• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Northern Unit Refurbishments and depot allocations.

diligentdave

Member
Joined
20 Oct 2007
Messages
441
These will presumably get digital mods at some stage? I guess now in the queue behind the seven six nine and three one nine reported to be going through the works for these elsewhere?
The Class 769 digital program starts in September this year, with the cascaded 156's running alongside starting in October (possibly during refresh but still to be awarded).
The Class 319's will not get digital trains fitted as they are all going off-lease at the end of this year.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
27,281
Location
Bolton
They are identical to any other Northern TrainFX unit.
Yes in terms of incode, however, in terms of output from the hardware, they are very very different. The one on 472 was poor enough that I mentioned to the conductor that there was a problem with the public address in my coach, as I could barely make out the words through the crackling and interference. He said with a wince that unfortunately they're all like this, and it's something that has already been fed back internally so there was nothing he could do. They also added that the digital train modifications have resulted in the public address handsets in the saloon being removed, so the original bombardier system was in fact better in every way really.

This promoted me to take a closer look at the screen in the unit. Unfortunately it's much more flickery and it's actually quite difficult to read compared to the Bombardier ones. I've attached a picture of the awful workmanship where the area previously under the screen casing hasn't even been cleaned before the new ones have been put in. Is that the finished product:

20230701_195811.jpg

Then again, I know that the issue in these units where the charging sockets have been installed behind where the seat cushion goes has been raised multiple times internally and by customers over the last four years but that seems not to be something that is being fixed either:

20230701_200136.jpg

Unfortunately despite a substantial amount of public money being spent on these units the customer experience they are offering has become worse rather than better. The units at ScotRail still do not have any of the above issues and work just fine. At least the ETCS cabinets aren't quite as intrusive as they are on the 150s, where several seats have been removed to accommodate them.
 

modernrail

Established Member
Joined
26 Jul 2015
Messages
1,454
Yes in terms of incode, however, in terms of output from the hardware, they are very very different. The one on 472 was poor enough that I mentioned to the conductor that there was a problem with the public address in my coach, as I could barely make out the words through the crackling and interference. He said with a wince that unfortunately they're all like this, and it's something that has already been fed back internally so there was nothing he could do. They also added that the digital train modifications have resulted in the public address handsets in the saloon being removed, so the original bombardier system was in fact better in every way really.

This promoted me to take a closer look at the screen in the unit. Unfortunately it's much more flickery and it's actually quite difficult to read compared to the Bombardier ones. I've attached a picture of the awful workmanship where the area previously under the screen casing hasn't even been cleaned before the new ones have been put in. Is that the finished product:

View attachment 138397

Then again, I know that the issue in these units where the charging sockets have been installed behind where the seat cushion goes has been raised multiple times internally and by customers over the last four years but that seems not to be something that is being fixed either:

View attachment 138398

Unfortunately despite a substantial amount of public money being spent on these units the customer experience they are offering has become worse rather than better. The units at ScotRail still do not have any of the above issues and work just fine. At least the ETCS cabinets aren't quite as intrusive as they are on the 150s, where several seats have been removed to accommodate them.
The placement of that plug really is quite special. Well done to whoever signed that one off. It would have been better to take it out and plate it to at least provide some degree of impression there is a vague level of attention to detail.

Work to northern trains always seems to be done poorly and produce poor results. SWR refurbishments from just after privatisation seem to hold up better than Northern refurbishment from a year or two ago, on similarly aged units.
 

skyhigh

Established Member
Joined
14 Sep 2014
Messages
6,865
Yes in terms of incode, however, in terms of output from the hardware, they are very very different. The one on 472 was poor enough that I mentioned to the conductor that there was a problem with the public address in my coach, as I could barely make out the words through the crackling and interference. He said with a wince that unfortunately they're all like this, and it's something that has already been fed back internally so there was nothing he could do. They also added that the digital train modifications have resulted in the public address handsets in the saloon being removed, so the original bombardier system was in fact better in every way really.
They're all being fixed to sort the cracking.

And yes, the original system was better.
 

py_megapixel

Established Member
Joined
5 Nov 2018
Messages
7,485
Location
Northern England
That is huge news is still happening so soon. Wigan (and Victoria?) staff still don’t have any 323 training…
Nor any 323s to drive, given the Aventras in the West Midlands aren't yet in service so the cascade hasn't started.

I suppose the 319s could be covered for temporarily by short-forming Blackpool services, which are currently run by pairs of 331s. They don't seem to be used all that much anyway.
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
27,281
Location
Bolton
Nor any 323s to drive, given the Aventras in the West Midlands aren't yet in service so the cascade hasn't started.
Generally not, but they can work 323s between Manchester Airport and Liverpool Lime Street if they have the traction knowledge.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

They're all being fixed to sort the cracking.
I admire your optimism, but hopefully the trainfx work is being managed better than the charging sockets.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

It would have been better to take it out and plate it to at least provide some degree of impression there is a vague level of attention to detail.
I guess long term replacing those ones with the USB A ones is a sensible solution.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Work to northern trains always seems to be done poorly and produce poor results.
Given the units that stayed at ScotRail are near identical, but the ScotRail refurbishment programme didn't seem to have any of these problems, I unfortunately have to agree.

ScotRail have been less ambitious though in not trying to install ETCS wiring cabinets which is likely a good thing frankly. They also don't have the multi-media screens however which is potentially a disadvantage.
 
Last edited:

skyhigh

Established Member
Joined
14 Sep 2014
Messages
6,865
I admire your optimism, but hopefully the trainfx work is being managed better than the charging sockets.
Is it not the case that's how they arrived from ScotRail?

In this case Yellow Rail haven't supplied the mods according to the standards required so are rectifying the work under warranty. If the sockets arrived in the current location, that would be an expenditure to resolve (but I agree it should have happened).
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
27,281
Location
Bolton
Is it not the case that's how they arrived from ScotRail?

In this case Yellow Rail haven't supplied the mods according to the standards required so are rectifying the work under warranty. If the sockets arrived in the current location, that would be an expenditure to resolve (but I agree it should have happened).
They weren't fitted with them at ScotRail.
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
27,281
Location
Bolton
Amazing. Will it be a conversion course? I recall Northern staff already 156 trained only needed a few days to be signed off on 158s.
Not an enormous amount of traction similarly with a 323 for any other existing Northern traction.
 

jonesy3001

Established Member
Joined
13 Jul 2009
Messages
3,317
Location
Otley, West Yorkshire
IIRC Manchester Airport to Liverpool will be booked for 331/1s from the December timetable change, pending the swap of 331/0s and 331/1s between Allerton and Neville Hill depots.
How many are being swapped over it is going to be like for like 12 for 12 until the platforms up here have been extended?
 
Last edited:

Halish Railway

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2017
Messages
2,176
Location
West Yorkshire / Birmingham
How many are being swapped over it is going to be like for like 12 for 12 until the platforms up here have been extended?
As I understand it’ll be a sort of ‘half-way’ transfer, with a mix of three and four car units operating out of both of Allerton and Neville Hill depots, with Bradford to Ilkley and Skipton services being three carriages in length for the time being from December.

Crews at Doncaster and the relevant link at Leeds haven’t begun training on the 333s for services from Doncaster to Leeds which I believe will work on those services once Neville Hill looses its four carriage 331s.
 

td97

Established Member
Joined
26 Jul 2017
Messages
1,556
I suppose the 319s could be covered for temporarily by short-forming Blackpool services, which are currently run by pairs of 331s. They don't seem to be used all that much anyway.
Absolutely not. Manchester to Blackpool requires 6×23m at half hourly frequency in the daytime.
IIRC Manchester Airport to Liverpool will be booked for 331/1s from the December timetable change, pending the swap of 331/0s and 331/1s between Allerton and Neville Hill depots.
As I understand it’ll be a sort of ‘half-way’ transfer, with a mix of three and four car units operating out of both of Allerton and Neville Hill depots
Presumably retaining 6×23m on the Blackpool to Airport. Anything less would leave passengers behind, particularly at peak times. The current timetable uses 100mph 331 timings on the Bolton corridor and WCML from Euxton to Preston, which a 323 could not achieve.
 

Halish Railway

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2017
Messages
2,176
Location
West Yorkshire / Birmingham
Presumably retaining 6×23m on the Blackpool to Airport. Anything less would leave passengers behind, particularly at peak times. The current timetable uses 100mph 331 timings on the Bolton corridor and WCML from Euxton to Preston, which a 323 could not achieve.
I wouldn’t read into the timing loads on RTT and other data sources too much. The 323s still have incredibly sprity acceleration, but significantly quicker door cycles than the 331s which can off set any losses caused by the slightly lower top speed.

I seem to remember a suggestion that the 319s would be reintroduced onto the Manchester Airport to Blackpool North services when some 331/0s transferred east, but that may have changed if the 319s will be withdrawn at an earlier date.
 

61653 HTAFC

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Dec 2012
Messages
19,352
Location
Yorkshire
As I understand it’ll be a sort of ‘half-way’ transfer, with a mix of three and four car units operating out of both of Allerton and Neville Hill depots, with Bradford to Ilkley and Skipton services being three carriages in length for the time being from December.
Three-car units on the Bradfords makes some sense, IF the half-hourly frequency is returning. If not, then going from eight carriages per hour to three in six months is quite the downgrade.
 
Joined
27 Jul 2022
Messages
26
Location
Bradford
As I understand it’ll be a sort of ‘half-way’ transfer, with a mix of three and four car units operating out of both of Allerton and Neville Hill depots, with Bradford to Ilkley and Skipton services being three carriages in length for the time being from December.

Crews at Doncaster and the relevant link at Leeds haven’t begun training on the 333s for services from Doncaster to Leeds which I believe will work on those services once Neville Hill looses its four carriage 331s.
A 333 went on a gauging run recently to Doncaster, but I have heard during off peak hours trains may be a 3 car 331 and during peak hours it may be a 6 car 331.

But again I have heard the same it is intended to be for the December timetable change, but for the 331s I have been told a dispatcher may be needed at Shipley or the body side cameras may be used for dispatch by a guard in a cab.

We will also have to wait for ASDO testing I believe when they come as I’m not sure on what stations can’t accommodate anymore than 4 carriages and the announcements station to travel at the front of the train for certain stations don’t seem to click with passengers in my opinion.
 

Neptune

Established Member
Joined
29 May 2018
Messages
2,626
Location
Yorkshire
A 333 went on a gauging run recently to Doncaster, but I have heard during off peak hours trains may be a 3 car 331 and during peak hours it may be a 6 car 331.
333’s for Donny, 6 car 331 in the peaks is a future possibility.
But again I have heard the same it is intended to be for the December timetable change, but for the 331s I have been told a dispatcher may be needed at Shipley or the body side cameras may be used for dispatch by a guard in a cab.
I’m not on the ops side of things but guards will definitely not be using the body side cameras for dispatch from the cab. Shipley, Keighley and Skipton booking office staff are all dispatch trained.
We will also have to wait for ASDO testing I believe when they come as I’m not sure on what stations can’t accommodate anymore than 4 carriages and the announcements station to travel at the front of the train for certain stations don’t seem to click with passengers in my opinion.
I’m sure our conductors are pro-active enough to assist in this. It’s worked well elsewhere.
 

Top