• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

RMT abstain from TUC "Solidarity with Ukraine" motion

Status
Not open for further replies.

DustyBin

Established Member
Joined
20 Sep 2020
Messages
3,927
Location
First Class
Unfortunately the dispute is partially ours. Under the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances of 1994 the UK and US provided security assurances to Ukraine in exchange for its giving up of nuclear weapons. We failed to act when Russia invaded Crimea even turning up for the World Cup in Russia afterwards which presumably encouraged Putin to further attack Ukraine assuming the West would continue to ignore the situation.

I find the number of people who have no knowledge/appreciation of this, even at this stage, quite surprising.

I’ve always vocally opposed direct military intervention, including the no-fly zone nonsense, for obvious reasons. To suggest that we should simply turn the other cheek however is ridiculous; we’re protecting our own interests here as well as helping Ukraine.

It’s a disgusting stance from the RMT, who demonstrably do support similar motions when it suits them. Perhaps some people are so blinkered and dogmatic in their political beliefs that they simply can’t bring themselves to criticise their beloved trade union, and would rather (desperately I should add) defend the indefensible.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Bantamzen

Established Member
Joined
4 Dec 2013
Messages
10,510
Location
Cheshire
I can't believe some folk don't think the war in Ukraine is anything to do with us. It has had a literal effect on our economy, and Putin gaining ground in Europe will likely not be to our benefit. So it is hugely disappointing that the RMT have chosen not to show support for Ukraine.
 

Strathclyder

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2013
Messages
3,846
Location
Clydebank
God forbid that a UK Railway union be more interested in matters relating to the UK and it's railways, than some foreign war a continent away.
Like the ones quoted by @greatkingrat in post #16?

And last time I checked, Ukraine is in Europe. Our continent.

Why is it embarassing? It's refusing to take sides in a squabble between two Eastern European right wing nationalists. What good has come for us ordinary folk out of taking sides in this?
From a moral standpoint? A basic human decency standpoint? I haven't personally met any Ukrainians who have had their lives upturned by this war (I have seen a Ukrainian-registered car here in Clydebank though), but I for one I'm glad we're 'taking sides' on this. And broadbrushing Ukraine as a right-wing nationalist is conveniently side-stepping the progress they were and are making in improving matters and rooting out corruption. Ukraine isn't perfect, but they ain't Belarus fgs (they would be if certain members here had their way).

I can't believe some folk don't think the war in Ukraine is anything to do with us. It has had a literal effect on our economy, and Putin gaining ground in Europe will likely not be to our benefit. So it is hugely disappointing that the RMT have chosen not to show support for Ukraine.
Quite. It's staggering to be honest.

Oh dear, there seem some very militant people on this forum.
Please, for your own sake, look in the mirror before casting that aspersion. And for the record, if I or others here are 'militant' for taking the moral high ground in a completely unjustified war that's killed scores of innocents and displaced countless others, so be it.

For what it is worth I cannot support our pouring billions into a dispute which is not ours
Given how we in the West (specifically the UK and US) failed to act when Crimea was invaded, effectively ignoring the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances of 1994 in the process (as @deltic notes above), then afterwards appeased the tyrant responsible or otherwise turned a blind eye to him which only emboldened him further, it is very much our dispute (and that's not even getting into the effects the war has had ecomonically, we have already lost billions in that regard). We gave the Ukrainians our word that we could be relied upon to preserve their independence and security in an emergency, and we failed them miserably in 2014.

and a leader of Ukraine who is almost as bad as Putin.
What utter drivel. Remind me, who was it that ordered the full-scale invasion of one of it's sovereign neighbours and then tried to spin a pathetic narrative justifying it? Who is it that has a long history of brutality, suppression, foreign interference, spinning false narratives and increasingly brazen attacks on foreign soil? Answer: it ain't Zelenskyy.

It surely is time they sat down at the table and came to a sensible agreement about the disputed territories in the east who have been in conflict for many years.
Russia has no right to any of Ukraine's territory. Period. The only reason those eastern terrorities have been in conflict for many years is thanks to Russia's constant interference and meddling. This conflict could - and damn well should - end today with Putin withdrawing every last member of his armed forces from Ukrainian territory and returning to pre-18th March 2014 border postions, but he won't; it's virtually the only thing keeping him from falling out the nearest window for one thing (can't enjoy his vast ill-gotten fortune then, can he?)

Besides, why on earth would Ukraine, or anyone else for that matter, agree to any demands Russia makes in any such hypothetical sit-downs when they have a history of going back on such agreements when they think no-one is paying attention, the grain deal fisaco being only the latest example of this.
 
Last edited:

DarloRich

Veteran Member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
32,949
Location
Fenny Stratford
For what it is worth I cannot support our pouring billions into a dispute which is not ours and a leader of Ukraine who is almost as bad as Putin. It surely is time they sat down at the table and came to a sensible agreement about the disputed territories in the east who have been in conflict for many years.
So your solution: Give Russia what it wants which, lets be really clear about this, is a part of a sovereign nation. Giving them that slice of another nation will only embolden them and reward them for thier aggression. They will then go for other territory they claim in other soverign nations.

BTW, which country are you happy for Russia to invade next? The Baltic states? Poland? Finland? Romania? Which of these countries is a country too far?

Also WE agreed to support the independence and security of Ukraine in return for them giving up the nuclear weapons they had acquired via the break up of the former soviet union. You must see why that is our problem. We gave these people our word that we could be relied on in an emergency.

God forbid that a UK Railway union be more interested in matters relating to the UK and it's railways, than some foreign war a continent away.
but that isn't what is happening. What is happening here is that tankies gotta tankie.

You must know this is all wrapped up in the stance of a section of the further left in the UK opposed to any position USA/NATO/Western powers take in relation to the east. We saw that in Corbyn and this is simply the same side of the coin. It is a really poor stance to take. It is textbook useful idiot stuff
 

davews

Member
Joined
24 Apr 2021
Messages
1,018
Location
Bracknell
OK, you obviously think differently and I regret even commenting on this thread. I had better say no more. Please just accept that there are many of us who are absolutely horrified about this war, or any war for that matter.
 

DarloRich

Veteran Member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
32,949
Location
Fenny Stratford
Please just accept that there are many of us who are absolutely horrified about this war, or any war for that matter
As long as you accept that you do not hold a monopoly on being horrified by war.

OK, you obviously think differently and I regret even commenting on this thread. I had better say no more.
Why - you have stated your view and been challenged on it. Why do you think Russia should be allowed to take bites out of sovereign nations because it feels like it?

PS - my view is there to be challenged. I do not assume I am right.
 

Thirteen

Established Member
Joined
3 Oct 2021
Messages
1,904
Location
London
The FBU voted against the motion which is a bit odd as firefighters don't strike me as pro Putin.

Eddie Dempsey's pro Russia views have always been problematic and even more so since he's in a senior position at the RMT.
 

ainsworth74

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Global Moderator
Joined
16 Nov 2009
Messages
31,129
Location
Redcar
Please see the existing thread for discussion on the Russian invasion of Ukraine which can be found here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top