• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Best UK Train Manufacturer?

Who is objectively the best UK train manufacturer at the present time?

  • Alstom (inc. Bombardier)

    Votes: 42 13.4%
  • CAF

    Votes: 4 1.3%
  • Hitachi

    Votes: 22 7.0%
  • Siemens

    Votes: 129 41.1%
  • Stadler Rail

    Votes: 117 37.3%

  • Total voters
    314
Status
Not open for further replies.

ac6000cw

Established Member
Joined
10 May 2014
Messages
3,911
Location
Cambridge, UK
Do they even have internal doors? If so where and how many?
Automatic sliding doors at the ends of the cars.

During the pandemic GA locked them open, but I noticed that at least some were back in use last time I had a Day Ranger ride-around on various 755s and a 745. It make a big difference to the noise levels on a 755 running on diesel in the cars adjoining the power car.

But even with the internal doors open they still feel far less 'sitting in a corridor' than a 12-car 700...
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,910
Do they even have internal doors? If so where and how many?

Automatic sliding doors at the ends of the cars.

During the pandemic GA locked them open, but I noticed that at least some were back in use last time I had a Day Ranger ride-around on various 755s and a 745. It make a big difference to the noise levels on a 755 running on diesel in the cars adjoining the power car.

But even with the internal doors open they still feel far less 'sitting in a corridor' than a 12-car 700...
Yes I've noticed the doors in the 755s seem generally to be not locked open any more. I haven't yet been on a 745 where the doors haven't been locked open since COVID. @Rhydgaled the 755's have doors to partition the engine pod/thrash cabinet off from the saloons. The 745's have sliding doors at eve set of external doors, to partition the "vestibule" off from the rest of the saloon, makes for a cost travelling environment, quite nice and a pity they seem not to be in use.
 

Wolfie

Established Member
Joined
17 Aug 2010
Messages
7,429
It’s got to be alstom. The Pendolinos are brilliant trains and are one of the few trains that tilt in the country and are the best train the UK has had in the past 20 years
Ahem, 180s, 175s, 458s initially - all junk.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,859
Automatic sliding doors at the ends of the cars.

During the pandemic GA locked them open, but I noticed that at least some were back in use last time I had a Day Ranger ride-around on various 755s and a 745. It make a big difference to the noise levels on a 755 running on diesel in the cars adjoining the power car.
@Rhydgaled the 755's have doors to partition the engine pod/thrash cabinet off from the saloons. The 745's have sliding doors at eve set of external doors, to partition the "vestibule" off from the rest of the saloon, makes for a cost travelling environment, quite nice and a pity they seem not to be in use.
Thanks both, although you don't appear to have given the exact same answer. Perhaps this can be explained by differences between the 745s and 755s? You both mentioned the diesel engine, I think I can safely say that the diesel power module has doors to close it off at both ends (red lines on the drawing of the 755). However, I'm less clear about the connection between the other vehicles (yellow/orange on the 755 drawing) and around the vestibules (blue on the 755 drawing).


755 intdoors.png745 intdoors.png
Ahem, 180s, 175s, 458s initially - all junk.
Haven't the 458s, in both guises, also had spells as golden-spanner-winning super-reliable stock?
 

ac6000cw

Established Member
Joined
10 May 2014
Messages
3,911
Location
Cambridge, UK
Thanks both, although you don't appear to have given the exact same answer. Perhaps this can be explained by differences between the 745s and 755s? You both mentioned the diesel engine, I think I can safely say that the diesel power module has doors to close it off at both ends (red lines on the drawing of the 755). However, I'm less clear about the connection between the other vehicles (yellow/orange on the 755 drawing) and around the vestibules (blue on the 755 drawing).
Having watched a couple of 'walkthrough' videos on YouTube to check, I believe the situation with interior sliding doors is:

745 - fitted on either side of the exterior door vestibules. No doors between cars. (So only the red doors in your diagram)

755 - fitted on either side of the power car. No vestibule or other inter-car doors. (So only the red doors in your diagram)

(My memory of the door arrangements from riding the trains was obviously not very good :smile: )
 

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,910
Having watched a couple of 'walkthrough' videos on YouTube to check, I believe the situation with interior sliding doors is:

745 - fitted on either side of the exterior door vestibules. No doors between cars. (So only the red doors in your diagram)

755 - fitted on either side of the power car. No vestibule or other inter-car doors. (So only the red doors in your diagram)
Correct. Though as noted the 745 internal doors seem to be permanently locked open.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,859
Having watched a couple of 'walkthrough' videos on YouTube to check, I believe the situation with interior sliding doors is:

745 - fitted on either side of the exterior door vestibules. No doors between cars. (So only the red doors in your diagram)

755 - fitted on either side of the power car. No vestibule or other inter-car doors. (So only the red doors in your diagram)

(My memory of the door arrangements from riding the trains was obviously not very good :smile: )
Correct. Though as noted the 745 internal doors seem to be permanently locked open.
Thanks both. Not a particularly high-quality InterCity ambiance then, with the outside air able to flood directly into the passenger saloon at every stop, but in the case of the 745s (which I assumed had no internal doors at all) the original design was not nearly as bad as I thought if only the internal doors hadn't been locked open.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
113,568
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
Thanks both. Not a particularly high-quality InterCity ambiance then, with the outside air able to flood directly into the passenger saloon at every stop, but in the case of the 745s (which I assumed had no internal doors at all) the original design was not nearly as bad as I thought if only the internal doors hadn't been locked open.

755s are not InterCity trains. They are 153/156 replacements.

745s have doors either side of the vestibules. Sure the doors aren't at the ends, but the ambiance is similar to if they did.

The gangways are sealed so no leaks from there.

Have you been on one?
 

61653 HTAFC

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Dec 2012
Messages
19,354
Location
Yorkshire
Regarding the topic title 'Best UK Train Manufacturer' I'm not really sure there is a UK Manufacturer anymore
That's a good point. If we're taking ownership into account as well as location, perhaps there's a case for Boston Lodge works on the Ffestiniog to be considered the "Best UK (owned) Manufacturer... ;)
 

InkyScrolls

On Moderation
Joined
20 Jul 2022
Messages
1,459
Location
North of England
Aside from Boston Lodge (of course!) Siemens must surely be the obvious answer. Given the quality of the 333s, which were a Siemens/CAF joint venture, and other Siemens products around the country, I'm staggered Northern went with Cheap As F*** (CAF) over Siemens for their new trains; the 195s and 331s are tacky, unreliable and uncomfortable. Give me a 333 any day, and long may they last!
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
113,568
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
Aside from Boston Lodge (of course!) Siemens must surely be the obvious answer. Given the quality of the 333s, which were a Siemens/CAF joint venture, and other Siemens products around the country, I'm staggered Northern went with Cheap As F*** (CAF) over Siemens for their new trains; the 195s and 331s are tacky, unreliable and uncomfortable. Give me a 333 any day, and long may they last!

The 333s are CAF bodies and Siemens electrics I believe. I was quite surprised on my first ride that the 195 was nowhere near as spacious.

The answer of course lies in the "Cheap" bit.
 

43096

On Moderation
Joined
23 Nov 2015
Messages
18,848
The 333s are CAF bodies and Siemens electrics I believe. I was quite surprised on my first ride that the 195 was nowhere near as spacious.

The answer of course lies in the "Cheap" bit.
Importantly, the 333s had Siemens as the prime contractor with CAF as a sun-contractor.
 

Wolfie

Established Member
Joined
17 Aug 2010
Messages
7,429
Aside from Boston Lodge (of course!) Siemens must surely be the obvious answer. Given the quality of the 333s, which were a Siemens/CAF joint venture, and other Siemens products around the country, I'm staggered Northern went with Cheap As F*** (CAF) over Siemens for their new trains; the 195s and 331s are tacky, unreliable and uncomfortable. Give me a 333 any day, and long may they last!
You in part perhaps give the answer yourself - the 333s were a CAF joint venture with Siemens.... The 332s had serious corrosion issues and there have been rumblings about the 333s.
 

61653 HTAFC

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Dec 2012
Messages
19,354
Location
Yorkshire
Aside from Boston Lodge (of course!) Siemens must surely be the obvious answer. Given the quality of the 333s, which were a Siemens/CAF joint venture, and other Siemens products around the country, I'm staggered Northern went with Cheap As F*** (CAF) over Siemens for their new trains; the 195s and 331s are tacky, unreliable and uncomfortable. Give me a 333 any day, and long may they last!
As others have said, the "Cheap" part is the important bit. To be honest, the alternative name for CAF is becoming less funny by the day, and is up there with "ironing board seats" as a phrase guaranteed to raise an eye-roll. Remember that CAF aren't the only manufacturer to have suffered issues in recent years, those fancy expensive Hitach units have also had problems so it isn't simply a case of "buy cheap, buy twice"... and then there's Alstardier and the 701s, need I say more?

The CAF units I've used overseas didn't seem to have the issues that their most recent GB units have had (albeit that's a very small sample size), so it's probably (a) being built down to a price, and (b) a relative unfamiliarity with conditions on the GB network, that have caused some of the problems we've seen with the new Northern units.
 

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,910
755s are not InterCity trains. They are 153/156 replacements.

745s have doors either side of the vestibules. Sure the doors aren't at the ends, but the ambiance is similar to if they did.

The gangways are sealed so no leaks from there.

Have you been on one?
There's quite a wide glass partition at the exterior doors, and there's only one set per saloon so it's not a huge issue with temperature changes when the doors open.
It is a shame the 745 internal doors seem to be permanently locked out of use though.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,859
745s have doors either side of the vestibules. Sure the doors aren't at the ends, but the ambiance is similar to if they did.

The gangways are sealed so no leaks from there.

Have you been on one?
No, I've not been on either 745s or 755s, but I have been on some doors-at-thirds stock (170s and/or 185s I can't remember) which has internal doors around the gangways (which if applied to a 755 would be the yellow and red marks on the diagram of a 755 I posted above) which I assumed must be for noise reasons given that said stock clearly hasn't a care in the world about draughts given the lack of proper vestibules. Are the sealed gangways on a 745 different?

That's a good point. If we're taking ownership into account as well as location, perhaps there's a case for Boston Lodge works on the Ffestiniog to be considered the "Best UK (owned) Manufacturer... ;)
Good thinking. However, I wasn't so much talking about ownership as the actual content of the train: CAF and Hitachi only assemble units in the UK - I'm led to beleive that even Litchurch Lane builds stock using many overseas components.

As others have said, the "Cheap" part is the important bit. To be honest, the alternative name for CAF is becoming less funny by the day, and is up there with "ironing board seats" as a phrase guaranteed to raise an eye-roll. Remember that CAF aren't the only manufacturer to have suffered issues in recent years, those fancy expensive Hitach units have also had problems so it isn't simply a case of "buy cheap, buy twice"... and then there's Alstardier and the 701s, need I say more?

The CAF units I've used overseas didn't seem to have the issues that their most recent GB units have had (albeit that's a very small sample size), so it's probably (a) being built down to a price, and (b) a relative unfamiliarity with conditions on the GB network, that have caused some of the problems we've seen with the new Northern units.
Yes, the cheap part is the important bit - even the Hitachi 80x series have suffered from this (it was the contractual arrangements that were expensive; the specification of the trains was actually towards the budget end with cheap (and therefore hard and uncomfortable) seats, basic doors (not neater sliding plugs) and a load of short 5-car units).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top