lammergeier
Member
- Joined
- 5 Oct 2017
- Messages
- 505
The river Rother flows under Chesterfield station.
The rail tunnel intersects with the canal tunnel, it doesn't actually use it in the sense trains run along its former alignment.Also Southampton uses an old canal tunnel
I think the Westbourne is a sewer. The aqueduct was hit by a bomb in WW2 flooding the station in filthy water. The rebuilt station had only been open a short while.Sloane Square is under the River Westbourne
View attachment 124056
The River Fleet ‘sewer’ passes under St Pancras, I understand.
The Porter Brook runs under Sheffield station.
Indirectly, but it doesn’t really. The culverted Fleet river goes round the front of the hotel, well clear of its basement, then heads north under the road before veering towards St Pancras. So effectively the river culvert defined the hotel position. The curve of the new concourse was then designed to integrate with the back of the hotel.You beat me to it. I understand the curved shape of Kings + station concourse owes its design to the river bank (before it was covered).
The tunnel between Higham and Strood was originally a canal tunnel.Higham area I believe
Also Southampton uses an old canal tunnel
It’s possible technically a corner of Platform 2 might be over the Avon, I wouldn’t know without checking, but the station itself is most definitely not over the river.Bath Spa.
... and for a station to be (expensively) over a wide river, it would need to be in or very near an important city.To achieve this you need a wide river to start with - or put up with very short platforms!![]()
Yes, Consall.A historical one which almost qualifies: I think one of the stations (by the A53 N of the Potteries) had the single railway line behind a retaining wall above the Caldon canal and the platform cantilevered out over the canal! I can't see it on the historical maps now, (https://maps.nls.uk/view/101595884) so maybe it is one of the platforms on the restored Churnet Valley railway...
If we are allowed Ryde Pier Head, then can we really stretch the point. What about the Brighton and Rottingdean, where the Daddy Long-Legs never came into land (tidal conditions permitting)!?... and for a station to be (expensively) over a wide river, it would need to be in or very near an important city.
Now to stretch the definition of a river, Ryde Pier Head is totally over the Solent which is the estuary of Southampton Water into which the Test and Itchen flow.![]()
If Ryde Pier Head is allowed, then so must be Portsmouth Harbour.If we are allowed Ryde Pier Head, then can we really stretch the point. What about the Brighton and Rottingdean, where the Daddy Long-Legs never came into land (tidal conditions permitting)!?(OK, OK, I know the B&R was a tramway!)
Surely not? They're both over open seawater!If Ryde Pier Head is allowed, then so must be Portsmouth Harbour.
That's the way I see it, but.....Surely not? They're both over open seawater!
... and for a station to be (expensively) over a wide river, it would need to be in or very near an important city.
Now to stretch the definition of a river, Ryde Pier Head is totally over the Solent which is the estuary of Southampton Water into which the Test and Itchen flow.![]()
Next thing you’ll be suggesting Portsmouth Harbour Station is on one of the estuaries of the River Wallington.... and for a station to be (expensively) over a wide river, it would need to be in or very near an important city.
Now to stretch the definition of a river, Ryde Pier Head is totally over the Solent which is the estuary of Southampton Water into which the Test and Itchen flow.![]()
Portsmouth harbour (as are many of the inlets on the S coast) is a drowned river valley or ria. This is caused by the Uk sinking in the south while rising in Scotland as it recovers from the massive weight of ice over N Uk in the ice age. The raised beaches in Scotland are the evidence of the rising ground there.Next thing you’ll be suggesting Portsmouth Harbour Station is on one of the estuaries of the River Wallington.(It runs through Fareham for anyone wondering.)
Yes, none of us should take these trivia threads too seriously.Although not actually specified by the OP, I would take 'river' to mean a contained free-flowing stream of (relatively) fresh water....and 'estuary' (or 'firth' in Scotland) to mean a wide expanse of tidal salt water forming an inlet from the sea. Although one flows into the other, if it were my thread I would not accept Portsmouth Harbour or Ryde Pierhead....although I realise that those suggestions were made in jest.![]()