• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Midland Connect new master plan for HS2 hub at Toton

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
5 Aug 2011
Messages
791
‘Revolutionary’ new plans are being put forward to the Government today, calling for three tram extensions, new train lines and stations and better transport connections for hundreds of thousands of people.

Put forward by powerful lobbying body Midlands Connect, 11 substantial infrastructure projects totalling £2.7 billion could significantly change the public transport landscape.

One of three tram extensions proposed would involve tracks being laid to Long Eaton, with around six trams per hour, at an estimated cost of £115 million. It is hoped this could be operational by 2030.

Another, at a cost of £375 million, would involve the tram going from the yet-to-be-built HS2 station at Toton all the way to Derby.

A third would extend further from Long Eaton to Ratcliffe Power Station, which is expected to be redeveloped, and the employment hub at East Midlands Gateway, with an estimated price tag of £430 million.

The biggest project would see a new railway station at East Midlands airport, connected to Midland Mainline services, meaning people could go straight there from Nottingham or Derby. It is anticipated this will cost £820 million.

The Maid Marian line would also be reopened to passenger trains under the plans, meaning people could travel from Mansfield, Ilkeston and Langley Mill straight to the Toton station, instead of having to connect in Nottingham. The report estimates this would cost £85 million.

New, frequent, buses would also join the Toton station with West Bridgford and Clifton at a cost of £5 million - the lowest price of any of the 11 proposals.

Overall, the £2.7 billion transport plan launched today by Sir John Peace aims to help the Government in its ambition to ‘level up’ the East Midlands, recover economically from COVID-19, and make it easier for people to get the East Midlands HS2 hub at Toton.

For years, transport investment in the East Midlands has been significantly below the national average, and UK transport spending per head is currently the lowest in the country - more than four times lower than london, and less than half of what is spent in the North West.


An artist's impression of what the HS2 Hub at Toton could look like

An artist's impression of what the HS2 Hub at Toton could look like (Image: copyright unknown)

In part as a result of transport investment being 49 percent below the UK average, productivity per head in the East Midlands is 23 percent lower than the UK average.

Support for the comprehensive transport strategy has already attracted relatively-rare consensus from political leaders of all colours across the East Midlands.

While comparatively low spending has caused problems historically, some argue it gives the Government opportunities for ‘easy wins’, with under investment giving avenue for higher returns on infrastructure investment.

The plan itself - which has now been presented to the Department for Transport - is broken down into three phases, with the first aiming to be completed and ready to use in 10 years.

At the top of the list for the first phase is the tram extension to Long Eaton.

The second and third phases - which include the other two tram extensions - are scheduled to be operational within 25 years.

While the £2.7 billion price tag may be hefty, the initial ask is more moderate.

Midlands Connect - which put the plan together - is calling for the Government to provide £4.5 million in funding to help develop detailed plans and costs for phase one by the end of next year.

Sir John Peace is the chairman of Midlands Connect and Midlands Engine.


A CGI of the Toton HS2 hub

A CGI of the Toton HS2 hub (Image: East Midlands Councils)
Speaking ahead of the launch of the report, he said:“The arrival of High Speed Two is a watershed moment for our region, and an opportunity that we must grasp with both hands.

“As we work towards an economic renewal post-COVID-19, the East Midlands must step forward and work together to secure the transport network, economic future and social mobility it deserves.

“This truly integrated transport strategy isn’t just about connecting more people to the HS2 station; it will also support the building of new homes, accelerate transformational regeneration and link some of our most deprived communities to nationally-important assets across the East Midlands.

“It means spreading the benefits of high speed rail to businesses and workers across the region, from our great cities of Derby, Leicester and Nottingham, to bustling towns like Mansfield and Loughborough and smaller communities that may otherwise feel HS2 won’t benefit them.

“Our message to Westminster is clear - support us in making this vision a reality.”

Labour Councillor David Mellen is the leader of Nottingham City Council, and represents the Dales ward.

He said: “This transport plan will connect every corner of Nottingham to new housing developments, leisure facilities, jobs and of course, the high speed rail network at Toton.

“We’re passionate about sustainability in this city, and by moving these plans forward we can ensure that everyone, including our most deprived communities have access to a well-connected, green, transport network.”

Councillor Kay Cutts is the leader of Nottinghamshire County Council, and represents Radcliffe on Trent for the Conservatives, as well as being the chairwoman of the HS2 East Midlands Growth Board.

She said: “The arrival of High Speed Two in Nottinghamshire will bring with it widespread regeneration, development and highly-skilled jobs.

“This comprehensive plan ensures that communities in our towns and villages can access these opportunities, and that the benefits of this investment are spread far and wide.

“This isn’t just a transport project, it’s about securing a successful future for our people, promoting prosperity and social mobility for generations to come. We need to work alongside the Government to ensure that the East Midlands sees benefits as soon as possible.”



I can see the benefit of extending the tram to the new HS2 Hub in Toton and on into Long Eaton and then on to Derby though there aren't that many places on route. I am struggling to see the benefit of a loop from Long Eaton over the river Trent to Ratcliffe on Soar power station site.

I carn't really see the point in a rail loop line from the MML to Eastmidllands airport and onto Derby as EMA is mostly low cost carriers and freight.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0219.PNG
    IMG_0219.PNG
    1.1 MB · Views: 66
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Jorge Da Silva

Established Member
Joined
4 Apr 2018
Messages
2,642
Location
Cleethorpes, North East Lincolnshire
1590659620650.png

these are the connections to Toton from each station

from what they are saying it seems like (by Rail):

  • 3tph: Crewe to East Midlands Hub
  • 1tph: Matlock to East Midlands Hub
  • 2tph: Mansfield to East Midlands Hub
  • 1tph: Lincoln to East Midlands Hub
  • 3tph: Nottingham to East Midlands Hub
  • 4tph: Leicester to East Midlands Hub
  • 2tph: East Midlands Airport to East Midlands Hub
These could be amended to run like so:

  • 2tph: Mansfield to East Midlands Airport
  • 1tph: Lincoln to Crewe
  • 2tph: Crewe to Grantham
  • 1tph: Matlock to Nottingham
  • 4tph: Leicester to East Midlands Hub
Plus:

  • 1tph: London Euston to Leeds/Sheffield: Calling at: Old Oak Common, East Midlands Hub
    • Front 200 metres/8 Coaches for: Sheffield
    • Rear 200 metres/8 Coaches for: Leeds
  • 2tph: London Euston to Leeds: Calling at Old Oak Common, Birmingham Interchange (1tph), East Midlands Hub
  • 1tph: London Euston to York: Old Oak Common, East Midlands Hub
    • Front 200 Metres/8 Coaches for: Chesterfield, Sheffield
    • Rear 200 Metres/8 Coaches for: York
  • 2tph: Birmingham Curzon Street to Leeds: East Midlands Hub
  • 1tph: Birmingham Curzon Street to Newcastle: East Midlands Hub, York, Darlington, Durham
  • 1tph: Bedford to Leeds
  • 1tph: Birmingham to Nottingham
 
Last edited:

Jorge Da Silva

Established Member
Joined
4 Apr 2018
Messages
2,642
Location
Cleethorpes, North East Lincolnshire
1590664991744.png
Image: from railmaponline

There is also plans for a new curve called the Trowell curve which would link the East Midlands Hub with Nottingham via the Langley Mill to Nottingham line allowing services to Nottingham to run via the East Midlands Hub
 

edwin_m

Veteran Member
Joined
21 Apr 2013
Messages
28,692
Location
Nottingham
There is also plans for a new curve called the Trowell curve which would link the East Midlands Hub with Nottingham via the Langley Mill to Nottingham line allowing services to Nottingham to run via the East Midlands Hub
That's probably the only way they can get the 4TPH capacity into Nottingham, without which London to the centre of Nottingham will still be quicker via the existing MML.

Engineering-wise it looks horribly difficult. You have the M1, housing, a river and a sewage works in the way, plus HS2 itself in the future, and the level difference between the Nottingham and Toton lines at Trowell is very obvious from the train. I wonder if it might actually have to go off northwards from the line coming out of Nottingham and swing back across it.
 
Joined
5 Aug 2011
Messages
791
That's probably the only way they can get the 4TPH capacity into Nottingham, without which London to the centre of Nottingham will still be quicker via the existing MML.

Engineering-wise it looks horribly difficult. You have the M1, housing, a river and a sewage works in the way, plus HS2 itself in the future, and the level difference between the Nottingham and Toton lines at Trowell is very obvious from the train. I wonder if it might actually have to go off northwards from the line coming out of Nottingham and swing back across it.

The curve and e gradients between the M1 and the Erewash valley line would be very sharp without the obstacles you mention.

Schemes 9 and 10 are the rail access to Eastmidlands airport, Total cost £1.4 billion.

Scheme 9 | Rail

The construction of a railway station at East Midlands Airport, connected to the Midland Mainline via a spur to the south of Kegworth village, allowing new direct rail services to the airport from Derby, Nottingham, Leicester and Mansfield as well as some intermediate stations including HS2 East Midlands Hub and East Midlands Parkway. This intervention will vastly improve public transport access to East Midlands Airport for passengers and staff.

Cost £820m

Scheme 10

A new rail line between East Midlands Airport (opened during Phase 2) and Derby via the South Derby Growth Zone residential and employment developments and the Rolls Royce site, designed to support local housing and employment growth.

Cost £620m
 

Jorge Da Silva

Established Member
Joined
4 Apr 2018
Messages
2,642
Location
Cleethorpes, North East Lincolnshire
Trains to Nottingham and Derby are far too infrequent for it to be a park and ride for those journeys - at that distance P&R probably needs a train/tram/bus every 15min or so. Its main purpose was to provide an alternative starting point for long distance journeys, particularly London. Toton will do that much better for most people. I expect it will end up as a station for local trains only - it does have some purpose as it's right next to the coal-fired power station at Ratcliffe, site which is identified as an opportunity site for re-development.

Decided to include it here as it relates to the wider plan.

Toton could be a very busy station with:

Rail:
  • 2tph: Mansfield to Leicester via Sutton Parkway, Kirkby-in-Ashfield, Langley Mill, Ilkeston, East Midlands Parkway and Loughborough
  • 1tph: Lincoln to Crewe via Newark, Nottingham, Long Eaton, Derby and Stoke-on-Trent
  • 1tph: Crewe to Grantham via Long Eaton, Derby and Stoke-on-Trent
  • 1tph: Crewe to Leicester via Long Eaton, Derby and Stoke-on-Trent
  • 1tph: Matlock to Nottingham via Long Eaton and Derby
  • 2tph: East Midlands Airport to East Midlands Hub Via East Midlands Parkway
  • 1tph: London Euston to Leeds/Sheffield: Calling at: Old Oak Common, East Midlands Hub
    • Front 200 metres/8 Coaches for: Sheffield
    • Rear 200 metres/8 Coaches for: Leeds
  • 2tph: London Euston to Leeds: Calling at Old Oak Common, Birmingham Interchange (1tph), East Midlands Hub
  • 1tph: London Euston to York: Old Oak Common, East Midlands Hub
    • Front 200 Metres/8 Coaches for: Chesterfield, Sheffield
    • Rear 200 Metres/8 Coaches for: York
  • 2tph: Birmingham Curzon Street to Leeds: East Midlands Hub
  • 1tph: Birmingham Curzon Street to Newcastle: East Midlands Hub, York, Darlington, Durham
  • 1tph: Bedford to Leeds calling at: Wellingborough, Kettering, Market Harborough, Leicester, Loughborough, East Midlands Parkway, East Midlands Hub and Leeds
  • 1tph: Birmingham Curzon Street to Nottingham: Calling at: East Midlands Hub and Nottingham
Trams:

  • 14 trams per hour to Nottingham via Beeston, University of Nottingham, Queens Medical Centre
  • 6 trams per hour to Long Eaton
  • 6 trams per hour to Derby City Centre via Longmoor Lane, M1 P&R, Breaston, Draycott, Borrowash, Spondon, Wyvern P&R & Pride Park
  • 2 trams per hour to East Midlands Airport

Bus:

  • 2 buses per hour to Ruddington via Clifton
  • 2 buses per hour to Edwalton via West Bridgford
  • 4 buses per hour to Ripley via Heanor (2 via Ilkeston and 2 via Langley Mill and Pheonix Park P&R)
Buses Rapid Transit:

  • 6 buses per hour to Derby City Centre
 
Last edited:

quantinghome

Established Member
Joined
1 Jun 2013
Messages
2,897
Looks pretty tight. I reckon it's a 250m radius curve to avoid realigning the A6007 and having a separate crossing over the M1. A 450m radius curve could avoid the housing but needs a new bridge over the M1.
 

si404

Established Member
Joined
28 Dec 2012
Messages
1,267
Toton could be a very busy station with:
Presumably, the HS2 classic-compatibles to Leicester/Bedford/probably St Pancras and Nottingham would be included in the 4tph from those cities to Toton? Your list has them as extras, making 5tph.

And, AFAICS, the BRT and Tram to Derby City Centre are mutually exclusive - its one or the other (or maybe one then the other?).

I'd also not be hasty to pair the services up yet - especially as there's a wider network of routes not going via East Midlands Hub that aren't mentioned in this report to consider.
 

Jorge Da Silva

Established Member
Joined
4 Apr 2018
Messages
2,642
Location
Cleethorpes, North East Lincolnshire
Presumably, the HS2 classic-compatibles to Leicester/Bedford/probably St Pancras and Nottingham would be included in the 4tph from those cities to Toton? Your list has them as extras, making 5tph.

And, AFAICS, the BRT and Tram to Derby City Centre are mutually exclusive - its one or the other (or maybe one then the other?).

I'd also not be hasty to pair the services up yet - especially as there's a wider network of routes not going via East Midlands Hub that aren't mentioned in this report to consider.

Amended now. Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top