• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Mysterious Black ring used by train drivers/signal operators

Status
Not open for further replies.

MattA7

Member
Joined
27 Jan 2019
Messages
473
At my local train station when the train arrives at the station the driver always stops and passes a large black ring like thing to the signalman (there is a white signal office just before the station) then proceeds to the platform.

what is this large black ring like thing and what purpose does it serve?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

MarkyT

Established Member
Joined
20 May 2012
Messages
7,611
Location
Torbay
At my local train station when the train arrives at the station the driver always stops and passes a large black ring like thing to the signalman (there is a white signal office just before the station) then proceeds to the platform.

what is this large black ring like thing and what purpose does it serve?
A single line token or train staff contained in a pouch with the larger ring form handle to make it easier to pass between signaller and crew without dropping it.
 

MattA7

Member
Joined
27 Jan 2019
Messages
473
Thanks. Interestingly after finding out the name Wikipedia used my local train station as a example of locations where it still continues to be in use.
 

ac6000cw

Established Member
Joined
10 May 2014
Messages
3,917
Location
Cambridge, UK
Non-stop exchanges being particularly entertaining for the observer ;)

Judging by the speed it's going as it passes the 'box and the acceleration after the re-start, that was a 'lets get the hell of town' bit of driving that didn't quite work out ;)

(Nice bit of Alco 251 diesel thrash too...)
 

Killingworth

Established Member
Joined
30 May 2018
Messages
6,499
Location
Sheffield
Not always a signalman these days, this at Ambergate on the Derwent Valley line from Matlock. Token in locked cabinet and phone ahead.

IMG_20190604_145244.jpg
 

Bill57p9

Member
Joined
1 Dec 2019
Messages
902
Location
Ayrshire
Girvan, South Ayrshire
The line between Girvan and Stranraer is well known for being the last main line use of tablet working in the UK with the equipment dating from the 19th century. Elsewhere Network Rail metals use the later "token" system. Although functionally the same a "tablet" is a round disc whereas a "token" tends to be more staff or key like.

The tablet equipment is quite visible at Barrhill station, where the box is on the platform at platform level.

The other tablet exchange points are at Glenwhilly and Dunragit signal boxes, where all trains stop purely to exchange tablets. Glenwhilly is notable as it is believed to have the last working distant semaphore in Scotland.

Between Girvan and Ayr the single line working is "tokenless block" which doesn't employ a physical token.


EDIT - Excuse the link, however the photograph is copyright. Picture of tablets being exchanged at Glenwhilly https://railscot.co.uk/img/12/56/
 

XAM2175

Established Member
Joined
8 Jun 2016
Messages
3,471
Location
Glasgow
Judging by the speed it's going as it passes the 'box and the acceleration after the re-start, that was a 'lets get the hell of town' bit of driving that didn't quite work out ;)

(Nice bit of Alco 251 diesel thrash too...)

15 mph limit for a manual exchange in daylight, would you believe? :E

(and yeah you really do have to love the 251s)
 

MarkyT

Established Member
Joined
20 May 2012
Messages
7,611
Location
Torbay
Not always a signalman these days, this at Ambergate on the Derwent Valley line from Matlock. Token in locked cabinet and phone ahead.
In some places there have been 'auxiliary' token machines directly accessed by train crew for decades, going back even before BR. They might be located in a cabinet on a platform like this, or at the end of a goods loop, so the signaller (or crew member) doesn't have to walk possibly hundreds of yards to issue or collect a token for certain movement sequences for which the box is at the wrong end of the station for example. In this case, the token is released remotely by the EMCC (East Midlands Control Centre). On the Central Wales line, all the intermediate crossing loops have token machines in platform cabinets operated by the train crew. An unusual feature of that line is that the tokens, while clearly interlocked with each other as necessary to ensure only one can be out of a system for a particular single line section, the keys are free to be removed (if safe) without a release being given by the signaller, although verbal authority by telephone must be obtained for each withdrawal. In this system, engineered in the cash strapped 1980s, the machines at opposite ends of each section were originally linked by leased private BT lines to avoid having to provide cabling alongside the whole line as a replacement for the old aerial pole route. A safety-certified FDM (frequency division multiplex) 'Reed' system operating at audio frequencies carried multiple bits of relay state data across each BT link.
 

norbitonflyer

Established Member
Joined
24 Mar 2020
Messages
5,828
Location
SW London
I seem to recall reading that on some lines alternate sections use tablets and tokens to avoid mistakes of the kind that happened at Abermule in 1921 - when a misunderstanding between staff at the station led to a driver mistakenly being given back the tablet he had just arrived with. The driver failed to check what it was, thus believing he had authority to proceed into the next section. In fact a tablet was already out for that section, on board a train coming the other way. The errant driver was among the seventeen fatalities in the resulting head-on collision.
 
Last edited:

MarkyT

Established Member
Joined
20 May 2012
Messages
7,611
Location
Torbay
I seem to recall reading that on some lines alternate sections use tablets and tokens to avoid mistakes of the kind that happened at Abermule in 1921 - when a misunderstanding between staff at the station led to a driver mistakenly being given back the tablet he had just arrived with. The driver failed to check what it was, thus believing he had authority to proceed into the next section. In fact a tablet was already out for that section, on board a train coming the other way. The errant driver was among the seventeen fatalities in the resulting head-on collision.
I don't know about that, but in addition to the distinct section names engraved on the tokens, Tyers key token, the most common type in UK today, are configured to one of four patterns that cannot be inserted into a non-matching machine. All machines in a particular signalbox must be of different configurations to avoid the risk of a signaller mistakenly placing a token in the wrong one. The key ends have slots cut in varying positions to distinguish them from their neighbours. Identified by the letter code, a view of each configuration looking along the key from the handle end is illustrated below, showing the relative positions of the slots that engage with corresponding pins in their matching machine. The modern cast tokens are painted distinct colours according to their pattern: A = red, B = blue, C = green, D = yellow.

token config.jpg
Here's a pair of machines at Ashburton Junction SB on my local heritage railway, the SDR. In this case, the next SB can switch out. The green tokens are for the short section to Bishops Bridge, while the yellow ones cover the long section to Buckfastleigh when Bishops Bridge is switched out. The key release instrument on the cabinet to the right holds the train staff for the short connecting line to National Rail Totnes.
1636718294622.png
1636719095157.png
 

matchmaker

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2009
Messages
1,890
Location
Central Scotland
It's also worth mentioning that there used to exist automatic token exchange apparatus, which allowed tokens/tablets to be exchanged at speed. The best known was Manson's, invented by James Manson of the Great North of Scotland Railway. Article here Manson . It was still in use well into BR days, the last installations being between Aberdeen and Inverness where it was fitted to the Swindon Cross-Country DMUs, under control of the guard.

Photo of the installation on a class 25

Manson.jpg
 

norbitonflyer

Established Member
Joined
24 Mar 2020
Messages
5,828
Location
SW London
I don't know about that, but in addition to the distinct section names engraved on the tokens, Tyers key token, the most common type in UK today, are configured to one of four patterns that cannot be inserted into a non-matching machine. All machines in a particular signalbox must be of different configurations to avoid the risk of a signaller mistakenly placing a token in the wrong one. The modern cast tokens are painted distinct colours according to their pattern: A = red, B = blue, C = green, D = yellow.
None of that would have prevented Abermule. The token was never put in the machine. The porter who collected the token from the driver gave it, in its pouch, to the stationmaster to replace in the machine. The stationmaster thought the porter had already done this, and that he was being given a token for the next section that the porter had just taken from the other machine. In fact no-one had been in the machine room since a third person, unbeknown to the other two, had operated the release for a token to be retrieved at the other end of the single line section, allowing a train coming the other way into the section and preventing another token for that section being released.

Neither the stationmaster nor the driver checked what was actually in the pouch.

After Abermule, rules became much stricter about who could operate the tablet machines, where they were installed (Abermule's was in the stationmaster's office, not the signalbox) and interlocking the tablet equipment with the signals.
 

MarkyT

Established Member
Joined
20 May 2012
Messages
7,611
Location
Torbay
After Abermule, rules became much stricter about who could operate the tablet machines, where they were installed (Abermule's was in the stationmaster's office, not the signalbox) and interlocking the tablet equipment with the signals.
Agreed. The final point is the critical one in my view, as a token needs to be withdrawn from the appropriate machine for the associated block signal lever to be released electrically to pull, so if there's an incoming train just arrived from the same section, that one's token/tablet must be inserted first to put the system back in phase for the subsequent withdrawal. Later circuits also enforce a 'one pull' feature, so if the block signal has been cleared already but needs to be replaced to danger for any reason before departure, the token must be run through the machine again in cooperation with the signaller at the other end of the section in order for the signal to be released again. All actions logged in the train register of course. Just as today, the cumulative improvements in system and procedural safety were built on the findings and recommendations of accident investigations over decades.
 

380101

Member
Joined
18 Feb 2015
Messages
1,141
The tablet equipment is quite visible at Barrhill station, where the box is on the platform at platform lelevel.
The tablet equipment is not in the signal box at Barrhill, it is within the station office on the Platform along with the GSM-R telephone where the signaller spends all his time unless exchanging tablets with the driver or pulling off signals.
 
Joined
24 Apr 2021
Messages
8
Location
Lichfield
Supprised that the line to Stranraer has not gone radio token given it would allow more fleet flexibility withing the sprinters on the West Highland Line.
 

Tomnick

Established Member
Joined
10 Jun 2005
Messages
5,933
Supprised that the line to Stranraer has not gone radio token given it would allow more fleet flexibility withing the sprinters on the West Highland Line.
It wouldn't give more flexibility, it'd reduce it. An RETB-fitted unit can work over the Stranraer line under the current signalling - it doesn't need any special equipment fitted to the train.
 

Rescars

Established Member
Joined
25 May 2021
Messages
2,582
Location
Surrey
If you can find a copy of Tales of the Glasgow and South Western Railway by David L Smith, you'll find lots of anecdotes about single line working and tablet changing in Galloway and Ayrshire - and more about Manson's and other varieties of tablet exchange apparatus.
 

calopez

Member
Joined
16 May 2017
Messages
114
One of my most memorable footplate rides in India was on a WP class pacific hauled express between Lucknow and Varanasi, which involved a token exchange at speed. The apparatus on the loco was extremely simple – just a prong which the driver unhooked from the side of the cab as we approached the pick-up point. He told me to stand clear, very wisely as the token hoop slammed into the side of the cab with considerable force! The driver then extracted the token from its pouch and examined it with the leading fireman (there were two other firemen) to confirm that it was, indeed, for the correct section.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top