I asked Shaw if he understood what the flashing Yellow aspects approaching Colwich meant. He stated that, as at Norton Bridge, he thought that the flashing Yellow aspects took him not only from the Down Fast line to the Down Slow line, but through Colwich Junction onto the Down Manchester line. When he received a steady Yellow aspect at Signal CH28 he thought "They have altered it, it is different from Norton Bridge and they must still have the track approach". He knew he was entitled to go through the crossover at 45 mile/h and therefore braked down to 40 mile/h. Signal CH28 did not change from its single Yellow aspect as he passed it, but he still believed that the junction signal, CH23, which was displaying a Red aspect, first as he approached the banner repeater and then as he approached the actual signal would change from Red to a proceed aspect as the approach release cleared. When he realised that the Red aspect was not going to clear, he made an emergency brake application at a point some 40 yards before the signal, or 300 yards from the junction.
49. Shaw admitted that his trouble, in addition to failing to study the notices outlining the alterations to the signalling at Colwich, was that he believed that the arrangement was similar to that at Norton Bridge and that the flashing Yellow aspects meant that the line was clear for him to proceed through the junction onto the Down Manchester line. I asked Shaw why, having received a single steady Yellow at Signal CH28 which did not clear to a less restrictive aspect as he passed it, he had any reason to expect Signal CH23 to clear from Red and allow a clear run across the switch diamonds to the Down Manchester line. He replied that on every occasion when he had encountered flashing Yellow aspects, he had never encountered a Red aspect. He accepted that, having passed Signal CH28 at a steady single Yellow aspect, he passed the banner repeater for signal CH23 in the 'On' position and then, despite his emergency application of the brake some 40 yards before Signal CH23, be passed the signal at Danger.