• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Lochaber narrow gauge railway : did it reach Loch Laggan ?

Justin Smith

Established Member
Joined
14 Nov 2009
Messages
1,442
Location
Sheffield
I have added most of the Lochaber Narrow Gauge railway to my Cobbs historical atlas but did the top section (from Loch Treig to Loch Laggan) ever exist ? The Wiki page is unclear if it did or not and it is not on any of the OS one inch maps I can find online, though the bottom section from Loch Trieg to Fort William is on the one inch OS maps, plus the course of the railway is also on the up to date 50,000 series as "dismantled tramway".
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Albaman

Member
Joined
16 Sep 2018
Messages
135
I have added most of the Lochaber Narrow Gauge railway to my Cobbs historical atlas but did the top section (from Loch Treig to Loch Laggan) ever exist ? The Wiki page is unclear if it did or not and it is not on any of the OS one inch maps I can find online, though the bottom section from Loch Trieg to Fort William is on the one inch OS maps, plus the course of the railway is also on the up to date 50,000 series as "dismantled tramway".

The publication " The Puggy Line " by Patrick Howat may assist you in your enquiry.
 

Justin Smith

Established Member
Joined
14 Nov 2009
Messages
1,442
Location
Sheffield

Justin Smith

Established Member
Joined
14 Nov 2009
Messages
1,442
Location
Sheffield
What should we be looking at on this side-by-side map?
On the left hand map (Bartholomew Half Inch 1947-47) look at the north end of Loch Treig, and you'll see the track of the branch to Loch Laggan.
The map also has the course of the under ground aqueduct taking the water down the hill to power the Lochaber hydroelectric scheme.
 

izvor

Member
Joined
11 Jun 2014
Messages
602
Location
on the SER
In the meantime I have confirmed the branch from Loch Treig to Loch Laggan did exist and found a map of the route (on the exceptionally useful National Library of Scotland page)
Bartholomew were rather in the habit of showing planned railways as open, and although I would think it unlikely in this case, I wouldn't like to use a Barts map as definitive historical evidence, especially if no Ordnance Survey map can be found to show it.
 

Justin Smith

Established Member
Joined
14 Nov 2009
Messages
1,442
Location
Sheffield
Bartholomew were rather in the habit of showing planned railways as open, and although I would think it unlikely in this case, I wouldn't like to use a Barts map as definitive historical evidence, especially if no Ordnance Survey map can be found to show it.
In the time I have to spend on it I could not find the OS map of the period (if anyone does find it please link to it for us ! ), but the route is more or less where the Wiki article [which is largely based, it seems, on the book the Albaman mentioned above] said it ran.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

There is an article on the Lochaber Railway in Railway Magazine Apr 1955 (p241 on) which states the line from Loch Treig to Loch Laggan was built in 1931 for the construction of a tunnel down from Loch Laggan to Loch Treig. This implies it did not last long after that ?
The RWM article on the original construction of this section is in the Jul 1931 edition (p73).
 
Last edited:

DelW

Established Member
Joined
15 Jan 2015
Messages
6,054
There is an article on the Lochaber Railway in Railway Magazine Apr 1955 (p241 on) which states the line from Loch Treig to Loch Laggan was built in 1931 for the construction of a tunnel down from Loch Laggan to Loch Treig. This implies it did not last long after that ?
The RWM article on the original construction of this section is in the Jul 1931 edition (p73).
In that era it would have been quite common for civil engineering contractors to use temporary narrow gauge railways for moving materials to a site, and within a site, particularly in remote areas with little or no road access. A longer and earlier example (though standard gauge) is the fairly well known line to Talla reservoir in the Scottish lowlands:
The Talla Railway was a privately constructed railway line in southern Scotland under the Edinburgh Water Company. It was built 1895–97 to aid the construction of the Talla Reservoir, to serve the water demand of Edinburgh. The railway was about eight miles (13 km) long, running south from a connection with the Caledonian Railway's Peebles branch at Broughton. A private passenger service was operated for workmen on the reservoir construction.
It's also quite possible that there would have been temporary track laid within the tunnel for construction purposes. In the mid 1970s I worked on construction of a dam which incorporated a tunnel, and we had temporary 2' gauge track (in panels aka Jubilee track) laid through it, with wagons hauled by small battery electric locos. My then employer owned the equipment, which had been used on a number of previous contracts, although I think that was probably its last.

So the contractor(s) for the Laggan dam and tunnel would probably have been very familiar with temporary railways, and might well have had the necessary equipment available already.
 

Top