delay Repay, so if either TOCs mention that, it's irrelevant.

I would push back, probably from both Eurostar and LNER, to get the refund. However, I would personally focus on LNER based on the information that we have, as they should not have charged you for a new ticket if there were no further LUMO trains that day.
I'm not sure that this follows: the requirement for any rail company who can to help out is part of the National Rail Conditions of Travel (NRCoT - condition 28.2) and Eurostar isn't covered by the NRCoT. So it seems to me that as far as LNER are concerned, the OP started their NRCoT-compliant journey at Kings Cross: the fact that they were late getting to St Pancras and so to Kings Cross is no more LNER's problem than if they had been delayed on the bus or tube when getting to Kings Cross.

That's not to say that the OP shouldn't be seeking their money back - but it may mean that they need to pursue one or both railway companies (I would suggest Eurostar) and seeking a goodwill payment because of how they were messed about, rather than compensation as a right.

(Edited to add)
Having said which:

Did you buy the ticket with the origin of London Terminals, London King's Cross, or London International? If it is the latter you would have been undoubtedly protected.
I didn't know this
 
Joined
7 Oct 2024
Messages
7
Location
Newcastle
I have seen a HOTNAT before on my duties and have honoured it. However, I don't believe there is any requirement for UK operators to do. HOTNAT is an agreement between Railteam members: DB, Eurostar, NS, SCNB, SCNF, ÖBB and SBB.

I have noticed on the Eurostar website they have a section for missed connections. It's the part of the uploaded screenshot mentioning "If you miss your connecting train in the UK"

If no strict HOTNAT agreement, they do have some kind of agreement here it seems. The sticking point I suppose is that there were no more trains that evening from Lumo, only LNER.
 

Attachments

  • WhatsApp Image 2024-10-07 at 14.10.44.jpeg
    WhatsApp Image 2024-10-07 at 14.10.44.jpeg
    108.2 KB · Views: 182

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
113,832
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
The original Lumo ticket was a Standard Class fixed ticket. The new one I bought on the day is an LNER Super Off-Peak Single. The original journey was London Kings Cross to Newcastle, the new ticket was London Kings Cross to Darlington.

Did you actually only go to Darlo and e.g. get collected there or did the guard actually sell a short fare?!
 

realemil

Member
Joined
14 Feb 2021
Messages
471
Location
Glasgow
They don't if the OP doesn't have a London International (CIV) ticket, because the delay causing the "stranding" occurred outside the network and outside the NRCoT.
Yeah I completely forgot that the ticket needs to be a CIV one, hence my edit below.

From the response OP gave, it seems that they dont hold a CIV ticket, but the image attached and https://www.eurostar.com/uk-en/travel-info/connecting-train#Missed-Connection does state what the OP says the guard said on ES

Missed connection due to a delayed train in the UK​

If you’ve missed an onward connection because of a train delay or cancellation, you can get on the next available train for free. This is because we have an agreement with other local train operators in the UK.
If you miss your connecting train in the UK:
Chat to a member of our team to confirm that your Eurostar train has been delayed or cancelled. At your connecting station, staff of the train operator you’re travelling with will get you on the next available connecting train for free.
 
Joined
7 Oct 2024
Messages
7
Location
Newcastle
HOTNAT does not apply to LNER unless there is a local agreement between the two; if one exists I am unaware of it. This is why London International (CIV) tickets are sold for domestic travel.


Did you buy the ticket with the origin of London Terminals, London King's Cross, or London International? If it is the latter you would have been undoubtedly protected.


They don't if the OP doesn't have a London International (CIV) ticket, because the delay causing the "stranding" occurred outside the network and outside the NRCoT.
The ticket says it was bought within London Terminals, not International or King's Cross.

While I'm understanding HOTNAT doesn't apply to LNER and UK trains, Eurostar's website does have a section that I've attached elsewhere in this thread mentioning that if the Eurostar is delayed or cancelled then the network of the train I'm due to be on will sort me out to get on the next train. The problem I face is that there was no more Lumo that day. I was on the 20.27 Lumo, the last of the day.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Did you actually only go to Darlo and e.g. get collected there or did the guard actually sell a short fare?!
He sold me a short fare to help me out
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
113,832
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
He sold me a short fare to help me out

Umm...this could prove a problem in getting this sorted. He really should not have done that and if it gets escalated he could be in serious trouble.

(If you'd been caught at Newcastle you'd also probably have been on the thick end of a prosecution/expensive settlement - yes, if he sold it that's him as an authorised person giving you permission to overtravel, but TOC prosecution departments don't always check all the facts)
 
Joined
7 Oct 2024
Messages
7
Location
Newcastle
Umm...this could prove a problem in getting this sorted. He really should not have done that and if it gets escalated he could be in serious trouble.

(If you'd been caught at Newcastle you'd also probably have been on the thick end of a prosecution/expensive settlement)
He told me he was train manager until Newcastle and I wouldn't have an issue, which proved true. It's why I'm reluctant to upload ticket images because I fear that may identify him. Despite my issue, I don't want him to get in serious trouble for trying to help me out.
 

AlterEgo

Verified Rep - Wingin' It! Paul Lucas
Joined
30 Dec 2008
Messages
29,672
Location
LBK
He told me he was train manager until Newcastle and I wouldn't have an issue, which proved true.
He doesn't know there isn't revenue on the gate though, and has sold you a ticket which doesn't cover your journey, which is going to be a problem - you will need to show you purchased a replacement ticket for the journey. He should not have done this knowing you would need to submit it in order to evidence your journey to Newcastle. This has made things quite a bit more complex.
 
Joined
7 Oct 2024
Messages
7
Location
Newcastle
Update:
I've just heard from Eurostar who have chased things up.

After speaking and confirming with an LNER Customer Service Director, they said "LNER are unfortunately in the wrong here.
There is an ongoing agreement for all UK TOC's (Train Operating Companies) that was put in place by RDG (Rail Delivery Group) that was only re-confirmed only this summer." and advised me to go back to them with this information.
 

David Horne

Verified Rep - LNER
Joined
7 Oct 2024
Messages
4
Location
ECML
Update:
I've just heard from Eurostar who have chased things up.

After speaking and confirming with an LNER Customer Service Director, they said "LNER are unfortunately in the wrong here.
There is an ongoing agreement for all UK TOC's (Train Operating Companies) that was put in place by RDG (Rail Delivery Group) that was only re-confirmed only this summer." and advised me to go back to them with this information.
Hi pickindim_kmet. Please can you email to me a copy of your correspondence with LNER customer services? My email is david.horne@lner.co.uk.
Many thanks
David
 

Mr Grayson

On Moderation
Joined
15 Jan 2024
Messages
8
Location
SW London
Good to see some quick progress towards resolving this. Once it has been resolved, I think we'd all be pleased to see the wording of the RDG's agreement in black and white so we know where we stand (and to potentially quote it in cases of dispute).
 

mad_rich

Member
Joined
12 Feb 2013
Messages
593
Location
Newcastle
Good to see the MD posting here (assuming it is indeed him?!).

Hopefully that will get the issue resolved, and maybe even some clarification on what is supposed to happen in these circumstances.
 

John R

Established Member
Joined
1 Jul 2013
Messages
6,135
You can save all the hassle by buying a CIV to/from ‘London International’
Whilst good advice in general, that is of no help to the OP, which is the purpose of the thread. And besides, it’s clear that LNER has been alerted to the complaint at the highest managerial level, and so I suspect the OP’s problem will be resolved very soon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top