• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

How long ago did London buses go flat rate?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Joe SeafordNY

Member
Joined
24 Jul 2019
Messages
5
I am a New Yorker who has visited London only three times, so my knowledge of London buses is little. A friend will visit London in February. I was surprised that the fares are not distance-based and rather a flat £1.65, with no need to tap out. When were distance-based fares (with stages?) phased out? Thank you. Joe
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Snow1964

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2019
Messages
11,192
Location
West Wiltshire
Flat rate fares were originally introduced about 50 years ago on a few services (called Red Arrow) in central London, which generally did routes between the main rail stations.

The majority of routes only changed after contactless card called oyster was introduced about 15 years ago. At about same time cash fares were set higher to encourage take up of the new cards. The cash fares were phased out about 7 years ago, and in recent years contactless bank cards have become an option.

Someone might remember the dates, so apologies if I have missed by a year or two
 

duncanp

Established Member
Joined
16 Aug 2012
Messages
4,856
Distance based fares started to be phased out in the early 1980s.

The Conservative led GLC introduced a flat fare zone in the outer suburbs in early 1981, and when Labour won control of the GLC later that year they introduced a system where there was a short hop fare (for very short journeys) and a standard flat fare (for longer journeys).

Later on, the short hop fare was abolished and there was a single fare for any journey regardless of distance.

Oyster cards started to appear in the early 2000s, and the flat fare system meant that there was no need to tap off when exiting the bus.

More recently, contactless bank cards and mobile phones were accepted as payment methods, and there is also now the hopper fare, whereby if you tap on another bus within one hour of a previous tap on there is no extra charge.

There is also an overall cap of £4.95 per day when travelling by bus only.

Andy Byford, who is the current Commissioner of Transport for London, used to work at the MTA in a similar position, and had previous experience at London Underground before he went to work in New York.

His experience was instrumental in introducing the OMNY system in New York, which is similar in many ways to the Oyster system.
 

Deerfold

Veteran Member
Joined
26 Nov 2009
Messages
13,751
Location
Yorkshire
Distance based fares started to be phased out in the early 1980s.

The Conservative led GLC introduced a flat fare zone in the outer suburbs in early 1981, and when Labour won control of the GLC later that year they introduced a system where there was a short hop fare (for very short journeys) and a standard flat fare (for longer journeys).
There was a period between these two where distance-based fares returned, especially for fares on buses which left London and on night buses. When I visited London in the late 90s and 2000, these fares could be over £3 and Day and Weekend Travelcards were not valid on night buses.

Later on, the short hop fare was abolished and there was a single fare for any journey regardless of distance.

Oyster cards started to appear in the early 2000s, and the flat fare system meant that there was no need to tap off when exiting the bus.
Before the Oyster card was launched Ken Livingstone introduced two fares, 70p outside Zone 1, £1 including Zone one (though cheaper packs of "saver" tickets were available). Oyster card was launched to the public in 2004 and those using it paid 70p for any ticket. The price increased substantially to £1 in 2005, but didn't go above that until 2010 and went down to 90p for 2008 only).
More recently, contactless bank cards and mobile phones were accepted as payment methods, and there is also now the hopper fare, whereby if you tap on another bus within one hour of a previous tap on there is no extra charge.

There is also an overall cap of £4.95 per day when travelling by bus only.

Andy Byford, who is the current Commissioner of Transport for London, used to work at the MTA in a similar position, and had previous experience at London Underground before he went to work in New York.

His experience was instrumental in introducing the OMNY system in New York, which is similar in many ways to the Oyster system.
 

Roger1973

Member
Joined
5 Jul 2020
Messages
859
Location
Berkshire
To be very obscure, but I believe that the first 'flat fare' LT service may have been the Inter-Station route (initially evenings and nights, later nights only) which had a (then premium) flat fare of one shilling for any journey from its transfer to LT in 1936, and fairly sure it was outside the standard fare structure until it was replaced with conventional night routes in 1985.

The 'red book' timetables (one reproduced here) mentioned that LT staff free passes were not valid for travel, I think it was initially at least operated under contract to the main line railway companies.

And of course some special shuttle services, e.g. to sporting events etc, were flat fare.
 

Busaholic

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Jun 2014
Messages
14,671
I recall the W8 being flat fare in the 1970s. This page suggests it was flat fare from its introduction in 1969.
https://www.londonbuses.co.uk/_routes/prefix/w8.html
I have a vague recollection that all the W routes were always flat fare.
They were, as were all letter prefixed routes for a few years, excepting the N prefix night services.

The first non-Red Arrow, non-prefix flat fare route was the 615 in 1970. I went on it with an L.T. colleague on its first day in the p.m. peak and we were the sole passengers, even though many would-be passengers waiting for a 15 could have saved themselves some cash by joining us!
 

busestrains

On Moderation
Joined
9 Sep 2022
Messages
788
Location
Salisbury
As it has been mentioned there has been mostly flat fares since the 1980s or so. However it was not entirely one fare. There was still a few differently priced fares for some local short distance journeys and some separate peak time and off peak fares. So it was mostly flat fare with a few exceptions and different fares here and there.

However i believe that 01/01/2004 was when all of the remaining other fares were finally abolished and just one simple flat fare that was the same regardless of route or distance travelled was introduced.

The fares then became as follows:

• 01/01/2004-31/12/2004 - £0.70-Oyster / £1.00-Cash
• 01/01/2005-31/12/2005 - £1.00-Oyster / £1.20-Cash
• 01/01/2006-31/12/2006 - £1.00-Oyster / £1.50-Cash
• 01/01/2007-31/12/2007 - £1.00-Oyster / £2.00-Cash
• 01/01/2008-31/12/2008 - £0.90-Oyster / £2.00-Cash
• 01/01/2009-31/12/2009 - £1.00-Oyster / £2.00-Cash
• 01/01/2010-31/12/2010 - £1.20-Oyster / £2.00-Cash
• 01/01/2011-31/12/2011 - £1.30-Oyster / £2.20-Cash
• 01/01/2012-31/12/2012 - £1.35-Oyster / £2.30-Cash
• 01/01/2013-31/12/2013 - £1.40-Oyster / £2.40-Cash
• 01/01/2014-05/07/2014 - £1.45-Oyster / £2.40-Cash

The 05/07/2014 was the last day that cash was accepted on the bus and from the 06/07/2014 it became Oyster (or Contactless too) only if you pay onboard the bus.

• 06/07/2014-31/12/2014 - £1.45-Oyster
• 01/01/2015-31/02/2021 - £1.50-Oyster
• 01/03/2021-31/02/2022 - £1.55-Oyster
• 01/03/2022-31/02/2023 - £1.65-Oyster

Amazingly the fare stayed at £1.50 for over six years but it has increased the past two years and will probably increase again next year too.

Before the 1980s or so i believe London was just like the rest of the UK is now and fares were distance based with the price increasing every couple of stops. Then they had Return tickets too which cost about 1.5 times the Single fare. This ticketing arrangement is still used on buses in most other places in the UK.
 

Roger1973

Member
Joined
5 Jul 2020
Messages
859
Location
Berkshire
Before the 1980s or so i believe London was just like the rest of the UK is now and fares were distance based with the price increasing every couple of stops. Then they had Return tickets too which cost about 1.5 times the Single fare. This ticketing arrangement is still used on buses in most other places in the UK.

Broadly, yes.

The London Bus Route Histories website has old fare charts for many routes - the page on route 21 (for example) has a 'fares' link at the bottom of the page which links to a 1966 fare chart in PDF form. There seems to have been a slight discount for longer journeys - the fares rose by 4d a time for the shortest journeys, 3d a time for most, and 2d a time for the longest. And I believe the fare stages were slightly closer together in central London.

Return tickets on London Transport (central / red) buses were very much a rarity - I wouldn't want to say they never existed, but I can't immediately think of any examples. They may have been more common before 1933 when the buses were in competition with independent operators and the trams on many routes.

I don't think they were all that common on the country buses and Green Line coaches until London Country had become a separate entity and started to follow National Bus Company practices. (Some 'red bus' routes followed London Country fares when they crossed the Greater London boundary - I think one or two may have had return fares in the 70s / 80s?)

London County Council trams had a comprehensive range of return, workman returns (only available before a certain time in the morning), cheap mid-day fares, and transfer tickets (so that you weren't penalised if there wasn't a direct service between A and B) - this was continued by LT and on the replacement trolleybuses, but was gradually abolished by 1950 when buses started replacing trams. ('Early Morning Single' fares applied for a few years as part compensation for the loss of workman return tickets.)

Again, there were a few examples where transfer tickets were available on red bus routes (until about 1950) but only a few.
 

PeterC

Established Member
Joined
29 Sep 2014
Messages
4,782
Return tickets on London Transport (central / red) buses were very much a rarity - I wouldn't want to say they never existed, but I can't immediately think of any examples. They may have been more common before 1933 when the buses were in competition with independent operators and the trams on many routes.
Returns certainly weren't available on any routes that I used as a boy in the 60s.

At some point when I was regularly bus spotting (64 to 66) LT published a plan proposing OPO operated flat fare routes around suburban hubs and crew operated radial routescwith staged fares. This started to be implemented with the first letter prefixed routes.
 

Busaholic

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Jun 2014
Messages
14,671
Returns certainly weren't available on any routes that I used as a boy in the 60s.

At some point when I was regularly bus spotting (64 to 66) LT published a plan proposing OPO operated flat fare routes around suburban hubs and crew operated radial routescwith staged fares. This started to be implemented with the first letter prefixed routes.
I'm as certain as you and Roger1973 that the Central area (i.e. red buses) never had return fares, but I'm not sure about the Country Area (green buses.) From my reading, the Gibson ticket machine that became the norm for bus conductors from 1953 onwards did have a code 'R' for return tickets, but that might have been provided 'just in case.' The Gibson was the invention of the man of that name who was boss of the L.T. Effra Road, Brixton Ticket Machine Works
 

Enthusiast

Established Member
Joined
18 Mar 2019
Messages
1,226
Flat rate fares were originally introduced about 50 years ago on a few services (called Red Arrow) in central London, which generally did routes between the main rail stations...
The original “modern day” (!) Red Arrow bus - Route 500 - was introduced in 1966, running between Victoria and Marble Arch during the peaks and over a circular route (via Grosvenor Square) returning to Victoria, at other times. The concept was extended and by 1972 there were eight routes:

500 Victoria - Park Lane - Oxford Street - Marble Arch - Park Lane - Victoria

501 Waterloo - Aldwych - Holborn - St Pauls - Bank - London Bridge

502 Waterloo - Aldwych - Fleet Street - St Pauls - London Wall - Liverpool Street

503 Waterloo - Westminster Bridge - Victoria

505 Waterloo - Aldwych - Holborn - Old Street - Shoreditch Church

506 Victoria - Green Park - Piccadilly Circus

507 Waterloo - Lambeth Bridge - Victoria

513 Waterloo - Aldwych - Fleet Street - St Pauls - Cannon Street - London Bridge


I used to 500 daily between 1975 and 1977. The flat fare was collected by means of a pair of turnstiles immediately behind the driver’s cab. Passengers had to insert an old sixpence (6d) coin (which, following decimalisation in 1971, was worth two and a half “New Pence”) and the turnstile would release to allow them through. These entries took up about a quarter of the length of the bus.

I'm as certain as you and Roger1973 that the Central area (i.e. red buses) never had return fares, but I'm not sure about the Country Area (green buses.) From my reading, the Gibson ticket machine that became the norm for bus conductors from 1953 onwards did have a code 'R' for return tickets, but that might have been provided 'just in case.' The Gibson was the invention of the man of that name who was boss of the L.T. Effra Road, Brixton Ticket Machine Works
I am absolutely certain that return fares were not offered on London's red routes. They were offered on Green Line coaches but I'm not sure about London Country routes as I rarely, if ever used them.

I have a Gibson A14 ticket machine, complete with carry case and harness. It has six "classes" of ticket:

ORD: Ordinary
COM: Combination (when two or more tickets had to be issued to make up the fare)
C: Child
EMS: Early Morning Single
X: Excursion
R: Return
 

MotCO

Established Member
Joined
25 Aug 2014
Messages
6,124
Were there any return tickets allowed on red buses which ran parallel with London Country buses where returns were offered? I'm thinking of places like where the 406 and 418 had a common section with the 281 from Kingston.

Also, there was a flat fare on route A1 from Hatton Cross to Heathrow from 1969 to 1977.
 

Deerfold

Veteran Member
Joined
26 Nov 2009
Messages
13,751
Location
Yorkshire
Also, there was a flat fare on route A1 from Hatton Cross to Heathrow from 1969 to 1977.
Hounslow West, rather than Hatton Cross, surely?

And it's hard not to be flat fare when there's no intermediate stops (though there were some garage extensions).
 

RT4038

Established Member
Joined
22 Feb 2014
Messages
5,459
Were there any return tickets allowed on red buses which ran parallel with London Country buses where returns were offered? I'm thinking of places like where the 406 and 418 had a common section with the 281 from Kingston.

Also, there was a flat fare on route A1 from Hatton Cross to Heathrow from 1969 to 1977.
Returns were not generally available on LT Country Buses, or London Country buses when the Gibson machine was used . There were exceptions on certain sections of outlying Country bus routes (for instance in the Brentwood-Ongar area and I think Tring-Aylesbury ) which lay outside the designated LT area and other operators farescales and conditions applied. Returns were issued on Green Line Coaches, but conductors on these never used the Gibson. (Speed Setrights were used to mechanise). Red buses never had returns.

For the last word in all things 'Gibson' I recommend the recently published book 'Mr Gibson's ticket machine' by Anthony Cross ISBN 978 1 85414 465 2
 

Falcon1200

Established Member
Joined
14 Jun 2021
Messages
6,586
Location
Neilston, East Renfrewshire
I don't think they were all that common on the country buses and Green Line coaches until London Country had become a separate entity and started to follow National Bus Company practices.

I lived in Harlow, served by London Country, from 1978 to 1980, and a flat fare system operated there; IIRC it was a silly amount, 18p I think, requiring a pocket full of change!
 
Joined
1 Aug 2014
Messages
440
The flat fare on the original Red Arrow services applied also to children - there was a 6d-in-the-slot turnstile.
 

MotCO

Established Member
Joined
25 Aug 2014
Messages
6,124
Hounslow West, rather than Hatton Cross, surely?

And it's hard not to be flat fare when there's no intermediate stops (though there were some garage extensions).
Whoops, yes, Hounslow West.
 

RELL6L

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
1,261
Whoops, yes, Hounslow West.
Didn't they extend the Piccadilly line first to Hatton Cross before it went all the way to Heathrow? My recollection is that they did then run the A1 from Hatton Cross to Heathrow. And it would have been flat fare!
 

busesrusuk

Member
Joined
19 May 2020
Messages
418
Location
London
The Piccadilly line extension to Heathrow Central opened on the 16 December 1977 and that is recorded as the last day of operation of the A1 as noted on the excellent London Bus routes website by Ian Armstrong (https://www.londonbuses.co.uk/ which gives a pretty complete history of all red London bus routes). Sources suggest that the Piccadilly line opened to Hatton Cross in 1975 so it seems the A1 continued until the full extension was opened.

As an aside, during the 81 running day earlier this year the route was reprised with a few journeys on the A1 operated by an MBA type bus (A type that didn't actually operate the route as the route started with MBS vehicles before being converted to SMS and then LS in its last year of operation). Pic here of that operation:

 

Enthusiast

Established Member
Joined
18 Mar 2019
Messages
1,226
Sources suggest that the Piccadilly line opened to Hatton Cross in 1975
Sources are correct. Hatton Cross opened on 19th July 1975. It marked the high water mark for the number of stations on the network. This is quoted at 279 but, try as I may to get to that number (and I've worked forwards from the opening of the system and backwards from the current total of 272) I make it 280. However, I digress.
 

busesrusuk

Member
Joined
19 May 2020
Messages
418
Location
London
Thanks, I coudn't seem to find the actual date of opening for Hatton Cross. In response to the original question, I don't think there has been reference to the first attempt at introducing a system wide flat fare; I need to check but believe it was done as part of the original Fares fair scheme introduced in the early 80's by Ken Livingstone when he was at the GLC.

From memory it was introduced outside of the central zone but was removed following a legal challenge by tory controlled Bexley council. I stand to be corrected on this hence the need to check. However, as a consequence of this scheme buses were adorned with stickers on the front of the bus proclaiming the fact that a flat fare was in operation. This particular image shows the accompanying advertising campaign that announced its introduction:

 

Enthusiast

Established Member
Joined
18 Mar 2019
Messages
1,226
From memory it was introduced outside of the central zone but was removed following a legal challenge by tory controlled Bexley council.
It was the London Borough of Bromley which led a successful challenge against GLC Leader Ken Livingstone's "Fares Fair" policy:

 

Roger1973

Member
Joined
5 Jul 2020
Messages
859
Location
Berkshire
From my reading, the Gibson ticket machine that became the norm for bus conductors from 1953 onwards did have a code 'R' for return tickets, but that might have been provided 'just in case.' The Gibson was the invention of the man of that name who was boss of the L.T. Effra Road, Brixton Ticket Machine Works

To be pedantic, at the time of its invention, he was superintendent of the punch repair works on Stockwell Road (the site if not the building had been a horse tram depot) - Effra Road just did printing (mainly of tickets) at that time - the two functions were concentrated at Effra Road in the post-war era.

I have a Gibson A14 ticket machine, complete with carry case and harness. It has six "classes" of ticket:

ORD: Ordinary
COM: Combination (when two or more tickets had to be issued to make up the fare)
C: Child
EMS: Early Morning Single
X: Excursion
R: Return

That's possibly a rarity - most I've seen have C/M rather than R. (including the one in my own collection, which is alpha coded and appears to have been used at Peckham on route 12 until fairly late on.)

X seems to have been more a 'miscellaneous' than Excursion. C/M is understood to have been intended for 'cheap mid-day' although not sure such fares still existed by the time they went in to production.

Is yours a country area machine? One that prints the date not a route number?

Returns were issued on Green Line Coaches, but conductors on these never used the Gibson. (Speed Setrights were used to mechanise). Red buses never had returns.

I've read somewhere that Gibsons were occasionally used on Green Line relief 'coaches' at peak summer weekends in the early /mid 50s when sunday reliefs were at their highest, as there weren't enough Setrights to go round. If that's true, it must have led to some quite long tickets to make up the fare values, and some nonsense trying to match the number of tickets issued with the capacity of the vehicle...


The flat fare on the original Red Arrow services applied also to children - there was a 6d-in-the-slot turnstile.

I think that applied at least until the MBAs with turnstiles were withdrawn (the concept not the 6d fare) - I have a vague recollection of being taken for a ride on one by my late father, probably soon before they were withdrawn (to get a ride on an MBA and to go through the Strand Underpass) and being mildly annoyed not to get a ticket...

Thanks, I coudn't seem to find the actual date of opening for Hatton Cross. In response to the original question, I don't think there has been reference to the first attempt at introducing a system wide flat fare; I need to check but believe it was done as part of the original Fares fair scheme introduced in the early 80's by Ken Livingstone when he was at the GLC.

Just before that - March 1981, as in

The Conservative led GLC introduced a flat fare zone in the outer suburbs in early 1981, and when Labour won control of the GLC later that year they introduced a system where there was a short hop fare (for very short journeys) and a standard flat fare (for longer journeys).

Although my understanding is that the (late 1981, Labour GLC) scheme wasn't flat fare - it was zonal (outer, inner, City and West end) with fares (and passes) being based on the number of zones travelled in, with a 'short hop' for (I think) 2 fare stages. The City and West End zones were later merged to become Zone 1.

Although many suburban routes only ran in the outer zone - for example, Lewisham was on the inner / outer zone boundary, so routes that terminated at Lewisham from the outer suburbs effectively just had the short hop fare and the one-zone fare.

Broadly, the late 1981 'outer zone' was the same as the March 1981 flat fare area, but it's quite possible there were some adjustments.
 

MotCO

Established Member
Joined
25 Aug 2014
Messages
6,124
I think that applied at least until the MBAs with turnstiles were withdrawn (the concept not the 6d fare) - I have a vague recollection of being taken for a ride on one by my late father, probably soon before they were withdrawn (to get a ride on an MBA and to go through the Strand Underpass) and being mildly annoyed not to get a ticket...
I have a memory of the Red Arrows being farebox buses rather than turnstyle. Am I mis-remembering?
 

Roger1973

Member
Joined
5 Jul 2020
Messages
859
Location
Berkshire
I have a memory of the Red Arrows being farebox buses rather than turnstyle. Am I mis-remembering?

Depending on when you are remembering, no you're not.

The LSs had fareboxes (photo - not mine - here) at least some of the time, and as I remember them.

I am fairly sure the Red Arrow LSs were new with fareboxes rather than turnstiles, and I think the MBA's kept turnstiles until they were withdrawn (although I think I only travelled on one the once.) Although there was a brief overlap (not sure if each route was converted in one go or whether there was ever a mixed allocation on one route - at that time, they were spread out among a few garages rather than a single Red Arrow base) so anything is possible.

And some SMSs were moved on to Red Arrow routes around 1979/80 - I can find a few photographs of them in action, but can't see clearly if they had a farebox or not.

Around the time the LSs were introduced was when LT started pushing bus pass sales, and think there was initially an option to add a bus pass on to a train season ticket (it may have started with Underground seasons and extended to BR seasons, before 'Capitalcard' became a thing. At that time my father worked within walking distance of a Southern Region terminus, so didn't travel by bus in central London regularly enough to get one) so there would have been a need to allow passengers on to the Red Arrow routes without making a cash payment. I don't think the turnstiles had an arrangement where the driver could allow a free entry, as that could have been open to fiddling...
 

busesrusuk

Member
Joined
19 May 2020
Messages
418
Location
London
Depending on when you are remembering, no you're not.

The LSs had fareboxes (photo - not mine - here) at least some of the time, and as I remember them.

I am fairly sure the Red Arrow LSs were new with fareboxes rather than turnstiles, and I think the MBA's kept turnstiles until they were withdrawn (although I think I only travelled on one the once.) Although there was a brief overlap (not sure if each route was converted in one go or whether there was ever a mixed allocation on one route - at that time, they were spread out among a few garages rather than a single Red Arrow base) so anything is possible.

And some SMSs were moved on to Red Arrow routes around 1979/80 - I can find a few photographs of them in action, but can't see clearly if they had a farebox or not.

Around the time the LSs were introduced was when LT started pushing bus pass sales, and think there was initially an option to add a bus pass on to a train season ticket (it may have started with Underground seasons and extended to BR seasons, before 'Capitalcard' became a thing. At that time my father worked within walking distance of a Southern Region terminus, so didn't travel by bus in central London regularly enough to get one) so there would have been a need to allow passengers on to the Red Arrow routes without making a cash payment. I don't think the turnstiles had an arrangement where the driver could allow a free entry, as that could have been open to fiddling...
I'm pretty certain that both the MBA's and the SMS's had fareboxes in later life. I'm pretty certain the SMS's would have been farebox fitted by the time they transferred to Red Arrow work. The turnstiles were pretty unreliable, and I think may have been replaced during their lives by fareboxes. The driver was able to release the turnstiles from the cab - again due to their general unreliability in the main. The LS's had fareboxes from new.

As an aside Waterloo garage employed dedicated "coinbox handlers" to remove and empty the cash when the buses returned to the garage. Ultimately, they were made redundant, quite possibly around the time when the network went cash free. Can't remember exactly when it was as I wasn't directly involved in that particular change.
 

Roger1973

Member
Joined
5 Jul 2020
Messages
859
Location
Berkshire
As an aside Waterloo garage employed dedicated "coinbox handlers" to remove and empty the cash when the buses returned to the garage. Ultimately, they were made redundant, quite possibly around the time when the network went cash free. Can't remember exactly when it was as I wasn't directly involved in that particular change.

I'd read about people (usually re-deployed conductors displaced by OPO conversions) having that role within London Country at garages where there was farebox operation. I wasn't aware that LT had similar but it figures (there could have been one or two at each of the garages that did Red Arrow before they were all moved to one location)

Wonder how it worked at places like Bromley that had farebox route B1 with about 2 or 3 buses?

Although it must have been (at least part of) someone's job to empty the 'automatic fare collection' machines on DMS and SMS types when they were in use...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top