• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Search results

  1. E

    "X for Y" - stations that should perhaps have another name added to them but don't have at present

    Wickham Market should be Campsea for Wickham Market, it's two miles from Wickham Market by road.
  2. E

    Rail replacement - will GBR enable a greater use of diversionary routes to avoid it?

    Theoretically I suppose with today's modern computer-equipped trains all that would need to be transmitted between trains would be a target acceleration/deceleration rate, with the train's computers then calculating what level of throttle/brake to apply to match it.
  3. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    Since I don't have the study to hand, I can't really give a conclusion about whether or not it was accurate or not.
  4. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    Your original post specifically mentioned the NRS social grades. Your quote in your reply, however, was about the NS-SEC classification system, which is different to the NRS system does. Also, as the government itself admits, within an NS-SEC grouping there can be much variation of income, nor...
  5. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    That's very vague, though. Subsidy can be reduced in a lot of ways, and a lot of those ways are clearly things that the government is unwilling to do, like engage in an extended fight with the unions over pay rises.
  6. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    I'm saying that it doesn't really say much about how much "the rich" vs. "the poor" use trains.
  7. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    The difference between NRS social grades ABC1 and C2DE is much more one of white-collar vs. blue-collar than anything directly reflecting income or wealth.
  8. E

    Electrifying Mainlines for Battery Train operation (using Class 897 as an example

    The sensible thing to do is plan based on the technology that exists today, not future technology that may or may not materialise.
  9. E

    (Fantasy) A through-running commuter rail tunnel for Birmingham

    I don't think anyone is arguing that economic growth is down to just one factor. The question is whether Glasgow is richer or poorer than it would be without its rail network. If you want to reduce rail subsidy, then more density around stations is an excellent way to do so.
  10. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    I am sure you will agree that businesses are not charities. If government investment is concentrated in London, then the rational financial choice will be for people and businesses to move to London. Relying on them to stick in the North out of charity is not a viable means of addressing...
  11. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    The opposite to this argument, which I have no doubt many of the general public will make, is "there's no point in the railways being well maintained if I can't afford to ride them".
  12. E

    What does the term "no brainer" mean in the context of ideas for reopenings etc?

    But my point wasn't that the precise method of reducing diesel running under wires was a no brainer, it was that the end goal is desirable and the various methods of achieving that goal should be investigated to see what is best. We shouldn't use "there are multiple different ways of achieving...
  13. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    Well the question then becomes "is the North equal to the Southeast in terms of passengers per station per homes/jobs within X distance of the station?".
  14. E

    Last trains to be put into a non-GBR livery, and hence/also the last trains to be put into the GBR livery?

    ...but that doesn't mean it won't get GBR livery. After all, it doesn't have a special "Night Riviera" livery at the moment!
  15. E

    What does the term "no brainer" mean in the context of ideas for reopenings etc?

    I wouldn't say a "no brainer" means "there is absolutely nothing preventing it from happening". But eliminating diesel running under wires seems a fairly obvious objective to work towards as an ultimate goal.
  16. E

    Last trains to be put into a non-GBR livery, and hence/also the last trains to be put into the GBR livery?

    The Night Riviera is prestige enough to get it, in my opinion. It's the Sprinters where them ever receiving GBR livery is doubtful.
  17. E

    What does the term "no brainer" mean in the context of ideas for reopenings etc?

    Well, you also have to take into account that building anything in the UK takes too long and costs too much. If the railway could get things done quicker and for less money, a lot more projects would become viable...
  18. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    If the railway really is offering those outside London a better deal as you seem to be claiming then it is best advised to prominently advertise that fact, considering the public perception of the railways is that they are heavily London-biased and provide a much better and more value-for-money...
  19. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    I am not sure you can so easily split "marketing tool" and "social benefit" like that. Just because something pays for itself doesn't mean it isn't a benefit, and furthermore just because something pays for itself in area A does not mean subsidies to introduce it into area B are unjustified - if...
  20. E

    The cost of living agenda - how should the railway contribute ?

    But this is the "rich get richer" issue that those wanting a national railcard want to address, where the South East gets more money because it gets more passengers relative to its population, and it gets more passengers because it gets more money.

Top