• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Recent content by MarlowDonkey

  1. M

    Potential Fare Evading - HELP!

    Doughnutting and short ticketing are the same thing really, short ticketing being where one of the stations doesn't have barriers. What you seem to admit to in your original post is repay fraud as you say that you were able to exit the station without the ticket being scanned and thus you could...
  2. M

    Senior Railcard validity: getting a definitive answer

    That's the historic division where the Waterloo to Exeter St Davids service was operated by Network South East and so the rules of the Network South East railcard were applied at the stations between them.
  3. M

    SWR short fare

    I don't think there have been any documented cases involving SWR, but if the debt of unpaid fares was large enough, might they contemplate a civil action for recovery? They could assert balance of probability that the person buying the suspect tickets was actually using them as well,
  4. M

    Do any DOO drivers still use screens on the platform to dispatch?

    There are mirrors too on the Maidenhead to Marlow branch although not at Marlow. There's always two crew members running to Marlow. The Guard used to inspect tickets, but perhaps not any more as Marlow now has a ticket machine, a contactless reader and penalty fare notices. The branch is still...
  5. M

    SWR short fare

    I think the point is that they have evidence as to who bought the tickets, but in the absence of stopping someone, no evidence as to who used them, unless you provide it.
  6. M

    My son has just received a fine to be paid in full of £3115 in 14 days.

    The OP needs to load the content of the notice with identification redacted. It isn't a fine unless issued by a Court.
  7. M

    prosecution threat after not presenting a railcard due to app not working

    What is the relevance of the purchase date and time? If they are told the expiry date and that it was in date when it should have been inspected, the purchase date would have been approximately either one year or three years earlier.
  8. M

    GWR Settlement Offer £256.15 after interview under caution - advice please

    Almost all trains from the main line Paddington station are first stop at least Slough, so outside the scope of Oyster. I suppose Elizabeth Line trains do still use it from time to time, so the gates would have to accept Oyster.
  9. M

    GWR Settlement Offer £256.15 after interview under caution - advice please

    One must suppose that the train left from one of the open platforms at Paddington and there was no inspection on the train.
  10. M

    HS2 Old Oak Common

    One difference is that the money to pay for the work is being rationed by year. The other is that they aren't trying to build it across a busy operational railway.
  11. M

    HS2 should stop at more stations in the Chilterns

    What are in essence commuter services to Kent run on HS1 to Ashford and then continue on the existing lines. Nothing similar was ever designed or proposed for HS2. If the interchange was where it crosses EWR, would a direct Old Oak Common service to Oxford via HS1 be faster than via Reading?
  12. M

    Disparity in Oyster vs Contactless inspections

    Oyster is only valid as far as West Drayton, so anyone west of there would be using Contactless if they weren't using traditional tickets or buying on a phone. It's not just the main line, but also the three branches to Windsor, Marlow and Henley.
  13. M

    Advice on west midland railway fine

    I think the OP wasn't buying any tickets at all, so would always be caught if there's a ticket inspection. Presumably there were no gates at either end of the journey.
  14. M

    Advice on west midland railway fine

    Did you mean a penalty fare as fines are only issued by courts of law following a successful prosecution? If you buy tickets on your phone using Trainline or similar, that's fairly easy for them to track down. Failure to pay the penalty fare can result in prosecution in your absence and a...
  15. M

    Collective competition claim against Govia Thameslink Railway

    It doesn't seem to have been followed through to Euston in particular, but at one time there was a principle introduced of having just one ToC per London main line station. That helped force the merger of Thames Trains with First Great Western out of Paddington removing a split that had existed...

Top