• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

TfW withdrawals (Now just 150/158s to go)

Jez

Established Member
Joined
22 Jan 2011
Messages
2,311
Location
Neath
Looks like the unit that sits in Swansea from the morning until 1627 will remain a 150 as well as one of the Ebbw Vales/Newports.

I think a couple of other 197s are being replaced withSprinters in the South? Will these be Maesteg or Cheltenham to avoid taking 197s off the Marches?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Mag_seven

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Global Moderator
Joined
1 Sep 2014
Messages
11,934
Location
here to eternity
Just a gentle reminder that this thread is for tracking withdrawals not for the discussion of allocations. Thanks :)
 

BenBracken

Member
Joined
27 Oct 2019
Messages
169
Location
Pembrokeshire
All but 1 197s are in service now. 398 rollout starts in the summer. All 231s and 756s in service. So time is ticking now on the 150s and 158s?
 

Russel

Established Member
Joined
30 Jun 2022
Messages
5,383
Location
Lichfield
Given the rumours around TFW wanting to order more 197s, how realistic do we think it is that all of the 158s will go?
 

positron

Member
Joined
18 Oct 2022
Messages
660
Location
Cardiff
Given the rumours around TFW wanting to order more 197s, how realistic do we think it is that all of the 158s will go?
Depends if anyone else has a use for them. If there's no big desire to get them back by the TOC then they might extend the lease at least. Have *any* 158s gone yet? Or is it all just 175s, 150s and 153s?
 

158822

Member
Joined
5 Apr 2025
Messages
81
Location
UK
All 158s are still with TfW and are needed for the Cambrian apart from the two units out of service since Talerddig. If 197s do enter service there in September which they apparently will there would be nowhere else to keep the 158s anyway. Machynlleth would not have room to maintain two fleets and nowhere else is suitable. Seems more likely that TfW will just extend leases on the not active travel 153s and use them in the south. If they did need to keep 158s longer then it seems likely they would just further delay Cambrian 197 introduction instead of moving fleets around.
 

Cardiff123

Established Member
Joined
10 Mar 2013
Messages
1,644
Location
South Wales
All but 1 197s are in service now. 398 rollout starts in the summer. All 231s and 756s in service. So time is ticking now on the 150s and 158s?
Any supposed rollout date for the 398s needs to be taken with several buckets of salt. In February, the rollout date was "later this spring". As I predicted at the time, that has now changed to "later this summer"..........
 

Caaardiff

Established Member
Joined
9 Jun 2019
Messages
1,371
Machynlleth would not have room to maintain two fleets and nowhere else is suitable. Seems more likely that TfW will just extend leases on the not active travel 153s and use them in the south. If they did need to keep 158s longer then it seems likely they would just further delay Cambrian 197 introduction instead of moving fleets around.
Canton maintain 158s. If/when 150's go they could cover a number of routes in the South.
It's likely the 158's will go to another TOC though.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,856
Depends if anyone else has a use for them. If there's no big desire to get them back by the TOC then they might extend the lease at least. Have *any* 158s gone yet? Or is it all just 175s, 150s and 153s?
Not just those classes are going/gone; TfW have of course also withdrawn their mark 2 & mark 3 coaches, 170s, 769s, 143s and 142s. Also, I've been led to believe that the two 158s damaged in the collision 2 years ago won't be coming back.

Canton maintain 158s. If/when 150's go they could cover a number of routes in the South.
It's likely the 158's will go to another TOC though.
Isn't some 158 maintenance also done at Crewe? If so, would Crewe and Canton between them be able to take over the 158s entirely when the 197s move into Machynlleth, or do they have similar lack of capacity for more units to CAF at Chester and TfW at Machynlleth?
 

tfw756rider

On Moderation
Joined
30 Nov 2024
Messages
1,935
Location
Wales (sometimes in England), thanks for replying!
Isn't some 158 maintenance also done at Crewe? If so, would Crewe and Canton between them be able to take over the 158s entirely when the 197s move into Machynlleth, or do they have similar lack of capacity for more units to CAF at Chester and TfW at Machynlleth?
Machynlleth depot can only hold about 10 units. Though all 22 (previously 24) Transport for Wales 158s are allocated to Machynlleth as their home depot, more than half of them at a time are stabled at the other stabling locations. This will of course continue with the 21 197/0e units.
 

Robin Edwards

Member
Joined
1 Dec 2013
Messages
680
Machynlleth depot can only hold about 10 units. Though all 22 (previously 24) Transport for Wales 158s are allocated to Machynlleth as their home depot, more than half of them at a time are stabled at the other stabling locations. This will of course continue with the 21 197/0e units.

Are there any regular workings that bring MNs 158's south to Cardiff? I spent a few days last week centred around Cardiff and only saw one pair of TfW 158s
 

Caaardiff

Established Member
Joined
9 Jun 2019
Messages
1,371
Machynlleth depot can only hold about 10 units. Though all 22 (previously 24) Transport for Wales 158s are allocated to Machynlleth as their home depot, more than half of them at a time are stabled at the other stabling locations. This will of course continue with the 21 197/0e units.
I think the point that was being made is keeping the 158s as additional units. So any stabling used for 197e are replacing the 158s. Any kept 158s are additional spaces required across the network.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

Are there any regular workings that bring MNs 158's south to Cardiff? I spent a few days last week centred around Cardiff and only saw one pair of TfW 158s
None. They occasionally come to Canton for heavy maintenance but eventually find their way back North
 

Jez

Established Member
Joined
22 Jan 2011
Messages
2,311
Location
Neath
The 158s normally appear on random services when they come to South Wales - usually a service from Holyhead/Chester.

I am hoping they will be around a bit longer as id like to ride one before they go. At one time my favourite units.
 

Armchair Bob

Member
Joined
28 Oct 2021
Messages
61
Location
Glamorgan
The 158s normally appear on random services when they come to South Wales - usually a service from Holyhead/Chester.

I am hoping they will be around a bit longer as id like to ride one before they go. At one time my favourite units.
According to post #1759, they will be around until at least April 2029.

All the 30 class 153s will also be staying for the foreseeable future, the ones stored at Landore are gradually being returned to service. As it currently stands, only 312, 329, 921, 922 and 926 are yet to be reinstated.
 

Robin Edwards

Member
Joined
1 Dec 2013
Messages
680
Do we still have 19 150s or is it fewer now?
From 8-12th June I recorded :

4 stored/withdrawn at Landore TMD 150217/241/254/257 1 was identified passing Canton TMD 150283

Working were 150208/242/245/251/252/256/259/260/262/264/267/278/279/280/282/284 (16) I wasn't able to track down 150285
 

47444

Member
Joined
10 Aug 2019
Messages
308
From 8-12th June I recorded :

4 stored/withdrawn at Landore TMD 150217/241/254/257 1 was identified passing Canton TMD 150283

Working were 150208/242/245/251/252/256/259/260/262/264/267/278/279/280/282/284 (16) I wasn't able to track down 150285
I think this leaves the following unaccounted for:
150213, 52235 from 150235, 150250 and 150255 all of which were last recorded on this thread as at Landore (I think!).

Have they all been disposed of, and if so where?

Thanks
 

Robin Edwards

Member
Joined
1 Dec 2013
Messages
680
I think this leaves the following unaccounted for:
150213, 52235 from 150235, 150250 and 150255 all of which were last recorded on this thread as at Landore (I think!).

Have they all been disposed of, and if so where?

Thanks
Those four have all been disposed of at Unimetals, Newport. 150213 9/25, 150235 & 150255 10/25 and 150250 at an unknown date in 2025
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,856
Machynlleth depot can only hold about 10 units. Though all 22 (previously 24) Transport for Wales 158s are allocated to Machynlleth as their home depot, more than half of them at a time are stabled at the other stabling locations. This will of course continue with the 21 197/0e units.
I think the point that was being made is keeping the 158s as additional units. So any stabling used for 197e are replacing the 158s. Any kept 158s are additional spaces required across the network.
Yes; although my question is specifically about actually maintaining the fleet (ie. not just overnight stabling in places like Pwllheli, where I assume repairs/exams/overhauls would not normally take place). TfW's fleet appears to be stretched rather thin, even without their proposed future Bristol services etc. it's been reported that many (if not all) the planned summer 4-car workings on the Cambrian Coast have been short-formed. They clearly need a larger fleet, but at the same time I've read on this forum that Machynlleth wouldn't realistically be big enough to keep both the 22x class 158s and the 21x ETCS-fitted class 197s (a total of 43 units!) in good working order, and Chester (built for the much-smaller class 175 fleet) wouldn't be able to take on all 77 class 197s by itself.

Hence my question of how much of the class 158 maintenance is currently done away from Machynlleth and whether any of the other depots currently involved have the capacity to take on more of that work? This question would equally apply to any inward cascades of other classes from other TOCs (if anything was available, which seems very unlikely).

According to post #1759, they will be around until at least April 2029.
As far as I know, class 197s are still expected to enter passenger service under ETCS on the Cambrian lines in September 2026. Unless the depots involved have the capacity to maintain both fleets, I fear that 'April 2029' date is more-likely to refer to a period of hand-back work somewhere like Landore than significant TfW passenger use for the class 158s in 2027 and 2028.
 

Caaardiff

Established Member
Joined
9 Jun 2019
Messages
1,371
Yes; although my question is specifically about actually maintaining the fleet (ie. not just overnight stabling in places like Pwllheli, where I assume repairs/exams/overhauls would not normally take place). TfW's fleet appears to be stretched rather thin, even without their proposed future Bristol services etc. it's been reported that many (if not all) the planned summer 4-car workings on the Cambrian Coast have been short-formed. They clearly need a larger fleet, but at the same time I've read on this forum that Machynlleth wouldn't realistically be big enough to keep both the 22x class 158s and the 21x ETCS-fitted class 197s (a total of 43 units!) in good working order, and Chester (built for the much-smaller class 175 fleet) wouldn't be able to take on all 77 class 197s by itself.
The Cambrian is moving to 197s. There will not be mixed fleet usage on that line. So Machynlleth Depot is out if the equation for 158s.
They've maintained 24 158s for some time. So there is scope for 3 more ETCS 197s to match the 158 throughput. The sheds at Mach can accommodate 2 cars only over 2 roads. A 3 car would be too long.
Bigger 158 maintenance is done at Canton and sometimes DB Crewe but is more ad-hoc and not regular maintenance. The big C exams are done are Bristol and Pullmans currently. In the same way CAF will do the ETCS bigger maintenance.

IF 158s stay, Canton is busy enough as it is. They could manage some but unlikely all. Options would be outsourcing at Landore or Crewe.
This question would equally apply to any inward cascades of other classes from other TOCs (if anything was available, which seems very unlikely).
Do you mean taking on other fleets handed down from other TOCs? Why would TFW do that when they've just about replaced most of their fleet? They want to standardise, not add more types.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,856
The Cambrian is moving to 197s. There will not be mixed fleet usage on that line. So Machynlleth Depot is out if the equation for 158s.
They've maintained 24 158s for some time. So there is scope for 3 more ETCS 197s to match the 158 throughput. The sheds at Mach can accommodate 2 cars only over 2 roads. A 3 car would be too long.
Bigger 158 maintenance is done at Canton and sometimes DB Crewe but is more ad-hoc and not regular maintenance. The big C exams are done are Bristol and Pullmans currently. In the same way CAF will do the ETCS bigger maintenance.

IF 158s stay, Canton is busy enough as it is. They could manage some but unlikely all. Options would be outsourcing at Landore or Crewe.
Yes, that's pretty much my understanding from what I've read on this forum (I'm not railway staff so this forum is my main source of info). Thus, I'm wondering if the 158 work that is currently done at Machynlleth could move to Crewe when the 197s take over at Machynlleth. With regard to Crewe, I seem to recall that there are (or was) at least two depots, once known as 'Crewe Electric' and another as 'Crewe Diesel'; is 'DB Crewe' an umbrella term covering both, or is just that's the only one that TfW make any use of?

Do you mean taking on other fleets handed down from other TOCs.
Yes. I'd better leave it there now since this isn't the speculative section.
 

craigybagel

Established Member
Joined
25 Oct 2012
Messages
5,820
With regard to Crewe, I seem to recall that there are (or was) at least two depots, once known as 'Crewe Electric' and another as 'Crewe Diesel'; is 'DB Crewe' an umbrella term covering both, or is just that's the only one that TfW make any use of?

Yes. I'd better leave it there now since this isn't the speculative section.

DB Crewe is Crewe Electric (or Crewe ETD in full). It is where most heavy maintenance on the 67s takes place, plus it has a wheel lathe regularly visited by MKIVs, 197s and Sprinters.

The depot traditionally known as the diesel depot is on the site currently occupied by LSL.

Arriva Train Care is based at the former Crewe Carriage Sidings. It is used by TfW for stabling and lighter maintenance on trains that overnight in Crewe, and also as a maintenance base for the MKIVs. It is of course also visited by trains from numerous other TOCs, both for stabling and heavy maintenance.
 
Last edited:

Wyrleybart

Established Member
Joined
29 Mar 2020
Messages
2,599
Location
South Staffordshire
Arriva Train Care is based at the former Crewe Carriage Sidings. It is used by TfW for stabling and lighter maintenance on trains that overnight in Crewe, and also as a maintenance base for the MKIVs. It is of course also visited by trains from numerous other TOCs, both for stabling and heavy maintenance.
Agree Craigy. In fact 170s occasionally visit from XC, Northern and Scotrail; too IIRC for big exams.
 

Anonymous10

Established Member
Joined
19 Dec 2019
Messages
2,629
Location
wales
Hi all, seen some posts about a set of 153s being sent back to landore. Will this be the end for that pair or could they come back again?
 

Top